LinkedIn Is Helping The Chinese Government Silence Critics
from the maybe-people-will-start-paying-attention-to-their-notifications-NOW dept
The social networks of the world aren’t doing much to make the world a better place. Facilitating communications across borders is great — a definite net gain for the world’s citizens. But these platforms insist on distributing globally while thinking locally, making their operations subject to censorial governments in the countries where they do business.
Facebook’s refusal to stand up to various authoritarian governments arguably made it an accessory to the fact in genocide. Twitter tends to sit back and let Turkey’s government vanish away criticism of President Erdogan and his actions. Google appears to be one of the few companies responsive to the Chinese government’s demands for content deletion, which is probably due to its ability to get past the country’s Great Firewall as well as its temporarily suspended construction of a Chinese government-controlled search engine.
One social network rarely appears in these discussions, most likely because few people actually see it as a social network. LinkedIn — the de facto adult in the world of social networking — is also giving China what it wants when it wants it.
LinkedIn censored the profile and activities of a vocal critic of the Chinese government for users in China, in another apparent response to a censorship request from the government.
Corporate fraud investigator Peter Humphrey, who is British and lives in the UK, was informed by LinkedIn in December that his profile had been censored in China, but after being asked about it by BuzzFeed News this week, LinkedIn restored the page and said it had only been blocked in error.
It comes days after LinkedIn censored the page of a pro-democracy activist in China before also later restoring it after a wave of negative publicity.
LinkedIn is one of the only American social media services to be warmly welcomed on the other side of the Great Firewall. Consequently, this means it actually has something to report about China and its demands for content removal in its transparency reports. So far, the censorship plan is working… with an assist from LinkedIn.
LinkedIn is trying to have it both ways. It’s complying with China’s demands and saying things about having to follow the laws of the country it’s doing business in, as it did in a message to Peter Humphrey about his account suspension. (Screenshot at this link.)
While we strongly support freedom of expression, we recognized when we launched that we would need to adhere to the requirements of the Chinese government in order to operate in China.
Then, when the heat comes down, LinkedIn is trying to pretend its proxy censorship was just a mistake.
Asked why Humphrey’s profile had been removed in China, Nicole Leverich, a spokesperson for LinkedIn, said an internal review found the profile was “blocked in error.” It has now been restored for users in China, she said.
“Our Trust and Safety team is updating our internal processes to help prevent an error like this from happening again,” she added.
Swell, if that is what’s actually going to happen going forward. But China is batting 9-for-9 in takedowns so far, which seems to indicate the review process kicks in only after people start complaining, rather than when LinkedIn receives requests from the Chinese government.
While it makes things easier to abide by local laws when offering services in other countries, companies shouldn’t be in any hurry to indulge censorship just because locals laws enable the silencing of criticism and dissent.