The Best Summary Of Australia's News Link Tax / 'Bargaining Code'
from the the-loser,-as-always,-is-you dept
I’ve been somewhat amazed at the response to Facebook’s decision in Australia to first block news links, in response to a dangerous new law, and then to cave in and cut deals with news organizations to pay for links. Most amazing to me is that otherwise reasonable people in Australia got very angry at me, insisting that I was misrepresenting the tax. They keep insisting it’s not a tax, and that it’s a “competition” response to “unfair bargaining power.” Except, as I’ve discussed previously, there’s nothing to bargain over when you should never have to pay for links. The links are free. There’s no bargaining imbalance, because there’s nothing to bargain over. And, it’s clearly a tax if the only end result is that Google and Facebook have to fork over money because the government tells them to. That’s… a tax.
Anyway, that’s why I’m happy to see The Juice Media, an Australian outfit that is famous for making hilarious “Honest Government Ads”, usually for the Australian government (but sometimes for elsewhere) has put out a new “ad” about the link tax in which they explain how it was a fight to take money from one set of giant rich companies, and give it to another set of giant rich companies, and not to do anything useful in between:
It’s worth watching. It also highlights some of the other awful aspects of the “code” which will give news organizations more access to data, as well as advance notice of algorithmic changes that no one else gets — allowing them to better hijack attention away from anyone else. The whole deal is dangerous and corrupt, and no one should be supporting it.