HBO Go Goes Everywhere… Except Your TV Set
from the pls-stop-using-our-services-in-unexpected-ways-kthx dept
Oh, HBO. You want so many people to love you. And they do, shelling out for additional offerings like HBO Go in order to take the shows they love with them on their mobile devices. And what do you do with this love? You crush it. You crush it like a heartless Lothario parting ways with a high-school girlfriend after a quick round under the bleachers, announcing “I’m going to college out of state. Call you sometime,” leaving her half-dressed, teary-eyed and a bit dusty.
The issue has been knocking around for awhile, but today, the unfortunate high school girlfriend was Fred Wilson, respected blogger and venture capitalist.
I put the awesome HBO GO app on the family's iPad yesterday and tried to Airplay into our family room TV. I got audio on the TV but not video. I thought I was doing something wrong. So I rebooted everything and tried again. Same thing.
So I did a web search on the topic to see what was going on. Turns out HBO GO has disabled the video on Airplay but not the audio. That's right. They disabled the video but include an Airplay button in the app.
Why would someone do this? Why brick half the service and leave end users scratching their heads and casting about wildly over at the Apple support forums?
The “why” is the usual “why.” Or rather, two usual “whys.” The first “why” is somewhat of a licensing issue. HBO really doesn’t want to do anything to jeopardize its relationship with the studios and cable companies, so it’s limited the functionality of the Go app to mobile devices only. HBO wants you to use HBO On Demand if its current slate of programs isn’t working for you. I would imagine there’s a revenue stream hidden there, but taking advantage of it would mean damaging some valuable relationships. In HBO’s view, Go isn’t broken because fixing it would break something more valuable.
The second “why” is piracy, or rather, the fear of. From the comment thread at AVC:
Having developed these sort of systems before, I can tell you it's because AirPlay is considered an insecure protocol. It's too easy to capture the AirPlay stream and thus, in theory, create HD copies of the video. That's why they don't do it.
I've found that the cryptographic particularities don't always matter when you're in discussions with the studios. They have a list of approved DRMs and technologies and you're either on the list or you're not. Otherwise, you face at least a 6+ month in depth technical review of the stack.
TL;DR: The studios can be somewhat arbitrary in approving or disproving technologies. Last I heard, AirPlay was not approved.
Even if HBO wanted you to have this freedom (and it’s not necessarily clear that it does), it still has to keep the upstream (studios) happy. And if the studios think there’s a possibility that the TV you’re streaming to is actually some sort of unauthorized recording device (like a VCR made out of hard drives?), it’s never going to get the green light.
The next question is this: why put an Airplay button in your app if it’s completely (or at least, mostly) unusable? No real answer is available. Perhaps the hope is that at some point the button will work. Or developer cruelty.
The whole situation is clearly ridiculous and highlights just how incestuous all these services (cable companies, movie studios, premium channels) are. HBO can’t piss off the up and downstream sides of the equation, so it locks down anything that might be perceived as “leaving money on the table.” The combined fear of piracy between these three entities (well, two of them anyway) is likely verging on “unmeasurable.” This results in some very arbitrary restrictions created in the name of copy protection.
Caught in the middle is the cheerleader/consumer. HBO Go requires having an active cable account. The cable box (an additional monthly charge) only provides access to HBO On Demand (another additional monthly charge). Then there’s HBO Go itself (another additional charge). It’s tough to see much more than couch cushion change being left on the table in this situation.
And why do people want to stream HBO Go to their TVs? Because of HBO itself. HBO’s On Demand selection is very limited as compared to HBO Go. On top of that, many users seem to feel that HBO Go’s interface is better and more easily navigated. So, if it’s all paid for, why is this feature bricked?
See above. Piracy fears. Fear of upsetting the balance between the three related parties. But further than that, it’s the inability to recognize that users and customers will want to use your products and services in ways you never intended.
