by Mike Masnick
Wed, Oct 24th 2007 12:40am
Just last week, Wired had an article looking at how a particular section of law regulating adult content could potentially hurt the growth of "user generated" porn sites. The law in question required any "publisher" of adult content to obtain and permanently keep records proving that the "performers" in question were of legal age. Obviously, the goal here is to prevent child porn -- but many felt that such a rule was incredibly burdensome on those who were producing legitimate adult content, and it was even worse for "user generated" sites that would now require such information from every participant. Now, Slashdot points out that the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has found the law to be unconstitutional, as it violates the First Amendment. The Slashdot post is a little misleading, implying that the case was about age verification for viewers. It's actually about the performers. The full ruling (pdf) is an interesting read, but the crux of the argument is that while preventing child porn is a noble goal, if it ends up putting a burden on plenty of legitimate expression, then it's a clear First Amendment violation. Many people may not think this is a big deal, as they don't care for adult content or don't have any problem with having it heavily regulated -- but as the court notes, the right for people to remain anonymous is an important part of the First Amendment. Weakening that right -- even if for a reasonable end goal -- starts you down a slippery slope.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- More National Security Letters Made Public After Government Drops Its Attempt To Keep Its Gag Orders In Place
- Activist Appeals Court Decision Stating Public Has No First Amendment Right To Record In Public Areas
- State Senator Wants To Turn First Amendment Activity Into 'Economic Terrorism'
- Trump's Constant Whining About The NY Times Isn't Just Bad For The First Amendment
- More Thoughts On Trump's Technology And Innovation Policies -- It All Goes Back To Freedom Of Speech