Game Creator Finds That Knockoffs Can't Match His Awesome Game

from the winning dept

One thing game developers have always had, and will always have, to deal with is the dreaded copycat clone. It’s something of a success indicator when you create something entertaining enough to breed like products. As they say, imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. Or, instead of being flattered, you can go the Zynga route and sue folks using IP laws rather than compete with them directly. Or, if one were so inclined, one could take a page out of the Namco playbook and threaten a kid for making a Pacman clone. Defenders of these actions will claim that they’re necessary. After all, a great amount of work and development went into those games and it seems unfair for a copycat to come along, use similar designs, and reap the benefits. How could the original creator compete with that?

Here to show us how the original creator could compete with that is Rami Ismail, developer of Ridiculous Fishing, who was just a tad late to the iOS market compared with copycat Ninja Fishing. Instead of going legal, or even crying foul, however, Ismail just concentrated on making his game freaking awesome.

“When we released the game, we promised people that for $2.99 (£1.79) they would get Ridiculous Fishing without any further in-app purchases or anything,” he told Digital Spy at PC and indie games expo Rezzed.

“We’re going to keep our word, but we want to emphasize that point that we were really serious about that. The plan we have now, if we pull it off the way we want to, we’re going to double the content and add a completely new narrative arc, and explore that world a bit further.”

The result? Well, Ridiculous Fishing got real big, real fast. Ninja Fishing did okay as well, but Ismail’s game has the kind of cachet that only comes with a tightly developed game and a loyal fanbase. Built largely off of his promise to refrain from in-app purchases and his passion for his customers, the whole thing exploded on iOS once it was released.

“Then what happened, that bubble just exploded. Elijah Wood played Ridiculous Fishing and tweeted about it. That’s mind-blowing. That’s not something that happens. We didn’t expect it to be this big – we hoped it would be this size. We really hoped this would be the definitive statement about creativity will always win, because obviously the whole cloning background is still there for us, right?

“We still want to make this statement that Ninja Fishing did well, but Ridiculous Fishing wins because it was the better game. Better games win. That’s what we hoped people would get out of it, and I think they did.”

A ton of downloads and one Apple design award later, Ismail serves as the perfect example of what the combination of fan loyalty and well-designed products mean in the war against game cloners. Instead of focusing on being angry and going the legal route, Ismail won because his game is better. Something to which the rest of the developer community should probably be paying attention.

Filed Under: , , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Game Creator Finds That Knockoffs Can't Match His Awesome Game”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
33 Comments
Wally (profile) says:

In app purchases

I don’t mind in app purchases as long as they aren’t required to complete a task in a game. I stopped paying attention to FarmVille because of it.

I grew up on games in a GUI environment Ina time when text adventures were all the rage with PC’s, my family had a MacPlus. I grew up on the works of Duane Blhem and a few other titles.

Tell me, is it so bad to still enjoy the good old 2D Mac games if they are converted over like Stuntcopter, Zero Gravity, and Cairo Shootout?

If you plan on getting the Stuntcopter remake for iOS, make sure it’s the iPad version since it has more of the old Mac feel to it :-3

Anyway enough rambling. Money is tight right now as I’m working to get my license recertified so I can practice again. I will definitely have to give Crazy Fishing a try ๐Ÿ™‚

One of the biggest things I can like and dislike about knockoffs is that they will always suck if done improperly. They bring a certain charm to life.

out_of_the_blue says:

By "cache", I guess you mean "cachet".

Your first paragraph can always be skipped as difficult to parse bombast that not only doesn’t introduce the topic, but obscures it.

Now, has “copycat” anything to do with chronology? — “Ridiculous Fishing, … was just a tad late to the iOS market compared with copycat Ninja Fishing.”

Besides being first to market yet deemed “copycat”, it seems that “Ninja Fishing” hasn’t copied the astounding features of “Ridiculous”, so again, how’s that being a “copycat” or “clone”? Isn’t it just a similar motif?

Apparently a big factor was luck of being touted by some celebrity: “Elijah Wood played Ridiculous Fishing and tweeted about it.”

Anonymous Coward says:

How emotions affect your financial decisions?
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/body/emotions-decisions.html

I can’t say in this case with any certainty, what I can say is that emotions do play a role, and I speculate that in this case good relations with your clients is essential for success as much as being capable to deliver on promises made.

