PETA Has Lost Its Monkey's 'Next Friend' In Its Crazy Copyright Case

from the the-monkey's-uncle-is-missing dept

The ongoing saga that is the monkey selfie lawsuit has continued to move forward, with the lawyers for photographer David Slater filing their brief in response to PETA’s. As you probably recall, PETA had teamed up with a primatologist named Antje Engelhardt claiming to be “next friends” for the Indonesian macaque monkey named Naruto, who is alleged to have taken the following selfie with David Slater’s camera.

Slater has claimed to hold the copyright on the photo for a long time, though he’s wrong. But PETA is much more wrong in arguing that it can step in and claim both (a) that there is a copyright on the image and (b) that the monkey holds it. Slater is just wrong about the copyright existing.

Either way, the PETA case was easily tossed out of the district court based on the fact that monkeys can’t get copyrights under US law (US laws don’t apply to animals unless specifically stated — this is why farms aren’t legally considered murder camps, no matter what some vegetarians might say). And, of course, PETA appealed. And we expect it will go about as well as the district court case. But it may go even worse.

That’s because in the reply, Slater’s lawyer points out that not only can a monkey not hold a copyright, but also that PETA has even less standing than before, because the primatologist, Antje Engelhardt, has decided she’s no longer a next friend of our buddy Naruto, the smiling monkey.

On appeal, the crazy got crazier. Dr. Engelhardt withdrew from the case. That leaves PETA, which does not allege any relationship with the monkey, as the monkey?s sole next friend.


Two putative next friends filed this action: PETA and Dr. Engelhardt, a primatologist who alleged that she has ?known, monitored, and studied Naruto since his birth.? ER 23. It may well be that the relationship with Naruto Dr. Engelhardt alleged is ?significant? under Coalition of Clergy v. Bush. However, Dr. Engelhardt moved to withdraw from the case, informing the Court that she ?will not continue as a next friend to Appellant in this proceeding.? This Court granted Dr. Engelhardt?s motion, thus leaving PETA as Naruto?s lone putative next friend.

This is a fairly big problem for PETA and its big time (seriously) lawyers from the (previously respectable) law firm of Irell & Manella.

Unlike Dr. Engelhardt, PETA did not allege any relationship with Naruto, much less a significant one. That is a problem on appeal. PETA is now in a position very much like the ballot initiative defenders in Hollingsworth v. Perry, 133 S. Ct. 2652 (2013): a party necessary for standing at the district court is not participating in the appeal. ?[S]tanding must be met by persons seeking appellate review, just as it must be met by persons appearing in courts of first instance.? Id. at 2661 (internal quotation marks and citation omitted).

All of the Naruto relationship allegations in the Complaint concern Dr. Engelhardt; none involve PETA…. PETA alleges no connection to Naruto, an Indonesian monkey who lives roughly 10,000 miles from PETA?s headquarters in Virginia.

In other words, even if Engelhardt had standing, PETA doesn’t.

The filing also contains its fair share of monkey jokes, so we’ll just end this post with a few of those:

Under controlling Ninth Circuit precedent, monkey see, monkey sue is not good law under any Act of Congress unless the legislative text plainly grants non-human animals standing to sue.


The only pertinent fact in this case is that Naruto is a monkey suing for copyright infringement.

Either way, one hopes that the court makes quick work of this case as well, but it is 9th Circuit, which perhaps deserves copyright on its… creative interpretations of copyright law at times. Hopefully this isn’t one of those cases.

Filed Under: , , , , , , ,
Companies: irell & manella, peta

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “PETA Has Lost Its Monkey's 'Next Friend' In Its Crazy Copyright Case”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Anonymous Coward says:

Re: At least the monkey is happy

Why is everyone assuming the monkey took a picture. It’s obvious that it thought the camera was a mirror and it’s checking for spinage caught in it’s teeth before chatting up the lovely lady monkey. Look at those raised eyebrows and the suave expression! The name is Bond. Monkey Bond.

Roger Strong (profile) says:

Re: Re:


Trump will soon need yet another set of campaign managers and advisors who can fling feces without claiming that Obama invaded Afghanistan. Someone who won’t try to explain Trump’s flip-flops with “He hasn’t changed his position on immigration, he has changed the ‘words’ that he is saying.”

Unable to speak at all while still being able to shout down others on a cable news panel, Naruto would be the ideal candidate. Naruto has the special combination of publicity and legal experience that Trump needs.

Anonymous Coward says:

This is a disaster for human culture! Since, after all, we are all descended from monkeys, ergo, all precedents applying to any other primates must also, ipso facto, apply to professional stock photographers. If this picture is not afforded the strongest protection of the most draconian law–and all unlicenced references to it prosecuted as terrorist acts by the FBI, the NSA, and the Galactic Patrol–civilization as we know it will end, and rodents will take over the earth.

Indeed, some say this has already happened.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...