Yeah, Russia Probably Forged A Weapons Cache Supposedly From The US Using A Video Game To Model The Weapons

from the fake-it-til-you-make-it dept

Video games are starting to get realistic. Like, crazy realistic. Between what graphics look like on the latest hardware to the unbelievable committment to authenticity many of the latest games have, it’s starting to get hard to tell game footage apart from video footage. So hard, in fact, that it appears the pro-Russian groups had an “oopsie!” moment while trying to accuse America of arming Ukrainian rebels with Stinger missiles.

A video from Ukrainian pro-Russian separatists…shows the rebels storming an underground compound and dusting off a wooden case with a “US army” inscription, where a the MANPADS Stinger 92 surface-to-air missile is stored.

Here’s a screenshot from the video, showing the Stinger missile in question.

Notice anything strange? Unless you’re familiar with American military equipment, you might have missed the lettering at the bottom of the device that reads “TRACKING RAINER.” You probably also aren’t aware that the actual American Stinger missiles have that same lettering, except that it’s supposed to read “TRACKING TRAINER” instead.
Between that and several other translation errors in the video, the general consensus is that the whole thing was cooked up by pro-Russians trying to make it look like America is sending weapons to the Ukraine (which we still might be) by creating mockups of the weapons and passing them off as the real thing. The next obvious question is what caused the pro-Russian groups to make the translation mistake on the Stinger missile in their video and what they used as a basis to model their mockup after? The answer is, of course, video games.

The most significant mistake is found in the inscription on the Stinger weapon itself, which reads “tracking rainer” instead of “tracking trainer”. Video games blogger Anton Logvinov noted on his website that the same typo occurs in the EA first-person shooter game Battlefield 3, leading him to believe that the Stinger ‘discovered’ in Lugansk is likely fake.

Russian propaganda: so good it very nearly fooled a video game blogger! We will, as always, welcome our friends from the Putin internet propaganda brigade in our comments section.

Filed Under: , , , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Yeah, Russia Probably Forged A Weapons Cache Supposedly From The US Using A Video Game To Model The Weapons”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
That One Guy (profile) says:

The boy who cried 'Stinger Missile'

Of course the funniest bit about attempted propaganda like this, and what makes it so incredibly stupid, is that if, at some point in the future they do discover an actual weapons shipment from the USG, they are going to have a much harder time getting people to believe that no, honest, this time it’s real.

In attempting to fabricate some pro-Russia propaganda, they instead shot themselves, and their credibility, in the foot.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: The boy who cried 'Stinger Missile'

Just remember: this propaganda isn’t exactly made for Western consumption; it is primarily meant to enforce the idea that US and NATO are out for Russia’s blood among the coutry’s population.

That same tactic has been used by the Soviet regime since the end of WWII, usually with better success, too.

Klaus says:

Re: Re: Re: The boy who cried 'Stinger Missile'

Remember Saddam’s troops throwing Kuwaiti babies out of incubators, or those horrific stories of WWI German infantrymen bayonetting babies? All made up.

It’s difficult to distinguish truth from fiction, and although still disputed by the perpetrating nations, the weight of argument tells us that the Rape of Nanking happened, as did the Massacre of the Armenians.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: Re:2 The boy who cried 'Stinger Missile'

G.E.N.O.C.I.D.E of Armenians. But now that Israel has bought the word and also holocaust, any other people’s suffering will never be accepted as one in the US. Pretty much every respectable nation on earth did so, even some not-so-respectable, they just called a duck a duck. Turkey and the US have a very special kinda hidden relationship, they wouldn’t ruin that.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: The boy who cried 'Stinger Missile'

It’s exactly what it’s for. Kerry looked a bit bamboozled when Lavrov said at the very end of the Iran deal that these bases in Poland and the Czech Republic, anti-missile/missile bases are now irrelevant, right John?

These bases are and always were to be able to first strike Russia, hell Kaliningrad is Russia but it’s just an exclave north of Poland. The Iran excuse was a joke, but also to appease Israel.

Anonymous Coward says:

Russian propaganda: so good it very nearly fooled a video game blogger! We will, as always, welcome our friends from the Putin internet propaganda brigade in our comments section.

No need to belittle the video game blogger. This would likely have passed by major news outlets without hitch, you know, if those would ever publish stuff against the US’s interests.