This is what some people didn’t understand yet, there is an emotional component to markets, and when played right you rip positive results, played wrong and you rip those results in spades most certainly. There are some sayings that I can’t recall at the moment about how good news are fleeting but bad news are forever or some such.

John Fenderson (profile) says:

Re: Re: Re: Too Bad Vlambeer Hasn't Learned Anything

That’s really sad, but I understand the emotion.

However, he should have been aware that copycatting is inevitable. This has been true for the entire history of the software (and every other field), so it’s not like he couldn’t have seen it coming. If that was something he couldn’t emotionally handle, then he should not have released the game.

The correct way to look at it is that if your efforts are not being copycatted by someone, then what you’re making is very likely to be worthless. Seeing a clone validates your efforts.

Also, just had to throw this in, copying an idea is a long way away from “stealing”.

Rami Ismail (user link) says:

Re: Too Bad Vlambeer Hasn't Learned Anything

Or you’ve simply failed to understand we don’t care about winning. We only cared because they made it important to show the world that cloning gives you an inferior product.

This whole winning thing tired us out, we just want to make good games. Not better games than someone else, better games than our previous games. You use competition as your driving force, we’ll keep our final responsibilities towards our games and fans.

Shawn H Corey (profile) says:

Why is there a PC on your desktop?

You know the one thing that sold more PCs for IBM than anything else they did? They released the PC Technical Manual. It told how to build your own PC. Because of it, there were lots of clones. Because there were a lot of clones, a lot of software was written for it. And because there was a lot of software, IBM sold many more PCs.

Clones simulate the market and because of them, you sell more of the original than would be possible without them.

John Fenderson (profile) says:

Re: Why is there a PC on your desktop?

IBM long regretted that they were so open with the PC. They only did it that way because they didn’t think the thing would actually sell.

It was great for the industry, and did make IBM a lot of money, but being the dominating evil corporation that they were, all they could see was how much more money they could have made if not for all the knockoffs.

Of course, they probably would not have made much more money in reality. The IBM PC entered a market that had many equally good Z80 systems already well established. People would likely have just continued buying those.

PaulT (profile) says:

Re: Re: Why is there a PC on your desktop?

That mindset is the reason why it’s so hard for companies to see the clear precedent out there – not just with the PC but with the open VHS format vs. the closed Betamax, etc., as well as developers for certain types of software. They don’t think “wow, look at all the money we made”, they think “just think how much more we could have made if those other guys didn’t get a slice!”. The fact that the competing product bolstered the market and made the overall pie bigger tends to elude them.

Lurker Keith says:

true on consoles too

This is true w/ console games as well.

I found a Splinter Cell clone, Rogue Ops, for the GameCube, a few years back. I think I only grabbed it because it was only $10 at an EB Games (can’t remember if it was new or used; I got Eternal Darkness new, also for $10, the same day iirc).

It was fun, but not nearly as good as Splinter Cell.

PaulT (profile) says:

Re: Re:

Do you have accurate figures for how much each game has actually made over time, or are you just guessing based on chart position? It’s worth noting that the two have very different business models – Ninja being free to play with in app purchases while Ridiculous is a single upfront payment. So just comparing apparent revenue might not actually be a true comparison of success.

If Ninja has a hard core of players who pay regularly money for in-app purchases, then that game has a revenue stream that’s simply not possible with the Ridiculous business model. Ninja could easily gross more even if Ridiculous has more overall players, and freemium games have a habit of staying longer in the charts anyway due to their constant revenue stream from active players.

“How is it “winning” when your game is earning less than your competitor that’s been out for more than a year?”

First off, how is the game doing compared to if there was no competition? If both games are doing better than projected, then both games are “winning” – this isn’t a zero sum game.

Secondly, the game has won numerous awards, is one of the best reviewed games of the year and has apparently sold a decent amount of copies. I’d call that “winning” even if someone else out there is also doing well – especially since both games were based off a free Flash game to begin with.

clairek (profile) says:

Personal Direct Injury

There are a lot of aspects that one must learn to understand when it comes to personal injury claim. These concepts are a bit complicated to understand if you will not seek help from people who actually understand such concepts. There are personal injury solicitors who are always willing and ready to explain concepts regarding personal injury claim.

