Stone Brewing Is Very Upset That People Don't Like Its Trademark Bullying

from the stone-cold dept

It was just days ago that we were discussing Stone Brewing’s new campaign to jealously protect all uses of the word “stone” on alcohol branding. The one time advocate brewer claiming to stand up for craft brewing against “Big Beer” has since devolved into a corporate gorilla smashing up the USPTO to get trademarks cancelled and firing off cease and desist notices to small breweries. All this, mind you, as it also wages war on a second front with MillerCoors over Keystone’s rebranding as simply “Stone”. In that suit, MillerCoors complained that lots of breweries use the word “stone”, which appears to have set Stone Brewing off on its bout of aggression.

When Sawstone Brewing pushed back on a C&D and failed to work out an agreement with Stone Brewing, the latter initiated an attempt to cancel the former’s trademark. Sawstone complained publicly. And now Stone Brewing is busy complaining that the public is being mean to it as a result.

Stone Brewing published a lengthy statement on its website Monday night regarding its trademark dispute with Sawstone Brewing Co. in Morehead, Ky., saying that Stone has become the “subject of a vicious online harassment and smear campaign.”

In a newly published statement, Greg Koch, the CEO of Stone Brewing, acknowledged the company’s multiple trademark disputes, noting that “this kind of thing is just part of owning a brand name and a company identity,” but he claimed that Sawstone’s version of events is not how the situation unfolded.

We’ll get into that last bit in a second, but its worth pointing out that Koch’s claim that this is all somehow necessary due to owning a brand name is demonstrably false. MillerCoors itself argued against this, admittedly disingenuously. After all, while I think I’d argue that turning Keystone to Stone probably is too close to Stone Brewing so as to cause confusion, MillerCoors’ claim that lots of other breweries have used the word “stone” within their brands for a long, long time is absolutely true. And if Stone Brewing not only survived, but thrived, with all those other uses in existence, it negates completely the claim that Stone Brewing had no choice but to act as it has. Were that true, Stone Brewing wouldn’t be the behemoth it now is.

Now, on to Koch’s claim that Sawstone Brewing’s description of events wasn’t accurate… it’s all in the petty details. Essentially, Koch claims that this all started when Sawstone Brewing attempted to trademark its name and that Stone Brewing tried to amicably work out a settlement of the trademark issues over the course of a few months. In addition, Sawstone missed a couple of deadlines for which it had promised settlement proposals. And… that’s it.

All of which completely misses the point. Stone Brewing didn’t have to take this action at all. And while the reported claims of online stalking and threats sent to Stone Brewing are reprehensible if true, a public backlash to bullying behavior by a brewer that was supposed to be standing up to these types of corporate actions is perfectly valid. If Stone Brewing doesn’t like that version of the backlash, it can cease playing the bully. Unfortunately…

As for the trademark dispute, Koch said that Stone will not back down and that the decision will ultimately lie with the USPTO.

Well, then enjoy the continued backlash, you Arrogant Bastards.

Filed Under: , , ,
Companies: sawstone brewing, stone brewing

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Stone Brewing Is Very Upset That People Don't Like Its Trademark Bullying”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Not THAT AC says:

Re: Re: Re:

I have only a modicum of sympathy should he be targeted – Stephen is a regular contributor here, so well aware of the landscape around trademarks and the increasing battles in the drinks sector. With that advantage of background and knowledge, he should have got in first to register his name (and all variants thereof) – something, something, profit.

btw "Stones" is probably a registered mark in the UK – originally a Northern brewery, I think ended up in the InBev (or whatever they are today) portfolio.

Not THAT AC says:

Re: Re: Re:2 Re:

4% – stronger than a session bitter. Also the traditional Stones Ginger wine at 13.5%.

On topic though – Stones Beers and Stones Ginger wine are the product of different companies (Molson Coors and Constellation respectively), and they don’t seem to have any problems co-existing. Maybe they’re not confused by consumers because of historical entrenchment, plus, the brans have been in existence a long time,

Anonymous Coward says:

If you don’t use the trademark in a product sold to the public you may lose it, after a few years, different beer have different logos, and labels on the
bottle, even if they have one word used in another beer,its very unlikely the public will be used.
Most UK beers are not sold in the USA unless they are owned by a big company , like Guinness.
Pubs in America can only stock a limited range of beers,.

Bartoniii (user link) says:

hot viet girls

Cheryl Hines Is Now gotten married To A Kennedy

Despite news coming out in the nation’s ENQUIRER in June about her fianc cheating on her, Actress Cheryl Hines wed environmentally friendly lawyer Robert F. Kennedy, jr. the special was held at the Kennedy family compound in Hyannis Port, Massachusetts Saturday in front of close colleagues members.

Hines looked radiant in a Romona Keveza gown that entailed pearl beading, A sweet bow at the waistline and waltz length skirt that flowed around her as she walked down the aisle. She donned strappy metal sandals for a simple, Clean look and wore a loose updo while holding a bouquet of blue and white flowers. Designer Keveza said of your beloved partner in a release, "Cheryl Hines keeps going the Kennedy legacy of iconic women with timeless style,

The 48 year old Suburgatory and Curb Your enthusiasm actress married Kennedy, 60, In front of 300 guests that included their children from previous marriages, Curb Your passion co stars Larry David and Julia Louis Dreyfus, And Kennedy’s girlfriend and son, Ethel Kennedy, in addition to the Conor Kennedy.

The couple initially planned to elope with just their kids when they became engaged last May, But later decided that more of their loved ones should be at the celebration. the couple danced to Adele’s "make you feel My Love" At the wedding celebration, and furthermore Kennedy danced to "amazing World" By Louis Armstrong together with daughter Kyra, creating a <a href=>how to tell if a vietnamese woman likes you</a> poignant moment. personal guests Lyle Lovett and Natasha Bedingfield sang "she’s No Lady, That’s my wife" as well as,while "unsaid, The party kept lets start work on guests dancing to modern hits such as Robin Thicke’s Lines, Beyonce’s Ladies and your favorite music from The Beatles, Neil bridal, as well as Monkeys.

the couple dated two years before they became engaged. this is basically the second marriage for Hines and the third for Kennedy.

icon via Cheryl Hines, myspace

Click to share with you on Facebook (Opens in new door)Click to share with you on LinkedIn (Opens in new windshield)Click to express on Reddit (Opens in new windows)Click to share with you on Twitter (Opens in new window case)Click to talk about on Tumblr (Opens in new window case)Click to express on Pinterest (Opens in new display)Click to talk about on Pocket (Opens in new window case)Click to express on Telegram (Opens in new screen)Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new time frame)Click to talk about on Skype (Opens in new wind shield).

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...