Police Detective Botches 82 Special Victims Cases, Walks Away With Career Mostly Intact

from the how-not-to-fix-the-problem dept

When it comes to criminals, most people agree that those who sexually victimize children are the worst of the worst. What happens when you turn over sensitive cases to a detective who apparently doesn’t feel like doing the job? Well, cases fall into the cracks, along with the victims. Sure, even the best detectives and Special Victims Units are going to have a few that “get away.” But in the case of Detective Tammy Kilgore Alois, it wasn’t just a few that “got away.” It was dozens. (via Crooks and Liars)

The Coconut Creek police botched dozens of criminal cases involving disturbing reports about children who were raped or abused and seniors who were neglected or exploited.

The 82 “special victims” cases from 2010-2012 were the focus of a trio of internal police investigations and part of another, more wide-ranging investigation by the Broward State Attorney’s Office of Coconut Creek Police Chief Michael Mann.

The 82 cases investigated were all linked to the same detective: Tammy Alois. Alois failed to interview witnesses and victims and mishandled evidence. She skipped out on writing reports or presenting cases to prosecutors. Some cases were closed by Alois without any apparent investigation occurring. As a result, accused persons walked, if they were ever picked up in the first place.

Worse, her neglect of these cases meant victims and their families were approached again in a belated effort to pursue Alois’ neglected caseload. This reopened closed wounds. Many of those approached turned down the chance at delayed justice in order to protect the exploited from having to relive the experiences.

Alois’ actions not only screwed over the victims of abuse, but it did serious damage to the Coconut Creek PD’s reputation, as one example pulled from the files obtained by the Florida Bulldog makes perfectly clear.

March 15, 2011 – City patrol officers respond to an allegation that an adult male, a former neighbor, had sexually battered a 10-year-old boy on three separate occasions. Alois interviewed the victim on video, but the DVD was not entered into evidence. She filed no report to indicate she’d obtained the statement, nor did she send the case for further review. After Alois’ reassignment, another Coconut Creek detective contacted the boy’s father who became “extremely upset and has refused to answer any more calls.”

Now, the PD has a reputation to repair, but its actions following the exposure of Alois’ misconduct aren’t going to win it any new fans, much less change the opinion of people like the unnamed victim’s father. Alois has been fired from the Coconut Creek police department, but not because of her actions as an SVU detective.

Rather, she was dismissed for violating a “Last Chance Agreement” the city gave her five months earlier in lieu of termination after she admitted to mishandling “numerous” investigations, and to prescription drug abuse. The violation was for failing to write a report about a burglary after she’d been transferred to road patrol.

Alois’ discipline for bungling 82 “high liability” cases: a four-week suspension without pay – the most allowed under restrictions agreed to by the city in its contract with the Broward County Police Benevolent Association.

Allowing Alois to bargain herself out of more severe punishment isn’t going to ensure future accountability. The PD is obviously hamstrung by its agreement with the police union, something that is going to continue to work against its reputation. Further actions — or lack thereof — by entities involved in the investigation only further call into question the government’s interest in holding its employees responsible for their misdeeds. Alois pretty much walked away clean from multiple years of failing in every aspect of her job. Those charged with policing the police don’t appear to be too concerned with this outcome.

The Broward State Attorney’s Office did not investigate Alois for possible criminal misconduct in the matter.

Police records contain no indication that department officials who failed to notice or take action about what was happening during the three years that Alois seriously neglected her cases were disciplined, or even investigated.

Police chief Michael Mann says Alois’ boss, Lt. Scott Tabel, was “basically let go” because of this investigation. Tabel — now employed as a police officer with the Palm Springs School District– claims he “retired” after 21 years with the Coconut Creek PD, rather than being forced out due to Alois’ actions while under his supervision.

In fact, Tabel spins it the other way. He claims Mann was apprised of Alois’ lousy work back in 2011, but that the Chief “didn’t want to do anything about it.” Other statements gathered by The Florida Bulldog back up this assertion.

Biondolillo testified that he ordered a full IA investigation, but said it was “countermanded” by Chief Mann. Instead, Mann asked the city’s Human Resources department to handle it administratively, he said.

Biondolillo testified that wasn’t the first time Mann had countermanded him regarding the need to investigate Alois.

