by Mike Masnick
Thu, Mar 17th 2011 10:33am
Sony's ridiculous and over-aggressive lawsuit against George Hotz (Geohot) for jailbreaking the PS3 keeps reaching new absurd levels. The latest is that the magistrate judge, who seems to be rubber stamping most of Sony's requests, is allowing the company to subpoena Paypal for Geohot's account records. We've already discussed how she's allowing subpoenas for visitors to Geohot's website, as well as for whoever watched the YouTube video he put up about the jailbreak. Sony claims it needs access to his Paypal records to prove that people in California may have donated. They want that so that they can establish California as the proper jurisdiction for hearing the case. Frankly, this is ridiculous. First, who donated to Geohot should not be even remotely meaningful in determining the proper jurisdiction for the case. Where Hotz is located should outweigh any donor locations. Second, shouldn't the judge be somewhat concerned with the privacy aspects here? In giving up Geohot's Paypal info, isn't this exposing the info of anyone who might have donated, without them having the ability to stop it?
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- Local Lawyers Challenge New Kuwaiti Law Creating Mandatory DNA Database Of All Citizens And Visitors
- Techdirt Podcast Episode 92: Passwords Suck; What's Next?
- EFF White Paper Hopes To Educate Cops On The Difference Between An IP Address And A Person
- Sony Apparently Issuing Takedowns To Facebook For News Articles About PS4 Slim Leak
- PayPal Stops A Payment Just Because The Payee's Memo Included The Word 'Cuba'