To HBO, it’s likely inconceivable that someone would want to stream to a device and kick it right back to the TV set where its other content resides. But they do. And they’re going to find ways to work around this limitation. When these roadblocks become easily circumvented, rather than realize that these efforts are made to make paid services work the way the customer wants them to, the content providers usually start worrying about their loss of distribution control. This worry leads to less innovation and more disabled features and bogus restrictions.
What they need to be doing (HBO, studios, cable providers) is taking long looks at these complaints and adjusting their offerings to better fit customer expectations. Consider yourself lucky you’re still able to monetize nearly every aspect of these services and look to improve your current offerings. Do this often enough and you may learn to anticipate customer wants and needs. If you’re looking to keep the food chain happy and trim down on “unauthorized” viewing, your best bet is to get to the “anticipation” point as quickly as you can.
Filed Under: hbo go, restrictions, tv
Companies: hbo
Comments on “HBO Go Goes Everywhere… Except Your TV Set”
It’s too easy to capture the AirPlay stream and thus, in theory, create HD copies of the video.
Because those HD copies don’t already exist within an hour (maybe two) of the show airing already…
Re:
Because those HD copies don’t already exist within an hour (maybe two) of the show airing already…
Considering their own statistics and personal experience, it isn’t the ones that exist within an hour that they should be concerned about, but the ones that appear 8 hours before the show airs anywhere, because a friend of a friend got a copy from a friend that knew someone in the production company.
I wish they would just give up on DRM already. They are only fooling themselves when they think DRM prevents infringement, since everyone else knows it happens regardless to DRM. The only way they are going to stop it is to give their customer a chance to buy it using a fair (to the customer) process.
Look on the bright side though...
At least my user experience wasn’t harmed by using non-approved software to do some non-approved use of the hardware I purchased, and the content I pay for.
Always assume your customers are thieves and eventually you’ll be right.
This is yet another reason why so many people download their shows off the internet for free. This actually encourages piracy. Unbelievable!
I tried this with HDMI out from my Droid Bionic. I got “This application does not allow HDMI out” or something to that effect. Disappointing really. Spent the next hour and half watching a movie on my couch on my 4.3 inch screen while the TV just looked on disapprovingly.
Xbox
HBOGo is available on the Xbox, so you can get it on your TV. I suspect eventually it will make it to other devices. I too was annoyed by this. Comcast on demand didn’t have all the true blood episodes, and I wanted to watch them on my TV.
I did get it to work using Parrot TV, but it looked like shit.
You know nothing, HBO
Re:
What you don’t understand* is that DRM isn’t supposed to stop piracy. It’s just supposed to stop average users that don’t understand computers** from pirating the latest movie. That is why we still need DRM.
* Because, you know, you must be a pirate or something
** and have no friends…or any kids in the family
/Take deep breath
/Laugh Out Loud
Re: Re:
At this point I think the studios understand that DRM does not story piracy but that’s not it’s main function any more. Since they’ve got laws passed that make it illegal to break locks on content they effectively have a veto on any new technology. If they don’t like something all they have to do is add a flimsy lock that breaks the system and that system becomes illegal.
All the talk about piracy is just the excuse to try and maintain this level of control in the hopes they can codify their current business models into law. Which means that as crazy as it may sound I don’t think the people on the other side of this debate are as stupid as they come across when it comes to these issues.
I think they now understand that piracy is effectively a none issue but they’ve learnt just how much of a powerful tool the fear of piracy is in advancing their goals. Which are sadly based on the idea that they will do anything to get their way and not caring about the fall out of their actions. If they go down they are willing to take everything down with them.
To support AirPlay, the execs would need to be not sticking their heads in the ground. Perhaps we should invent TunnelPlay or something… =P
Re:
But they don’t want “fair (to the customer)”, they want “what we consider fair”. Hence, DRM, which filters out all the people who don’t want to pay what they’re asking, don’t want to jump through the hurdles they decide to put in the way, are in the wrong country, etc, leaving just the obedient customers who will pay what they ask, how they ask, and will “go without” when they decide that they should.
The fact that the rest of them are still getting the product, but are now not paying *anything* is, of course, then pointed out to politicians as justification to turn the Internet into Cable TV.
When you look at it correctly, DRM makes perfect sense.
Why is HBO GO available on Roku HD, but not Apple TV?
Who Cares?
Let them sort out how best to protect their revenue streams. While they are working on that I will continue to use all the free alternatives that stream their programming.
Guess what? We the consumer now understand the safe harbor law and that we are not doing anything illegal by linking to infringing material.
I’m wondering how pissing off the paying customers is protecting the revenue stream. It must work like trickle-down economics.
I’m laughing because I just watched John Adams and Boardwalk Empire, which I got free from my public library. Who needs piracy?
Who Cares?
Unless you’re in England, where it’s legal, then the US would like to have a talk with you
by the time people have paid out for everything, costing a full arm and leg, to achieve almost nothing in the way of a service, not only is it a much cheaper and better option to ‘pirate’, is it any real wonder why people get driven to do so? the studios are their own worse enemy, not in the least because of being so damn greedy but for being as thick as fuck! instead of gaining some revenue, they lose the lot! no sympathy with them at all!!
Re:
Also, HBO Go works out of the box with Google TV. This smells like an Apple issue, not an HBO one. This time.
Re: Re:
as pointed out above it also works fine on an xbox360
cancel your HBO subscription and tell them why.
you can complain, suggest and rant online as much as you want, but as long as you are paying, they don’t care.
cancel. turn off HBO/Showtime/Etc. Hell, turn off your cable if you want to be bold. but turn it off.
or.
just keep ranting online. because nothing will change.
Re: Re:
People affected by this are the minority. It would not affect their bottom line much, if everyone trying to stream HBO Go to a TV canceled at the same time. Internet rants can become Internet movements, which has a greater, albeit still small, chance of resolving the issue.
Re: Re: Re:
In contrast to voting, where there are myriad ways to make your vote meaningless, voting with your dollars always counts for full effect, one dollar of effect per dollar spent or not spent.
Re: Re: Re: Re:
Absolutely true.
Remember, folks, corporations exist to make a profit. They are amoral engines of economic production. The dollar is the only force they listen to.
Every dollar you spend is a vote for them to continue with whatever their policies are, for better or worse. If you don’t like their policies, stop voting for them.
Re: Re:
I disconnected the cable cord from my tv and stopped watching over 2 years ago. Unfortunately, the people I live with still subscribe. Drives me insane to constantly be hearing someone’s tv blaring.
No thanks HBO I will pay for a VPN first. Money well spent.
HB who?
Enough with the “Rube Goldberg Machine” solutions and the crap that the dying industry foists on people. Ignore them and move on. Let other people suffer the grief and let the problem companies just die as their sucker market shrivels up and dies.
If you must have usable video content (then you really need a life, but) torrents are a good way to get some.
BTW: I can’t get to tpb by domain name or primary ip today (a rare problem in last 10 years or so where I am), but it could just be a hiccup (www.checksite.us says it is accessible from their US location}. Alternate ip http://194.71.107.80 works fine, though. Just point your browser at http://194.71.107.80 and you’re at tpb.
Meh, this is why I refuse to use anything other than an HTPC, bypass all of this nonsense with the standalone boxes or anything to do with Apple.
If it can play on a PC, it can play on a PC with an HDTV as the monitor.
HBO
I tried this with HDMI out from my Droid Bionic. I got “This application does not allow HDMI out” or something to that effect. Disappointing really
Look on the bright side though...
Because harming the use experience through approved means is so much better. At least to those who do the approving, anyhow.
Let’s see, so Airplay is not approved, but DHCP which I can order onliner ight now, an HDMI cable for a couple dollars to strip DHCP from the output, and that’s their idea of secure?
Ah, sorry, I just got it. They CARE about the pirates. See, the guy recording and encoding the shows to put online only needs an inexpensive cord to simply record the show, instead of doing some crazy hocus pocus wiz-bang thing to record a show and potentially even losing quality much less their time. How kind of HBO
Re:
Then you factor in how easily it’s beaten, DRM is worse than worthless.