He said that on two previous occasions Drug Enforcement Administration agents had visited him and Mann to inform them of evidence they’d found that Alois was a patient at pain clinics under surveillance as suspected pill mills.

Whatever the truth is, it still looks bad for the police department. Alois, apparently abusing drugs during her years as an SVU detective, has been allowed to walk away with her professional reputation pretty much intact. Her record will only show a dismissal for a single failure to write a report — a burglary report at that, rather than anything linked to her neglect of children abused by adults, or seniors abused by children and assisted living personnel. If she’s so inclined, she’ll probably be able to secure another position in the law enforcement field, which has proven willing to launder bad cops.

As for Chief Mann, he’s also been cleared of any wrongdoing in this investigation. As the person ultimately responsible for Alois’ failure (and her single count of misconduct), he bears some of this burden… or would if anyone was willing to hold him accountable. But it appears he’ll also emerge from this unscathed. The only thing left to salvage is the PD’s reputation, but those who are trying to do so appear to be stymied by those higher on the food chain: Chief Mann, the state’s attorney and the police union. Because of this, future misconduct will be allowed to continue for far too long and the repercussions will be far too mild to encourage better behavior. And those wondering why good cops don’t do something about the bad apples in their midst will have their depressing answer: the system protects its own, especially its worst-behaving insiders.

Filed Under: , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Police Detective Botches 82 Special Victims Cases, Walks Away With Career Mostly Intact”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Anonymous Coward says:

Nothing new

The Police don’t HAVE to do anything for you.

They do not have have to save your ass from a criminal with a knife in the heat of the act itself.

There is only one way to effectively defend yourself. A gun.

The police are only there for 1 thing… revenge of the law. They rarely stop crimes and never prevent them, they mostly just respond to shit that has already gone down where people are already dead, injured, raped, or victimized.

If you think the police are here to protect you… then you are already a victim waiting to happen. If you are not prepared to stand up for your own rights and self… no one else is either.

compgeek (profile) says:

Re: Nothing new

unfortunately it is all to true that police will not “protect and serve”. as i have had to find out first hand, more than once. i have been mugged and attacked several times, even had hospital stays from some encounters (one of which cost me my last job).

now i carry at least three weapons on me (i dont have the luxury of living in a crime free and expensive neighborhood) when i leave after dark (i work 3rd shift at the moment): all less-lethal. retractable baton, taser model C2, and law enforcement grade mace (all legal where i am).
so far i have had to use my baton twice, and mace once. haven’t used the taser yet cause those cartridges are not exactly cheap, and they are slow to change out. i.o.w., only got 1 chance.

only reason i don’t carry a gun is cause if it gets taken it will do more damage when turned on me. example: a bullet hits me, i am most likely dead. the taser, gotten for me by a friend on the condition that i take a jolt without the barbs (you get same amount of juice) so i see what i am doing to an attacker, did not hurt. i could not move, but it did not hurt. (not trying to sound tough. i used to work with electricity and my skin actually has extremely high electrical resistance, so i literally can’t feel it.)

wow good thing i don’t work tonight. i ramble when i am overtired. sorry for wall of text

Agonistes says:

Re: Re: Nothing new

Don’t fall for the current hysterical rhetoric prevalent about carrying a firearm for personal defense if that is why you believe it will be more dangerous to you rather than an effective tool to defend yourself. If you are truly willing to not be persuaded into being a victim, do your own investigating. http://www.gunfacts.info/ is a good start.

Vincent Clement (profile) says:

Re: Re:

I wouldn’t count on the American public to do anything. In the past 10 years, they let strangers grope them at airports, they let CBP set up checkpoints far away from any border or port of entry, they let law enforcement seize their assets with no charge, they let spy agencies spy on them, they keep sending back the same politicians, despite a lack of trust and support in those politicians, and so on.

That Anonymous Coward (profile) says:

Apparently the penalties do not exist or are not enforced, otherwise this would have never reached this level of horror.
Someone should start at the bottom and work their way up slapping charges on everyone in this chain of command who allowed this to happen and acted to cover up the total failure to do their sworn duty, most likely in a scheme to try to keep the police from looking bad.
Many people lost faith in these police when they were never helped, criminals not brought to justice, accused who never had a chance to clear their name.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...