Lucasfilm Disputes Empire Brewing's 'Strikes Bock' Trademark Application
from the the-power-of-the-dark-side dept
Here we go again. For some reason, alcohol products, particularly beer, seem to make everyone go trademark crazy. This latest case concerns Empire Brewing Company out of New York (you know, the “Empire State”) and their latest brew released in bottle form, called “Strikes Bock.” Do you already know where this is going? I’m pretty sure you already know where this is going.
Lucasfilm has filed a trademark dispute with a small brewery in Syracuse, New York. Empire Brewing Co., named after New York’s Empire State Building, recently applied for a trademark for its signature lager, Strikes Bock, according to Syracuse.com. The Star Wars producer contends Empire’s beer infringes on Lucasfilm trademarks and could be used to deceive consumers or cause brand confusion.
Of course, Lucasfilm, now featuring a litigation supercharger in the form of Disney ownership, has filed a trademark dispute. As best as the internet can tell me, there is no such thing as a Star Wars beer produced by Lucasfilm. As the trademark opposition itself notes, the trademark that Lucasfilm has is for “toys, games, apparel, video/computer games, personal-care products, paints, trading cards, confections, prerecorded films and music, books, magazines, music and entertainment services.” I don’t see beer. Or any other kinds of beverages. The best Lucasfilm can come up with in its opposition filings is that Lucasfilm licensed the “Skywalker” name to Skywalker Vineyards, which makes Skywalker wines. But it still seems like a stretch to argue there’s a likelihood of confusion here, rather than just a basic homage to the film.
“The thing is the beer is called ‘Strikes Bock,’ not ‘Empire Strikes Bock,’” Empire Brewing Co. owner David Katleski said. “It’s ‘Strikes Bock,’ by Empire.”
That may sound like a minor difference, but add to it the fact that Empire Brewing Company’s name is not in itself under dispute and their logos and packaging to date are in no way similar to any Star Wars films, and what we end up with is an obvious nod to the film — one which won’t cause any brand confusion — that’s being disputed by Lucasfilm just to be a pain in the ass. It’s worth noting, by the way, that Strikes Bock certainly isn’t the only such craft beer nod. Here’s a list of some more, including my favorite.
Katleski has hired a lawyer, but he also acknowledges his small brewery doesn’t have the money to contend with Lucasfilm in the long run if they decide to throw their money behind this. Of course, there is a reasonable flip side to this, which is that if they’re just such a small brewery, why did the company even bother filing for a trademark in the first place? The company doesn’t need the trademark to sell the beer. It could easily rely on common law trademark instead of getting a registered one, saving it some money (and calling in the attention of Lucasfilm/Disney lawyers). In the end, though, we just have another trademark dispute that doesn’t seem to serve any real benefit to anyone.