After Exploiting Covid Broadband Program, Verizon Faces Unsurprising Opposition To Tracfone Merger

from the surely-they'll-behave-THIS-time dept

When last we checked in with Verizon, the company had just been caught exploiting the government’s Covid broadband relief program to upsell struggling Americans to more expensive plans. Now, as Verizon tries to gain regulatory approval for its $6.2 billion acquisition of Tracfone, consumer groups and a small cadre of Senators are wondering if a company that thinks nothing of exploiting struggling Americans in need is a good steward for a discount phone company whose client base is predominantly comprised of low-income Americans.

Five U.S. Senators recently wrote the FCC, rather timidly wondering if Verizon would use the acquisition to simply upsell these lower-income Americans to more expensive plans (spoiler: yes):

“Senators Richard Blumenthal, Sheldon Whitehouse, Dianne Feinstein, Ron Wyden and Ed Markey said in a letter “Verizon would have significant incentives and opportunities to push subscribers from Lifeline and inexpensive prepaid services to higher revenue plans.”

The amusing part here is that there’s 40 years of documented history showing how Verizon and AT&T’s overall strategy is to acquire everyone, then use that consolidation and reduced competition to relentlessly nickel and dime their subscribers. This is just a factual reality and the way publicly-traded companies are structured to take full tactical advantage of the market and weak regulatory environments to the benefit of investors. It’s not some errant opinion that this will happen again in the wake of yet another industry merger, it’s the likely outcome based on decades of history.

Yet the concern that they’d do so again here (spoiler: they will) is framed as some kind of radical theoretical or — as is the preference of the DC Beltway “he said, she said” reporting set — purely a partisan concern expressed only by Democrats. But the fact Congress could only cobble together five Democratic Senators interested in giving a shit shows you pretty clearly that apathy to this kind of mindless consolidation is very much a bipartisan sport.

1.7 million of Tracfone’s customers currently enroll in the FCC’s Lifeline program. Started under Reagan and expanded by Bush, the program doles out a measly $9.25 monthly credit that struggling Americans can use to get a discount off of their phone, wireless, or broadband bill (they have to choose one). It’s literally the very least the government can do to help poor people afford telecom services, but it’s been endlessly demonized by folks like Trump FCC boss Ajit Pai, who think even this half-assed effort is a bridge too far.

If this telecom merger follows the pattern of other U.S. telecom mergers, a bipartisan coagulation of lawmakers will trip over themselves to ignore warnings and approve the deal. They’ll then sign off on a bunch of flimsy conditions — most likely crafted by Verizon — that not only won’t really do all that much, but won’t be enforced or adhered to. Meanwhile, Verizon gets way with rather nebulous claims that this deal creates amazing synergies and benefits that you just can’t get without greater industry consolidation:

“The company said the proposed deal “will bring value and benefits to value-conscious consumers in a myriad of ways.”

Then in two to three years, when policymakers and the press have forgotten all about the deal, Verizon will exploit the consolidation to steadily raise rates. The very same policymakers who signed off on yet more consolidation in the space will then stand around with their hands on their hips and a dumb look on their face wondering how we got here. Right before signing off on yet another “growth for growth’s sake” telecom megamerger that benefits absolutely nobody outside of the Hamptons set. Rinse, wash, and repeat, with absolutely nobody learning anything from the experience.

Filed Under: , , , , ,
Companies: tracfone, verizon

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “After Exploiting Covid Broadband Program, Verizon Faces Unsurprising Opposition To Tracfone Merger”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
David says:

You are misunderstanding something here

The very same policymakers who signed off on yet more consolidation in the space will then stand around with their hands on their hips and a dumb look on their face wondering how we got here.

The hands are not on their hips because they are flabbergasted but because their pockets have been stuffed full and the hands don’t fit. The dumb look on their face is just the well-rehearsed default for the "how could we ever have suspected that this would end just like every single previous time?" routine.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re:

Don’t need to.

AT&T Comcast and Verizon are effectively the same company.

In direct violation of anti-trust legislation and anti-cartel rules the heads of those companies have weekly meetings to decide pricing, non-compete areas etc.

They regularly discuss who will buy out which smaller company, so they don’t all bid raising the price. Effectively screwing over the smaller business.

All very very illegal and tbh the heads of the 3 telecoms companies should be in prison forever.

Anonymous Coward says:

when are people and senators gonna wise up to and actually admit to what is going on with the main broadband companies? nothing is more important than to keep lying about what they’ve done to improve the service and what they are doing to improve it further. total bullshit! USA broadband is one of the worst on the planet with shit speeds, crap customer service and pathetic coverage. the sooner this is admitted and congress folk start actually standing up to be counted on behalf of their customers rather than on behalf of the amount in their bank accounts, perhaps then there will be change!

Anonymous Coward says:

You can trust the free market to always find the most cost effective means to deliver the product to the customer. The company that delivers the best priced service will become the largest and most profitable. Those that don’t deliver the value to the customer will shrink and become obsolete.

We will also soon see the trickle down CEO effect. Once highly paid CEOs run out of places to stash their money, they will start spending it. The economic benefit will be much greater then anything FDR or even Trump could imagine. The higher the CEO pays goes, the closer we will get to economic nirvana. We should all support and encourage each and every executive pay raise.

All we need to do to make this happen is eliminate both the useless rules and the punitive taxes on these great corporations.

While we are at it, perhaps we should also start a religion to worship the divine treasury?

That One Guy (profile) says:

Stop treating them like idiots

Rinse, wash, and repeat, with absolutely nobody learning anything from the experience.

It is well past time to give the politicians involved the benefit of the doubt in assuming that they simply don’t know better, they do.

Politicians have learned that pandering to telecom companies pays really well and has basically no downsides, the ‘press’ has been brought to heel and will happily parrot whatever PR statements are given them with no pushback, and those in the regulatory bodies like the FCC are tripping over themselves to secure lucrative ‘retirements’ by doing whatever will please the telecom companies the most and looking the other way or handing out the smallest wrist-slaps they can when that’s not an option.

None of this is by accident so framing it as them ‘simply not knowing better’ is grossly underestimating the corruption here and giving them a pass on their actions that they most certainly do not deserve.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...