Tried TPB one last night. Nice but give an IP in Sweden. Used one from GB to watch olympics and BBC. Fuck you NBC your coverage sucked bad. Beyond sucked. Dont need or want your commentary.
Re:
You sir, just made my day. My employer will be hitting you up for the bill to clean my keyboard.
works on my XBOX just fine
not too big a deal here I think, HBO go works on my XBOX just fine.
The funny part
The funny part about all of this is that you are still forced to have a cable subscription. If you have a cable subscription then you’ve already got your ready made escape hatch.
You can simply record from your cable box.
Use a PC HD analog tuner. Record the analog signal. Do what you want with it.
This is how my own not-a-Tivo setup works.
Although I skip the HBO subscription and just buy DVDs.
There is also Netflix. Got 2 GoT BDs at home right now.
All of these can yield files free of restrictions that can be copied to or played on any device.
Who Cares?
Since when has being in a country where an action is legal been any defense against the US? If they can’t ‘persuade’ the other government to change the laws to make what you’ve done illegal, they’ll just lean on the government to deport you over.
Re: Who Cares?
and if that doesn’t work, we got bombs, navy seals and if none of that works then we threaten send Mitt Romney over there to speak….
Re: Re: Who Cares?
Sarah Palin would be a more credible threat… just sayin
The funny part
Exactly. I do the same thing, only I have HBO cause I don’t wanna wait a year for GoT True Blood and Newsroom. Now that they are over though, I may cancel till next April.
Re:
you are right, rants have gotten things moving before.
but i stand by what i said, speak with your money. stop paying for it and tell them why you are stopping. tell your friends to do the same.
keep the issue vocal, but stand by it with your money. otherwise their subscribership stays high and they don’t see an issue.
Re:
Trust me, the TV networks view you as a pirate, a reluctant one.
Re:
They also view everyone watching the cable stream who isnt the individual paying for it a freeloader.
Wired no better than wireless
I bought an HD out dongle for my iPad so my daughter can watch her netflix shows on the big screen. When i tried using it with HBO Go it said that app was not authorized to use HD out.
Let me get this straight: i can only use the app if i subscribe to your channel, but i can’t watch video from the app on the same HD tv that the subscription service feeds?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qileP4bAzek
P.S. Dear HBO, stop putting un-skippable ads for your other shows in front of stuff i watch on HBO Go. You already have my money. Making me watch ads for other stuff i already have access to makes me LESS likely to keep giving you my money, not more.
Re:
I’m a pirate? Thanks to the U.S. Government.
Wired no better than wireless
Of course you can, you just can’t do it on every device under the sun. As an Apple fan you should be use to a highly restrictive walled garden environment.
Re: Wired no better than wireless
As an Apple fan you should be use to a highly restrictive walled prison environment
fixed that for you.
I always wondered, what stops someone with a working cable subscription (with HBO) from posting it and having others use that info just to unlock HBO GO without having to spring for cable or HBO?
Re:
They do just ask Google…no wait….
Re:
You doubt that increasing your costs in order to decrease the value of your product is a viable business model ? Then you sir, must be a pirate!
Re:
Technically not free, seeing as your taxes pay for that library and its contents. But good idea either way.
Circumventing
I don’t have HBO on my DirecTV, but my friend does. And he has HBOgo too. He comes over to my house sometimes, and using my computer, logs into HBOgo and we can watch Game of Thrones or True Blood, (20 min after it airs) on my 46″ TV set up as a monitor on one input, and having DTV on another input.
HBO loses money on me, since I don’t have their services on my TV, yet I get them with an HBOgo account. (Which they don’t sell separately)
So I can certainly see their point. But I still think their point is ridiculous.
Re: Circumventing
So if you couldn’t watch using your friend’s HBO Go account, would you subscribe to HBO? If not, then HBO isn’t losing a dime on you.
