Court Tosses Lawsuit Claiming Muting A Runescape Character Violates The First Amendment

from the as-one-does dept

Here’s a bit of a weird one: a First Amendment lawsuit over the “muting” of a player’s character. (h/t Volokh Conspiracy)

Amro Elansari — in a handwritten complaint [PDF] — contends Jagex Inc., the company behind Runescape, violated loads of rights and other things when it apparently muted his character back in March of this year. The allegations include discrimination, violations of his free speech rights along with his due process rights, and other “adverse action.”

He claims he was muted for no reason and without notification — this despite being a “streamer + 2000 hours + invested.” He also claims this happened while he was streaming and that viewers witnessed this egregious violation of multiple rights as it happened. Elansari’s lawsuit asks for the court to order the “mute” removed and whatever else a jury might find proper to award him.

Obviously, there’s nothing the judicial system can do for him.

To start with, Elansari is suing a (UK) company for violating his (American) rights. Even without these particular modifiers, there’s nowhere Elansari can go with this. He’s suing a private company for violating his Constitutional rights — something that’s almost impossible for a private company to do. Especially First Amendment rights, which can only be violated by the government.

Early on in the order [PDF], the court notes there’s no federal claim it can even attempt to handle given the particulars of the allegations.

[Elansari] cannot state a constitutional claim against a private company precluding him [from] amending to assert a federal question.

It gets a bit more particular a couple of pages later:

While he alleges Jagex Inc., an entity located in the United Kingdom, muted and denied his appeal, these allegations cannot state a plausible constitutional claim.

Now, pay attention everyone lining up to sue social media platforms for moderating them.

The First Amendment and its constitutional free speech guarantees restrict government actors, not private entities.

The same goes for the due process claims. Only the government can violate these rights. For a private company to violate the Fifth Amendment, it has to be working in concert with the government when the violation occurs. Obviously, a Runescape muting does not involve state actors — not even UK-located ones.

I know our civics textbooks said nice things about the judicial system and the redress of grievances, but sometimes a (legal) complaint is just a (regular) complaint. The plaintiff gets to bitch a bit and the court just kind of nods along like a tolerant bartender until closing time.

The only place Elansari comes out ahead is at the cash register. The court grants his request to file without paying fees, but the only thing that does is keep him from falling farther behind.

Once again with feeling:

The First Amendment and its constitutional free speech guarantees restrict government actors, not private entities.

Some people out there need this tattooed to the inside of their eyelids… or at the very least, across the foreheads of their legal representation.

Filed Under: , , , ,
Companies: jagex

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Court Tosses Lawsuit Claiming Muting A Runescape Character Violates The First Amendment”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
20 Comments
Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: Re:

There are millionaires out there who made their fortune just because they’re fun to watch. What’s the difference between an improv comedian who quips with pals like Ryan Stiles and George Proops; and an improv comedian who happens to be raiding a virtual dungeon while he quips with pals?

Or, sometimes, it has connections to a real world skill or sport of some variety. For example, NASCAR driver William Byron’s career got started on iRacing when he was just 15. Now he’s the driver for Jeff Gordon’s former team.

This dude, though… this dude is definitely an "unfluencer".

Anonymous Coward says:

Just because someone else makes a living playing children’s games (video or otherwise) doesn’t mean society is obligated to remove all obstacles in the way of other people (say, me) making a living the same way.

I am, of course, free to rent a venue (online or off), collect entry fees, and perform. But why should, say, Carnegie Hall be forced to rent time to me–even if they are the most prestigious venue, and therefore the place I deem most likely to pay me a large profit?

Aside: I am a little surprised that the website’s TOS don’t require any litigation to be in British courts: sloppy work on the part of British lawyers who perhaps thought foreign courts were as irrelevant as foreign constitutions.

Anonymous Coward says:

Amro Elansari is an idiot. When you’re using my servers or you are on my property, you only have the rights I decide to give you. If you’re in my house and assume you have the right to free speech, my response would be to "get the fuck off my property". You’re free to exercise your right to free speech just as long as I don’t have to listen to it.

The right to free speech is limited to when the government decides that you can’t exercise it. It has nothing to do private conversation unless a government entity decides to use it against you.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »