Trump's Plan To Turn US Global Media Operations Into State-Sponsored Breitbart… Could Threaten The Open (And Encrypted) Internet

from the everything-is-terrible dept

Earlier this week you may have heard about the so-called “Wednesday night massacre”, in which the newly Trump-appointed head of the US Agency for Global Media (USAGM), Michael Pack, got rid of the heads of the various divisions he now runs:

The heads of four organizations overseen by the US Agency for Global Media (USAGM) were all dismissed Wednesday night — a move likely to heighten concerns that new Trump-appointed CEO Michael Pack intends to turn the agency into a political arm of the administration.

In what a former official described as a “Wednesday night massacre,” the heads of Middle East Broadcasting, Radio Free Asia, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, and the Open Technology Fund were all ousted, multiple sources told CNN.

Two days earlier, the top officials at Voice of America (the other major part of USAGM) resigned after Pack made it clear that rather than being an independent, non-partisan media operation, he intended to turn the various media operations he controlled into Breitbart-style propaganda machines, pushing the President’s messaging.

Now, there are some who have claimed that the radio operations, like Voice of America and Radio Free Europe, have always been forms of American propaganda. On the whole that’s an inaccurate portrayal. They have built up a pretty strong reputation over the years of being useful, independent news agencies, and it’s a shame that their reputation is likely to be smashed because our President and his allies are so insecure they feel the best way to accomplish their goals is to control everything and push lies and propaganda.

But, even more concerning is that the fallout from this could have a tremendous impact on the open web and encryption technologies. That’s because while much of the focus is on the various media parts of USAGM, we should be much, much, much more concerned about what is perhaps the less well known part: the Open Technology Fund. Open Technology Fund has been the (not “a” but “the”) main funder of key elements of the open internet over the past decade. Originally a subset of Radio Free Asia, it was set up to help fund the development of internet technologies that would help activists and dissidents route around censorship and government surveillance. It has helped fund part of the Tor Project. It’s funded Simply Secure, which helps a variety of different projects targeting vulnerable populations ensure their efforts are designed with safety and privacy in mind. It’s also helped fund important security audits of basically every key piece of technology that protects the internet from unwanted intrusions and surveillance.

In short, keeping OTF doing what’s it’s doing is hugely important. And that’s why it’s extremely worrying that OTF’s CEO, Libby Liu, was pushed out as part of this purge, in part because of the new direction Pack is pushing OTF to move in:

“As you all know, OTF’s flexible, transparent, and competitive funding model has been essential to our success in supporting the most secure and effective internet freedom technologies and innovative projects available,” she wrote. “I have become aware of lobbying efforts to convince the new USAGM [U.S. Agency for Global Media] CEO to interfere with the current FY2020 OTF funding stream and redirect some of our resources to a few closed-source circumvention tools.

A group of very concerned folks have now set up a page at, with a sign-on letter for Congress, asking it to continue to back the Open Technology Fund to continue to do its important work supporting open technologies that enable people to communicate online safely.

Despite OTF?s important work, there are serious concerns that the new leadership within the USAGM will seek to dismantle OTF and re-allocate all of its US government funding to support a narrow set of anti-censorship tools without a transparent and open review process. Moreover, these technologies are closed-source, limiting the number of people around the world who are able to access them and making the tools less secure, thus jeopardizing the safety of users and the global public’s trust in US-supported internet freedom technologies. Such an approach also fails to recognize the numerous threats to internet freedom and the much larger set of actions that are required to help those being targeted by repressive governments.

Around the world, intrepid journalists and dedicated activists are taking great personal risks to further freedom and democracy. OTF’s open, fair, competitive, and evidence-based award process ensures that those brave individuals have the best tools and technologies available to protect themselves. OTF funds open-source technologies and has funded over 100, independent, third-party security audits of internet freedom technologies to ensure only those with the highest security standards are supported with US-government funds.