Re:
True, but it’s the best subscription service out there.
so no airplay…… but it works just fine with a HDMI cord from my laptop. Some people are just idiots.
Thank goodness that they don’t allow Airplay! Otherwise people might be able to download 720p copies of their shows, 10 minutes after they air!
WTF
Since when does adding restrictions stop piracy? Why pay the $20 a month or what ever for HBO then all the additional charges for the streaming when you get locked out when you can pirate it for free? You want piracy to stop? Give affordable options that are on par with what the pirates offer. Right now, they are not.
What is the point of HBO GO
Don’t you think that if HBO GO was offered for a price as a stand alone product that HBO would get rid of the half the pirates? Because I would pay for it if it was the right price. But honestly, they just want you to watch on tv only.
I have yet to figure out why people want to watch anything on such a small screen.
For years we have been bombarded with ads to get the biggest flat panel screen we can fit in our living rooms for the “movie theater experience” at home.
Now we’re supposed to take it with us everywhere we go so we can stop in to our local Starbucks and watch a movie or TV show and consume tons of data that we all complain about being too expensive and capped because we’re using too much!
Then on top of all that you subscribe to HBO via cable or satellite that you say you want to cut, to watch on your big screen and then complain because the extra money that you pay for HBOgo doesn’t allow you to watch it on your big screen where it already exists!
Then at the end of the day you you come home all tired out from a long day at work and feel like you been running in circles all day.
YA THINK!
The execs at HBO that figured all this out gotta be laughing their asses off right about now watching the dog chase it’s tail
Re: Re:
HBOgo offers content that isn’t on most cable/sat providers ondemand service.
DTV recently reworked their HBO on demand to include most of what HBOgo offers, but not everything, plus the UI for it is horrible.
Its also about convienence. Convienence trumps quallity/size for the majority of people.
Case in point: Audio DVD/SACD were high quality, but MP3s were way more convienent…MP3 won that format war.
Being able to watch everywhere/anywhere is worth more to people than being tied to a big screen in their living room. Personally for most shows I prefer watching them on my laptop next to my pond in the nice afternoon air than locked away indoors. Only the very best content like Game of thrones gets the big screen treatment.
HBO Go - Not a go unless on Apple TV
Ok so yes I have an X Box and yes I can stream HBO Go through it in 720, I want it in 1080 on my Apple TV. Apple TV is in need of some more Apps. I’m already paying for HBO – it’s on a Roku player, Xbox 360, PS3 etc, why not Apple TV? If I could get a standalone HBO account I would drop cable like a bad habit. So tired of paying a ton of money every month for the 5 channels I want to watch.
It's not about stream security...
At least not the technical security of AirPlay vs. another format. I have an HDMI output on my iphone/ipad, and the HBOGo app will not output video that way either.
They actually do know that TV is the preferred viewing format, so it’s not the content providers they are worried about offending (after all, they own a lot of their own content and could approve that on a file-by-file basis), it’s the downstream distribution apparatus they have trouble with. Streaming from a tablet to your TV threatens the need for cable/satellite TV. Some people would never buy cable but for its requirement to get HBO. If you could replace your cable box with an iPad, it would accelerate the demand for a streaming-only subscription (as others have already demanded in this thread), and that would cost cable providers bigtime.
HBO is going to be one of the longest holdouts on this not only because they depend on the sales efforts of the cable companies, but because they have a complex relationship with TimeWarner cable, one of the largest cable providers in the world. They are no longer owned precisely together, but still have very close ties and many of the same shareholders.
Finally, there’s always the issue of having a password passed around. They are afraid that one person will subscribe to cable and 12 people all over the country will login to use that one subscription.
AirPlay
Is on the way. Early next year. From a very reliable insider.
any recent update regarding HBO Channel?
YOU CAN FIX THIS DONT BUY THERE TV OR RECORDERS
HBO and Netflix suck
Since when did the definition of “any device” mean only pathetic corporate devices?