Gwiz's Favorite Techdirt Posts Of The Week
from the golly-gee-whiz dept
This week's favorites post comes courtesy of Gwiz.
I have to admit that when I first said I would give the Favorite Posts a shot, I didn't realize how hard it would be to pick a few favorites from so many interesting articles. I happened to luck into a shorter week due to the holiday and I thought it might be easier, but not so much. Anyway, without further preamble, here are my picks for the week:
As an average working stiff with no vested interest in the industries usually discussed on Techdirt, my interests tend to lean towards the articles that deal with the slow erosion of things I hold dearly, like privacy, due process and protection against unreasonable search and seizures. The story about Austrian police seizing computers used as a Tor exit node was especially interesting to me. I found the initial discussion concerning anonymity on the internet to be very enlightening. This article also spawned an interesting phenomena in the comment section when one of the commenters voiced an extremely distasteful view of pedophilia. The subsequent reaction of the Techdirt community to this commenter became a very good argument in itself as to why the internet really is not a wild west that needs to be regulated and can do a fine job of policing itself.
Along the same lines, we had a few articles concerning PROTECT IP and the technological implications of this bill, which actually made me go and read the white paper written by some of the most knowledgeable people in regards to the DNS system. And, as an added bonus, we got to see a video of Mike discussing this issue. We also had the RIAA more or less attacking the public domain and telling us that it really has no value. At least, to offset that to some degree, we had the Polish Prime Minister realizing that things funded with public monies should be in the public domain. We need more thinking in that direction.
Making an account on any website is something I rarely do, but I felt compelled to register a profile on Techdirt for one main reason, the generally high level intelligence and mostly civil debates that happen in the comments section here. I have learned quite a bit from reading both sides of the debates and have on occasion had to revise my initial stance on issues because of it. The article about the arrest of people dancing at the Washington Memorial was one such post. When I last looked there were over 350 comments and the debate over civil disobedience and the reactions by law enforcement. Unfortunately, since I needed to keep abreast of all of the Techdirt articles this week, I haven't finished reading though them all, but what I did read was fascinating.
On a brighter note, it's good to see a body such as the UN acknowledging that the three strike laws and ACTA pose civil rights problems.
And lastly, on the humorous side of things, I found it very funny to see two fully grown companies acting like children on the playground and the Malaysian man who was required to apologize 100 times on Twitter for defaming someone, kind of like a modern day equivalent of writing "I will not say bad things about Susie" on the chalkboard.
Well, that's it for my Favorites this week. I hope you enjoyed them and it's back to lurking in the comment section for me.


A Small Critique
I'm not critiquing the article whatsoever, just the graph.
A little more contrast in colors would be nice. That graph is a bit tough to decipher.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Also of note...
hobbit polisher
Is that what the kids are calling it these days?
We usually referred to that as "Dating Miss Michigan" or "Spanking the monkey" in my youth.
Re: Re: Re: My disgust with MS grows almost daily
I don't think you can really do much hardcore gaming without supporting MS or Sony. I'm not an expert,...
Based on personal experience, I have been able to get most any game I wanted to run under Linux using Wine, Dosbox or one of the console simulators. The only ones I couldn't get to work were because I don't have a super-duper graphics card on my laptop and they didn't run under Windows either.
(Like a dumbass I bought The Witcher Enhanced Edition without reading the box and there it sits all pretty on that shelf mocking me daily)
Re: Re: Re: My disgust with MS grows almost daily
I like how you pitch the alternatives without pointing out how they are no better than MS in crackdowns, and most of time much worse.
Really? Can't say I recall ever seeing any sort of crackdown for sharing Linux distos. Just sayin'
Re: Re: Microsoft
Nah, it's just people downloading a free version of MS Office.
I doubt it. Everyone now knows if you download a free version of Office creepy green guys will emerge from your photocopier and take your computer.
Re:
I'd like to see the transparency report on the astroturf groups they control.
And I'd like to see flying unicorns that excrete magic fairy dust.
But I think we are both out of luck since these reports deal with reality and not completely made up fantasies inside our own minds.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
Hmm I don't think it's ever worked along the lines of "Make your product cheaper or we'll just pirate it".
Sure it has.
Restaurants: Sell your food cheaper or I will duplicate your recipe at home.
Auto parts: Sell your OEM parts cheaper or I will purchase from someone who has duplicated them and sells them cheaper.
Movies: Sell your theater tickets cheaper or I will wait until it's on broadcast TV for free.
Lawn Service: Mow my lawn at what I think is a fair price or I will mow it myself.
I could go on....
Re:
First we have to protect children from books, plays, telephones,.......
Don't forget about other kids too. They can be soooo mean sometimes.
We wouldn't want little Johnny's delicate psyche to suffer any damage before it can be properly crushed by the school of hard knocks when he reaches adulthood.
Re: What is/are:
What is/are drug smuggles?
They are large, blanket-like robe things that are also fire retardant so you don't catch fire when you drop the roach clip.
(untitled comment)
"We're in a transformative period with an explosion of technology that's going to need content..."
Translation: The world revolves around us and all that tech shit is completely worthless without us.
"We're going to have to be more subtle and consumer-oriented...."
Translation: We need to keep our backroom deals a more secretive and oriented way out of the line of sight of the consumers.
"We're on the wrong track if we describe this as thievery."
Translation: Those little shits have commandeered another of our derogatory names again. Maybe something like "artist soul snatchers" or "baby music killers" could work.
Re: It's not that simple
There's lots of evidence that piracy of already popular albums hurts sales; there are plenty of sales charts where you can see sales ramping up, then the album appears on file sharing networks, and sales drop dramatically.
I'm with Colin on this one. Please give us some citations of this "lots of evidence" you speak of.
I've been waiting quite awhile for some solidly verifiable data on this.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
http://www.google.com/search?q=bar+owner+hardship+ascap+bmi+live+music
Re: Re: Re: Re: $1-billion to labels?
Oof. Bad link.
http://www.techdirt.com/blog/?tag=termination+rights
Re: Re: Re: $1-billion to labels?
Why not just buy the labels, own the copyrights, and then do what you want with them...
If that happens, I wonder where Google will end up on the copyright termination fight.
Re: Re:
Whoops.
I meant: I looked up the jurisdiction of the Senate Finance Committee.
Re:
Moreover, the tack being taken in the letter to the Senate Finance Committee does seem a bit off the mark. If this is really founded on an "IP" issue, I would have expected it to be directed to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
This was my original thought also, until I looked up the jurisdiction of the Judiciary Committee and found that ACTA and TPP would fall exactly within their purview:
Re: Re: Re:
No, just pointing out the writer has an axe to grind- not to mentioned is a recent law school graduate. I'd be happy to read something by a legal scholar on the subject, which the author is far from.
Ummm, would the other 49 law professors, all from prestigious law schools, who signed the letter to Congress qualify in your book?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
how about any citations you didn't write? no offense, but how about an objective verification rather than just more of your own distorted perception?
Not really sure why I'm replying to you since you seem to be nothing more than some insufferable ass on the internet, but here you go:
ASCAP's About Page:
BMI's About Page:
Google Search really is awesome!
Re: Oddity
Well, having read that, I now have a somewhat irrational desire to start my own torrent site, it'll be "stolenbicycles.com"
Your first torrent on there should be the plans for this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmxjLpu2BvY
Re:
It's not meant as a way to recover losses. Its meant as a way to make an example of a select few.
And it seems to have failed two-fold for the RIAA:
1) Public opinion of the RIAA and the major labels has suffered greatly due to these lawsuits.
2) With such huge awards that are so far removed from reality, the public is losing respect for copyright laws in general.