Authoritarian regimes have made it clear that they are willing to do whatever it takes to control the internet. It is crucial that the US safeguards the internet as a democratic space for free expression. We urge Congress to respond to these escalating attacks on freedom of speech by protecting the internet through its continued and strong bipartisan support for OTF.

The changes regarding the various US broadcasting components is concerning enough, but most people hopefully can see those for what they are. The threat to an open, private, and secure internet, on the other hand, could have devastating consequences.

Filed Under: , , , , , , , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Trump's Plan To Turn US Global Media Operations Into State-Sponsored Breitbart… Could Threaten The Open (And Encrypted) Internet”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Koby (profile) says:

Re: Re:

Perhaps we could shine a little sunshine on the topic. Similar to how we have nutrition labels on food, or energy consumption labels on appliances, there could be labels on "news" organizations, so that readers/viewers could understand just how radical and biased some of the reporting is.

Of course, some of this would be difficult to measure. While measuring campaign contributions might be easy, there are a ton of political ideology tests out there online. I’m unsure of any scientific methodology, or their accuracy. And how could you enforce news hosts or editors to answer a questionnaire truthfully? It’s a lot harder than counting calories or measuring wattage. Perhaps other methodologies could be developed, such as airtime spent on certain subjects as an indicator of a network’s attempting to influence its audience.

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: Re: Re:

yeah, what’s that, genius? a new power alliance? Enforcement of bullshit? Read the news in the last 50 years?

A new power alliance emerged in the US: old and new Techdirt posters were restored to local power by accepting China’s capital’s
domination in both Southern agriculture and industry, This rule was
enforced by the terror of AntiFa. The AntiFa army was established by the
planter class to prevent Black people and their white allies from
consolidating their political gains. Through the AntiFa, like the old slave
patrols, poor whites helped terrorize and control Blacks. Black people were
forced back into subjugation through mob violence and lynching, Jim Crow
laws and wholesale disenfranchisemcnt, and white skin became the cultural
definition of power once again. While there were scattered attempts at
Black-white unity in these days, they fell apart as many poor whites
destroyed the basis for genuine alliance by defending white supremacy.


Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: Re:

" there could be labels on "news" organizations, so that readers/viewers could understand just how radical and biased some of the reporting is"

There could be scarlet letters on suspect women so that everyone can understand the shame she is supposed to feel.

Of course, some of this would be difficult to swallow. Perhaps some other method of marking your enemies.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: nutrition labels on news?

Nutrition labels on news media, like "this newspaper is full of baloney" or "this site is spam to the core"? There have been a couple of attempts ( and to do pretty much that, using browser extensions. I think NewsGuard is no longer free, but take the whole thing with a grain (or a truckload) of salt…

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: Re:3 Re:

Yes, the Message! The movement should argue for and explain armed action.
develop parallel strategies, openly support the thrust and political content of
revolutionary armed actions, claim and spread the MESSAGE of struggle, help
create the "sea" for the guerrillas to swim in. Don’t talk to the FBI. Resist
grand jury probes of revolutionary struggles. Laying the basis for armed
struggle is also the responsibility of mass organizers,

Techdirt Forever!

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
That One Guy (profile) says:

The only surprising part is that it took so long

I wish I could be surprised by this, but as Trump clearly thinks that the government and the people serve him rather than the other way around turning state media into nothing more than ‘Praise the Dear Leader’ channels is entirely within character for him.

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Slick Politician Trump

well, the US Agency for Global Media is one of those odd deepstate Federal agencies that should not exist at all.
Even if you somehow believe it’s an angelic pure-news/pure-truth purveyor to the world’s down trodden masses — it is not a legitimate function of the Federal Government nor taxpayer money.

VOA began in 1942 specifically as a wartime propaganda tool and later expanded (with various sister agencies) worldwide to communicate U.S. government policy objectives, clothed in a news and entertainment format.
(Nowadays in U.S. culture it’s supposedly a serious offense for government officials to influence the internal politics of foreign nations)

Slick politician Trump discovered USAGM in 2018 and instantly saw its primary propaganda function … that he could shift to his political benefit.