SE Software Technologies (profile) says:

Best Web Designing & Development Services

Welcome to SE Software Technologies

SE Software Technologies is company that providing the services of software Development, web design & development, consultation, E-commerce solution, SEO/SEM internet marketing, Project Portfolio management, Content Management System (CMS). Simultaneously focused on provides complete and integrated customized business solutions. We guarantee that all our customers get the best in services and support with our talented development team. Our strong client base proclaims the focus that we have on making all clients think, Special & Unique! SE Software Technologies is a foremost name in the most eye-catching, stunning, active, & unique website design & development at feasible cost.

Our Services

Web Development
Web Designing
E-Commerce Websites
Web Application Development
Web Hosting Services
Search Engine Optimization
Portal Development
Partner Program
School Management System
Patient Management System
College Management System
E-Commerce Solutions
Web CMS

superconeng (user link) says:

Online Web Desinging

This site is very important and famous for Online Website Designing AND Dewelopment.
SE Software Technologies is one of the foremost software providers and providing the services of Web development and designing,
OpenCart Websites Services, WordPress Websites Services, Accounting Software, Web Hosting Services, Domain Registration, SEO/SEM,
Consultation, E-commerce solution, Content Management System (CMS).
We are providing Services in different countries from last 10 years in UK, USA, Canada, Saudi Arabia Germany and Pakistan.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop ยป

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...
Older Stuff
16:10 David Braben, Once Angry At Used Games, Now A New Business Model Embracer (33)
18:40 Artists Embracing, Rather Than Fighting, BitTorrent Seeing Amazing Results (10)
15:41 Vodo's Big Brother Bundle Shows How Bundles Can Improve The 'Pay What You Want' Concept (12)
23:06 Price Elasticity Can Work: Dropping Ebook Price To $1 Catapulted Year-Old Book Onto NYT Best Seller List (58)
16:03 The Good And Bad In Chaotic eBook Pricing (35)
05:18 Game Creator Finds That Knockoffs Can't Match His Awesome Game (33)
23:09 The Value Of Kickstarter: Connecting With Fans On-The-Fly (18)
10:02 Massive Growth In Independent Musicians & Singers Over The Past Decade (101)
23:54 Cool New Platform For Supporting Artists: Patreon, From Jack Conte (23)
05:46 A New Hope: How Going Free To Play Brought Redemption To Star Wars MMO (48)
11:16 There Is No Logic To The Argument That Zach Braff Shouldn't Use Kickstarter (105)
06:00 When Startups Need More Lawyers Than Employees, The Patent System Isn't Working (55)
03:14 Hitchhiker's Fan-Site Started By Douglas Adams Shows Why Authors Shouldn't Panic Over Derivative Works (27)
09:21 Patents As Weapons: How 1-800-CONTACTS Is Using The Patent System To Kill An Innovative Startup (54)
07:19 How EA's 'Silent Treatment' Pushed The SimCity Story Into The Background (55)
13:30 Deftones Guitarist: People Who Download Our Music Are Fans, They're Welcome To Do So (29)
13:10 Macklemore Explains Why Not Being On A Label Helped Him Succeed (29)
03:45 Successful Self-Published Ebook Authors Sells Print & Movie Rights For $1 Million, But Keeps Digital Rights To Himself (43)
11:53 Musician Alex Day Explains How He Beat Justin Timberlake In The Charts Basically Just Via YouTube (52)
00:09 Publishers Show Yet Again How To Make Money By Reducing The Price To Zero (42)
20:13 Flattr Makes It Easier Than Ever To Support Content Creators Just By Favoriting Tweets (61)
16:03 Case Study: Band Embraces Grooveshark And Catapults Its Career (21)
19:39 Amanda Palmer On The True Nature Of Connecting With Fans: It's About Trust (131)
16:03 Kickstarter-Funded Movie Wins Oscar For Best Documentary (89)
13:41 It's Fine For The Rich & Famous To Use Kickstarter; Bjork's Project Failed Because It Was Lame (20)
17:34 Connecting With Fans In Unique Ways: Band Sets Up Treasure Hunt To Find Fan-Submitted Sounds In New Album (10)
07:27 Just As Many Musicians Say File Sharing Helps Them As Those Who Say It Hurts (131)
20:00 Skateboard Legend Stacy Peralta Demonstrates His Latest Trick: Cashing In By Going Direct-To-Fan (13)
23:58 Wallet Maker Shows Everyone How To Make Their Own Awesome Wallet (16)
11:27 $274 Million Raised Via Kickstarter In 2012 (8)
More arrow