Lisa Westveld (profile) says:

But what if the USA did create those weapons and misspelled it on purpose so everyone would think they’re fake while they’re really the real deal?
And what if Russians are claiming these typo’s were done on purpose by the USA because of the above logic, while it’s not true?
And what if the USA is claiming the Russians are lying when the Russians claim that the USA delivered these weapons including this typo to make it seem they did not send them?
And what if the Russians… Oh, well… You get my line of thinking by now. The truth? We’ll never know it…

Anonymous Coward says:

Both Countries are not innocent in the Ukraine conflict.

Its like they are finding russian uniforms in their country, well hate to break it to you but you can find US uniforms in Canada, does that mean the Americans are invading Canada. Just finding Military gear in Neighbour countries does not mean they are behind this and it does not mean they are not behind it as well. There are always Canadian and American Troop movements on both sides of the border and sometimes we come really close to that border, does not mean we attacked each other.

See I just proved that the USA is trying to invade Canada, I have the army jacket to prove it /s

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re:

Look! A squirrel!

That argument might have held more weight if a) it had anything to do with the obviously faked weapon being discussed an b) if the US had recently annexed Newfoundland and Canada had recently had its political system in shambles.

Wait… maybe the USA IS trying to invade Canada….

Lisa Westveld (profile) says:

Re: Re:

Actually, back in the time when the whole area was called the USSR, a lot of people were forced to move to other locations in the whole USSR. Especially the Russian citizens were moved to all of these “foreign” location, turning them into an invasive, legal aliens.
Then the USSR fell apart, those Russians just stayed where they were, demanding they would become basically dual-citizens. A large population of the Ukraine and especially the Krim las a lot of Russian people.
There are also plenty of Ukrainian people in Russia, though. The forced migrations worked in two ways and was meant to make everyone equal to one another.
But now Russian and Ukrainian Nationalists are calling for a forced separation. And that’s basically what started the whole conflict.
Yeap, Putin is Evil, but Putin isn’t Russia!

Anonymous Coward says:

Fake or this happened

*an evening of FPS with friends each with their own vodka bottle*
Hey, guys… I have an idea. Let’s fake a video of the US storing weapons in the Ukraine using this game engine.
-Sounds good, I make the assets you make the game.
Ok, your english is better anyway.

So yeah, either it is a fake or done by some drunk wannabe militairy guys. If Russia or even Mr NoShirt had anything to do with it they’d use real weapons. The US is selling them like candy so my guess is that for a gov it isn’t hard to get some of those.

Uriel-238 (profile) says:

Arms manufacturers still license the likenesses of their guns to video game manufacturers.

It’s one of the reasons why many games have guns that look a lot like real guns but are named differently and often have different characteristics.

For a while I was developing an open source fictional gun library of game assets that would allow for a consistent set of guns that behaved similarly across multiple games.

This presents yet another good reason to finish building such a library.

Anonymous Coward says:

So let me try and understand this. Since the Ukrainian pro-Russian separatists, are the rebels. The “legit government” wants to keep them as part of the ukraine instead of splintering off and becoming part of russia.

The pro russian rebels sent out a misinformation video saying that the americans are arming them to fight against the neo nazi ukraine government that is currently being backed by the americans among other various goverments.

Why would a Russian backed group send out any info claiming their forces are being supplied and armed by their enemies instead of being armed by their allies.

If somehow the ukraine rebels are considered the pro neo nazi government forces then they need to call them something else.

I don’t care for either side tbh. I have several friends living in ukraine and this is making a mess of their lives. I wish one side or the other would just win and end it. or the fascists to let those that want to secede go ahead and do it.

ECA (profile) says:

Good and Bad here

With an OPEN internet and being able to wonder around and find Almost anything.
Videos of Idiots. Pictures and Dogs Humping..
With a bit of video editing, or Just Capture 1 Picture in a Video game…
You can SAY anything. and have Proof..

With the Covert Ops of the past..its HARD for the people to know What has and have NOT been done in our OWN NATION..

It would be nice if our OWN gov would let us Know what they have FAILEd to do.

Uriel-238 (profile) says:

Re: Re: Re:2 Russian and Ukranian articles.

Probably not. But the Ukranians who’ve asked me not to call their territory The Ukraine were specifying protocol for English. It’s a national identity thing with deep grudges about occupation by the USSR.

Calling Ukraine The Ukraine is by no means a criminal act or even a severe faux pas, but it is step towards the Ukraine peoples owning their own destinies rather than being walked all over and occupied like poor Poland.

I tend to want to oblige them.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...