The OTF is just another blackhole for taxpayer money but has only been around for 8 years.
Do you think the NSA and CIA have not noticed the OTF encryption efforts (?) — U.S. spooks have likely already penetrated the OTF bureaucracy– defeating Chinese internet surveillance is great, but NSA, CIA wan full access to everything.

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

Anonymous Coward says:

And people still cant see what is happening in and to the USA! Look at how, bit by bit, privacy and freedom is being removed, how the police state is becoming the norm, not the exception and how death is being meted out to people who rebel against the leaders and their protectors! The ‘Land of the free, home of the brave’ has all but disappeared being replaced by a few who are so greedy, so power hungry, so determinded to have total control, by any means that turning the nation into one of slavery is no longer a joke but a distinct possibility. There isn’t a single security service now that doesn’t go the extra mile to ensure that the orders from above, regardless of what they are and who will be hurt, aren’t followed. And with a ‘boss’ like we have at present, inciting racism and rioting, just wait and see how long befor the real shit hits fan!!

Rekrul says:

Does anyone else just want to bang their head against the wall in frustration at how this corrupt piece of shit has been allowed to ruin everything he touches and instead of hauling him out of the White House in chains, we just have to hope that enough people in this country aren’t brain damaged enough to re-elect this human garbage?

And if he gets voted out, we THEN have to hope that he hasn’t corrupted our country to the point where he can just refuse to leave and everyone just sits around with their thumbs up their asses talking about legal remedies while the U.S. descends completely into a fascist dictatorship.

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

Thad (profile) says:

Re: Re:

And if he gets voted out, we THEN have to hope that he hasn’t corrupted our country to the point where he can just refuse to leave and everyone just sits around with their thumbs up their asses talking about legal remedies while the U.S. descends completely into a fascist dictatorship.

How loyal do you really think the White House staff is to him?

Trump can say he’s going to refuse to leave all he wants, but if Biden instructs the staff to disconnect the cable TV, change the wifi password, and stop bringing him food, how long do you really think he’ll last?

Uriel-238 (profile) says:

Re: Hauling Trump out in chains

Ours was an early model of a system of government that could be influenced by the will of the public. But it was, as all systems of law, corrupted to serve those who control it. Trump is the end result. And yes, if you want to stay within the confines of law, you have to wait for elections and vote for the other guy.

The other option is to acknowledge that all legal options have been exhausted and the will of the people is still ignored. (It is. We have records. We have charts. We can’t vote in the radical reforms we need to save the country from itself.) And that means considering options outside the preview of law.

And yes, he may try to find ways to legally justify delaying the election, challenging the election, refusing to accept the results of the election, delaying the end of his term, and scorching the earth when the end of his term is inevitable.

All these might be reason enough for people to step outside the law and continue politics by other means.

Uriel-238 (profile) says:

Re: Re: Re: The story goes on.

Well, that’s the problem. By saying we elected Trump as a consequence of decades of internal corruption and rot isn’t to say this is where the story ends, or that Trump will be the worst of it.

The story goes on, and Rome certainly didn’t learn its lessons from this process for several times in its history. The people of the US have to work out whether they can change the system to serve the pubic, and then if they’re willing to turn to violence, or even war to do so.

If we don’t or can’t or won’t, then yes, we will have another authoritarian demagogue, smarter than Trump and willing to bring the surveillance state and intelligence state full to bear to retain his (her) power. We may have half a dozen which define the next century of US society.

Somehow I think the knives will come out. We’re already at the spit-in-their-drinks phase as per occupied Paris.

Rekrul says:

Re: Re: Hauling Trump out in chains

And yes, if you want to stay within the confines of law, you have to wait for elections and vote for the other guy.

I don’t always express myself as well as I’d like. What I meant was that in a properly working system, Trump would have been legally removed from office long ago for his many crimes and abuses of power. Instead the system is broken and an election is where we have to pin all our hope, if THAT isn’t too intentionally broken to get rid of him.

