DHS Appears Willing To Violate Whistleblower Laws To Shut Down Leaks

from the STOP-LEAKING,-the-leaked-memo-stated dept

This Administration — like the one before it — isn’t a fan of leaks or whistleblowing. This Administration seems to be leakier than most, possibly due to the Commander-in-Chief’s vindictive shit-canning of anyone insufficiently deferential. When distrust abounds, the leaks will flow.

The Administration would like these leaks to stop. To accomplish this, it has tried several things — most of them legally-questionable. During his stint at the DOJ, Jeff Sessions suggested subjecting every National Security Council staffer to a polygraph test to sniff out who had leaked transcripts of Oval Office phone calls. The State Department issued a memo warning its employees about the dangers of leaking, including the possibility of prosecution. The memo against leaks was promptly leaked. The DHS has decided to focus its attention on exterior “threats:” namely, journalists who publish leaks. The First Amendment is apparently secondary to leak stoppage.

The DHS is still struggling with leaks. And it’s struggling to contain its struggles with leaks. Earlier this month, a memo demanding employees report leaks, leakers, and anything else they might think is suspicious was leaked to journalists.

Randolph D. “Tex” Alles, a senior DHS official, emailed all employees on Tuesday warning them to be careful handling “all classified, controlled unclassified, and draft information” and that unauthorized disclosures — whether deliberate or inadvertent — risked violating agency policy and potentially federal law. Alles sent the email after “sensitive but unclassified” information had been shared with “external entities.”

Reporter Ken Klippenstein also received a copy of the leaked memo. His “copy” was two screenshots apparently taken by a DHS employee.

So far, we have a leaky DHS, an attempt to plug leaks, yet another leak, and, two weeks later, claims the leaked anti-leak memo is actually illegal. Citing Klippenstein’s October 13 tweet, the American Federation of Government Employees (the largest federal employee labor union) says the memo issued by DHS Under Secretary Randolph Alles violates the law.

We are writing to seek your reconsideration of a recent directive that illegally stifles guaranteed whistleblower rights of its employees. (Exhibit A) This action is a crude violation of the Whistleblower Protection Act and appropriations provisions that shield DHS employees’ free speech rights and must be remedied immediately.

Exhibit A is Klippenstein’s tweet. The letter also refers to Buzzfeed’s reporting on the same memo from Alles.

DHS officials are apparently willing to violate the law to shut down leaks. That’s why the agency’s targeting of journalists wasn’t shut down while it was still just a bad idea. I doubt the DHS will rescind this memo without a court order or Congressional investigation, but it’s safe to say threatening to violate the law isn’t going to do much to deter future leaks or whistleblowing. The DHS’s problems with leaks will continue.

Filed Under: , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “DHS Appears Willing To Violate Whistleblower Laws To Shut Down Leaks”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
18 Comments
That One Guy (profile) says:

Hard to air someone's dirty laundry if they don't have any

The best part is if they really wanted to stop the leaking of damning evidence the solution is really simple: Stop doing questionable if not outright illegal stuff that people feel needs to be made public.

If they simply stopped engaging in behavior that made any ethical people who haven’t been purged from the government yet think that the public should really know what the government that is supposedly representing them is doing then the leaks would dry right up, with anything left being harmless stuff likely to make the leaker look worse than the government, but since that would require them to stop being so openly corrupt I suppose the next best thing is to keep trying to plug that dam.

ECA (profile) says:

Wouldnt it be nice

If the Gov. actually TALKED to the people.
Told us what they wanted to do, and how.
Asked our opinion.
Listened to us(hard as hell when we all have diff opinions)

I would love a decent questionnaire, to ASK us what we wanted. Not what Trump wants, NOT the repubs or the Demo.
But they arnt listening.
The know Less about this country then we do.

