by Mike Masnick
Wed, Aug 15th 2007 7:42pm
Back in 2005, following a criminal investigation of the site Allofmp3.com in Russia, officials declined to press charges, noting that the site did appear to be operating legally under existing Russian laws. That, of course, set off a string of events, including having the US pressure Russia to change its laws or risk being kept out of the WTO. Eventually, Russia did change some laws and forced Allofmp3.com to shut down, though it quickly popped up again under another name. It didn't take long for the big record labels to then push for the criminal prosecution of the site's owner, when all he had really done was help demonstrate a business model for selling music that seemed to be working well (i.e., price it reasonably and don't restrict it with DRM). Also, he tried to pay royalties to the RIAA, but they wouldn't accept them. Luckily for Allofmp3, it didn't take long for a court to see through the recording industry's arguments and throw out the case, pointing out (once again), that the site didn't break any Russian laws, while also noting that the record labels did an awful job presenting any real evidence of copyright infringement on the part of Allofmp3.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- Elsevier Says Downloading And Content-Mining Licensed Copies Of Research Papers 'Could Be Considered' Stealing
- Starting From Next Year, China Wants Music Services To Vet Every Song Before It Goes Online
- Awesome Stuff: MIDI Where You Need It
- RIAA Drops Allofmp3 Lawsuit; Pretends Mp3Sparks Doesn't Exist
- US Tells Russia To Change Laws So It Can Say Allofmp3 Was Always Illegal