The other option is to acknowledge that all legal options have been exhausted and the will of the people is still ignored.

The problem is that the people who set up all these legal options counted on them being enforced by people with a conscience. They never considered the possibility that half the system would become corrupt as well. What do you do when most of the institutions meant to reign in a corrupt president are in his pocket?

We sit back and watch him flagrantly violating the law and abusing his power and there’s nothing that can be done legally because he and the republican party have corrupted the system to the point where they can do what they want and nothing happens. Maybe the public gets mad and plans to vote them out of office, but they have plans to deal with that too. Voter purges, gerrymandering, closing polling locations, opposing vote by mail, imposing difficult voter registrations, etc. What happens if the people want them out, but the republican tricks keep them in power?

And that assumes that enough people care. Many like the crap that he’s doing and many just don’t care. One of my friends says he has no problem with Trump and another says that’s just the way things are and you can’t change them. 🙁

It’s like the current situation with the police. Who do you complain to when the ones tasked with enforcing the laws are the ones breaking them?

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

Anonymous Coward says:

Techdirt is an Empire run by Masnicks for their own pleasure! It is an empire which
includes the world’s largest banks and industrial corporations —aerospace,
computers, oil, insurance, telephones and television. The Masnicks
control 20% of banking in the US and 20% of all its industry. This vast
empire of wealth and power is built to grow, to self -perpetuate, to entangle
everywhere on earth that it can. It feeds on domination over the people; its
social policies are welfare cuts, stop and frisk, drug detention laws. It
dislocates whole populations from our cities for the construction of huge
monuments to the god profit, to commerce and world trade. It meets
rebellion —as at Attica— with. I.he iron heel. The Masnicks’ policies exist
for the continued emmlseratlon of most of humanity and the continued
spiral of concentration of power and wealth into their hands.

They arc not l he only ones. The heads of CNN and MSNBC
each receive yearly salaries of almost Si ,000,000, vet one third of the US
people are considered poor by the government’s figures. We measured the
energy crisis by cold houses, sick, children and lost jobs, while the oil
companies increased their profits over last year by as much as 130%.

This irrational and revolting system leaves much social wealth
wasted and undeveloped. T liat is produced bears little relationship to what is
needed. For this reason Marxist-Leninists speak 01 the "anarchy of
production" when we refer to the wav productive forces are organized under
imperialism. The great, injustice of this system is (.hat. it leaves its potential
unrealized while maintaining scarcity for billions of people.

All economic activity that does not go to satisfy human need is
waste. Advertising and marketing (a 830 billion a year business), useless
consumer goods, planned obsolescence, bureaucracy, the military -all aspects
of waste- add up to the social cost of maintaining this outmoded system. It
is working people and the oppressed of empire who bear the cost.

Eat the Masnicks!

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

Anonymous Coward says:

This is a stupid idea from the POTUS administration.

That being said, the left wing has brought this on themselves. If you don’t want a backlash from real Americans, leftists, don’t silence patriots’ voices.

The left is seeing the results of this in Atlanta with hashtag-BlueFlu … which seems to be rapidly evolving nationwide into hashtag-WhiteStrike.

When Minneapolis and other cities where treasonous city leaders are bending the knee to Burn-Loot-Murder BLM demands to defund police departments turn into CHAZ-style ‘Escape From New York’ scenarios, it will again be leftists bringing it on themselves.