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: Obama

That’s one of the two things I do hold against Obama – not closing Gitmo, and worse persecution of whistleblowers than even the Bush administration which preceded him.
That said, he was leagues better than this overgrown oompa-loompa, but he was by no means perfect, no politician is, and when they fail, we need, we must, excoriate them for it – to do any less is to fail in our own civic duty.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Scary Devil Monastery (profile) says:

Re: Re: Re: Obama

"That’s one of the two things I do hold against Obama…"

Plenty more, honestly. Obama tried to do a lot of good and talked a good game but in the balance of it he was just a typical "talk big, do little" president. With almost as many war crimes to his name as GWB.

Ironically he fought tooth and claw for the "affordable care act" which although it may have come to be called "Obamacare" was originally a republican suggestion.
It should have told everyone what the GOP of the day stood for when they opposed their own damn bill when that bill was launched by a Democrat president…

Scary Devil Monastery (profile) says:

Re: Re:

"It would be so much easier to empathize if it wasn’t for the perverse about of rationalization when Hope n’ Change violated whistleblower laws…"

And right on cue comes the alt-right to make the case that The second offender in the gang rape proves there’s nothing really wrong to do what the first offender did.

Here’s a clue. When your only argument is it’s not wrong if someone else did it first then that’s proof positive the action you try to defend isn’t defensible.

After all, in the logic you people keep trying to apply, since Hitler and Staling engaged in genocide there’s surely no moral barrier to repeating it.

ECA (profile) says:

I hate Pandora.

The story has been explained in more then 1 way.
That She released everything in the box Except ‘Hope’.
But did she get rid of all the Other crap to GO away, or to FIll the world with all the crap we dont want.
Either hope is locked up and we cant get it,
Or its the only thing we got left.

Im tired of believing HOPE, is all we got. Think its time to Show those responsible that it ISNT enough.

Bartonxwk (user link) says:

dating asian brides

Los Angeles Times coupon codes and reductions in price for January 2022

Los Angeles Times Coupon Codes save. By using our platform to help different retailers and well known store brands connect online shoppers with savings solutions, Your money will go further. web page, You will find a collection of free to use coupons, biggest banking sale offers, Active student kickbacks, Military rebates, free postage deals, And many more from some of your best brands, include things like Express coupons.

By working themselves with brands, We may easily receive exclusive insights and coupons for many stores like American Eagle Outfitters, SkinStore, garmin, Brooks supporting, Old dark blue, PrettyLittleThing bonus codes, Sephora, Wine associates, along with others brands you love and trust, Like the house and property Depot coupons. With our savings software, You can save the your online purchases. Our productive promo codes, Flash trade, And limited time offers <a href=https://www.bestbrides.net/how-to-tell-if-a-woman-likes-you-based-on-her-zodiac-sign/>how to know if a libra woman likes you</a> have already been verified by our dedicated coupon team of experts. This means all of the discounts that you see here have been checked and all are 100% free to use.

We also make shopping easy with promo codes and savings guides for special circumstances, incorporating Black Friday, Cyber friday, mother’s day, dad’s Day, romantic evening, And seasons deals. start now by browsing promo codes deals based on different categories or campaign events. You can find great outfits to add to your closet when you shop to find deals from Calvin Klein, Nike coupon codes, Chico’s, Vans promotion code, Aeropostale, And NordVPN coupons.

We add new coupons and promos everyday, So you can save money on some of the online stores and services. Whether you desire new clothing or shoes, it can save with the active promo codes and offers that we have listed on our pages. you could also save on your electronics, plus coupons on select laptops, touch screen phones, And mobile service contracts like the best Boost Mobile promo codes. Should you be interested in investing and other financial means, go to some of our top stores, decline Motley Fool coupons. If you are interested in food delivery, Check out our latest promo codes and offers from Postmates, newly, and many more. For low prices and free freight, You can find a variety of eBay coupons here, From codes for invited users only and promo codes for specific categories to online codes with sitewide discounts.
[—-]

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...