As noted recently, PETA isn't giving up
in its quixotic quest to argue that it can represent the interests of an Indonesian selfie-taking monkey, and further that the photos in question have a copyright and that copyright belongs to the monkey (and, by extension, PETA). UK IP professor Andrés Guadamuz recently wrote an interesting paper arguing that there is a copyright in the photograph
and it belongs to the guy who owned the camera, David Slater, based on UK copyright law. It's an interesting read, though others have convincingly argued the opposite
, noting that UK law requires a "person" to have created the work.
Either way, it seems this question may not be going away any time soon. Guadamuz has now also posted an amusing blog post highlighting the next potential battleground: a cat who loves to take selfies
. I mean, just look at them
. While there are some clearer shots, I think this one is clearly the best, based entirely on the cat's "I'm concentrating here" tongue:
Guadamuz notes that it's not entirely clear how much control the cat really has in these pictures, and they may really be the camera owner holding the camera itself, and snapping the photo when the cat is incentivized to reach in. In that case, there's a stronger copyright claim for the original camera owner -- an Instagram user by the username "youremahm"
. But, as Guadamuz notes, the real question is whether or not PETA will now sue on behalf of the cat.