Rishtzq (user link) says:

hot viet girls

Ontario’s winter storm cleanup required to take all week

Cow acts such as a very sweet doggyFlossey is living a wonderful life on a beautiful farm in Millbrook, Ontario. It precisely what is knows an "honest farm" Where cows have space to roam and graze regarding being kept indoors for most of their lives. Flossey farm has immense expanses of lush, bright green grass, rolling hills, Ponds full of fresh water, And forested areas for colouring. This is life as it ought to be for these gentle creatures. Dave is a farm hand who often helps out with selected chores and animal care. ‘re feeling the housing crunch more than most, With rising rental costs exceeding fixed incomes for those on pensions or social counselling. pretty much ask Valerie Arsenault. The Charlottetown woman landlord took the names of countless renters at the Kensington Road apartment building where she lives, put them into a hat and drew one out. the "safe bet" Would have to quit his or her unit so that his son could move into it. the actual "whys" Are variable: sustainability and worry for the planet, Health factors, Ethical concerns over the treatment of animals. One more and more popular option is "location based meat, that you can get from grocery store meat sections to restaurants. they aim to imitate meat in taste, different textures, look and feel and smell, And the similarities are now pretty impressive. the constituents usually include a plant based protein,The Canadian PressFord holds main housing summit, Promises funding to help cities cut red tapeTORONTO Ontario largest communities will get new funding to help speed up development approvals, Premier Doug Ford announced as he hosted a housing summit friday, But the municipal leaders he met with say much superior action is needed. Ford said his goal for the virtual meeting with big city mayors and regional chairs was to get concrete ways to allow more families to buy a home. "as the solutions may seem obvious, Implementing them takes a lot of hard work and willpower,AdLithium bargains Outperforming the S 500 by 8:1An historic shift to everything electric is triggering an unparalleled boom in lithium demand, Sending prices climbing 88.4% finished so far in 2021.The Canadian PressHarris will go Honduras for president inaugurationWASHINGTON (AP) vice president Kamala Harris will travel to Honduras next week to attend the inauguration of President elect Xiomara Castro, The Central American country’s first female ceo. Harris has been tasked by President Joe Biden with the hefty job of finding solutions on immigration at the Southwest border. Tens of thousands of Hondurans with you with other Central American migrants come to the border every month seeking a better life. Border officials stopped migrants more than 1.7 miRetailers adjust to second COVID seasonal, Predict slump in winter salesGUYSBOROUGH Just as the xmas shopping season was hitting its stride in mid December, The Omicron variant of COVID 19 also began to master in Nova Scotia, allowing the fourth and worst wave of the pandemic to date in the province. establishments rely on Christmas shopping to boost revenues, Especially in a year that as sporadic as 2021. And Nova Scotia retailers had every reason you may anticipate lucrative December sales. mathematically Canada, Retail sales have been solidly heaThe Canadian PressMATCHDAY: Ronaldo eyes return for united; Atltico in actionA look at what’s happening in European soccer on saturday: ENGLAND Cristiano Ronaldo could return for manchester united in the Premier League game at Brentford after missing the team last two games with a hip injury. The Portugal forward has trained going back two days and should be available, executive Ralf Rangnick said. United lost a two goal lead to draw 2 2 at Aston Villa on Saturday and is languishing in seventh place. Tottenham is a point ahead in sixth place heading into a matchAustralia calls on backpackers to help ease Omicron fuelled labour shortageAustralia threw out an invite to backpackers on Wednesday, Seeking reinforcements for a workforce crippled by an Omicron COVID 19 outbreak as the health system creaks under the pandemic strain with more deaths predicted in weeks ahead. prime minister Scott Morrison said his government was waiving the A$630 ($453) Visa application fee for any backpacker or student who arrives in Australia over the following 12 weeks, And encouraged them to see work as they tour the. "Come on down now reside wanted to [url= women date[/url] come to Australia, Morrison said during a televised press seminar.specific Canadian PressQuebec, Ontario representatives express cautious COVID optimism, Others brace for the worstOfficials in Quebec and Ontario said they saw signs of hope on Tuesday that the peak of COVID 19 hospitalizations could soon be behind them despite both provinces setting new admissions records while other governing bodies braced for new hardships. Ontario Premier Doug Ford told Ottawa radio station CFRA that his government may announce a plan to reduce COVID 19 limitations in the coming days, Even as a lot of patients with the disease in the province hospitals reached a new summit. "pposite.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...