Poland Prime Minister Suspends Any Effort To Ratify ACTA; May Kill ACTA In The EU

from the don't-piss-of-the-net dept

This is getting interesting. Following the growing protests about ACTA in Europe, as well as signs of US meddling, Poland’s prime minister is making it clear that Poland will not ratify ACTA for the time being, leading to speculation that the EU may not actually join ACTA.

Tusk’s backtracking could spell the end of ACTA for the entire European Union. If Poland or any other EU member state, or the European Parliament itself, fails to ratify the document, it becomes null and void across the union. As it stands, there are already five member countries that have not even signed ACTA.

“I share the opinions of those who from the beginning said that consultations were not complete,” Tusk said, according to a report in Wirtualna Polska. The 54-year-old prime minister added that a Polish rejection of ACTA is now on the table, and admitted that he had previously approached the agreement from a “20th century” perspective, due to his age.

Filed Under: , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Poland Prime Minister Suspends Any Effort To Ratify ACTA; May Kill ACTA In The EU”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Chris From Poland says:

Tusk cannot END the ratification process, just postpone it for later. Our media are questioning his declaration because in fact it changes nothing. ACTA will have to be voted on regardless, just a bit later. Most of the media think that Tusk is just counting on the fact that people will forget about the entire situation and stop protesting. So he’s doing some damage control, but the danger of ACTA being passed is still on the horizon.

Tom from Poland says:

Re: Re: Re:

Parliament is the one to vote so yes, representatives will be under presser from the public.

But.. Tusk is a very skilled player and a great PR-ist so this won’t be as easy as people think based on the today’s declaration by Tusk. He has already managed to complaint on his officials, which is a clear sign of a heavy PR being turned on – this is his routine trick, like in the old Russia where Tzar was always the good guy, only officials were evil.

Raphael (profile) says:

Re: Re:

Agreed, thanks for the clarification. I’m optimistic that a lot of us have signed up for this game of whack-a-maximalist for the long haul. It’s good exercise of the ol’ democracy, and I think everyone has an eye on the fluffy public domain plush hanging over the counter when the machine starts spitting out tickets.

Alex V says:

Re: Re:

Well, if you follow the link in the ZDNet article to the article in WirtualnaPolska that the debate over ACTA “may need to revise the traditional concept of property rights, in a situation where the traditional internet turned reality upside down.”

The is the first time I’ve heard a politician from any country say that.

Tom from Poland says:

Re: Re: Re:

I would also be happy with that statement if I didn’t knew how great PR player he is – it’s almost clear to me that it’s a statement baked by his propagandists to make the protesters calm down.

Note that the people protesting in Poland were mostly young people that voted for Tusk in recent elections, so he is now in a damage control mode – and will say everything that’s needed to re-gain as much support from them as possible.

Kevin H (profile) says:

This is why we need Wikileaks and other services like them. I want every communication between Washington DC and Embassies abroad that have to do with ACTA in any way shape or form. I want to know what was said, and who said it. The only way to end this kind of public usurping is to bring these backdoor deals into the light and let the people see what they are doing. If its casts a bad light on us then so be it. We shouldn’t have been doing it in the first place.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re:

“I want every communication between Washington DC and Embassies abroad that have to do with ACTA in any way shape or form. I want to know what was said, and who said it. The only way to end this kind of public usurping is to bring these backdoor deals into the light and let the people see what they are doing. “

Your absolutely right. The stuff politicans argue about in public is peanuts compared to the real deals being made behind our backs under the guise of “trade agreements”.

Start a petition about requesting documents concerning ACTA. A newspaper or magazine should be on the trail for FOIA documents.

Ima Fish (profile) says:

Re: Kill the Bill

Maximizing copyright has nothing to do with saving or creating jobs. That’s just BS politicians say to ensure their cut.

Politicians give out rights to collect monopoly rents, and in exchange, the politicians get to keep some of the gravy for themselves. This scam has been going on for over a century, it’s just that the tax payers are finally getting sick of it.

farooge (profile) says:

ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha; it’s over

is the ‘k st’ area suitable for heavy industry? can we beg Bill Gates and Google to buy it up and encourage industry to put some union jobs there (free beer and public transportation from 1700 to 0300 on fri & sat!?!)? wouldn’t that be awesome?

they could offer dibs on the choice positions to out of work lobbyists. you know, something they’re actually qualified for (and, if you think like me, their karma _probably_ says they deserve) like bumper installing for one of those people who drive the cars off the line

this is so much faster than i ever dreamed possible

last thing – thanks Poland.

(yea, it’s _always_ 1/2 full …)

Chris From Poland says:

Tusk and his political party lost 5% support overall in the last two weeks and an entire 17% among the youngest voters and those not yet allowed to vote. He’s doing damage control for his own political benefit, but nevertheless, this might in fact lead to a reform of copyright law in poland. Our minister of culture has acknowleged that the law in this regard is outdated. Furthermore, an academic study “Obiegi Kultury” (an english version is forthcoming) (http://www.obiegikultury.centrumcyfrowe.pl/) has proven beyond all doubt on a representative group of Polish people that those who download media off the internet are the same people who BUY the most media in stores and are the most culurally active overall. Now everyone is quoting this academic study against copyright maximalists. Our equivalent of the RIAA in Poland is ZAiKS and it seems to be losing its arguments due to this study. In fact, ZAiKS fucked up several years ago by trying to make people pay for playing Creative Commons music in public places (pubs, clubs, etc.). So there’s a HUGE backlash against copyright maximalism among the 15-35 age group and among voters and politicians are beginning to see this in the voting polls.

Chris From Poland says:

We don’t have a Pirate Party… yet :-). I mean, we do, theoretically… But they’re just an organization and they have a blog, but I’m not even sure if they’re registered as as political party and they sure aren’t in the Parliament… So we don’t have a REAL Pirate Party, but we sure will soon :-). The people have woken up.

s. keeling says:

Re: Re:

Polish jokes don’t offend us. We too have our American and Russian jokes, so to each his own ๐Ÿ™‚

I read the same thing on slashdot.org last night from another Pole when I was reading about this there. It was quite a rousing discussion with quite a few Poles contributing, and very positive, anti-ACTA just like this one (not to take anything away from TD :-).

Thanks Chris for the report, and I hope for the best for yourself, Poland, and the EU. Much appreciated.

Chris From Poland says:

The “few students” represent a 17% of the voting population. A “to be or not to be” for a political party. This isn’t just a minor protest group, but a generational movement.

But yes, the particular protest I linked to was the smallest one I’ve seen. It was more of an “afterparty” to the proper protest.

Daria says:

Re: Re:

Chris, thank you! This video has made my day! I had no idea that so many people protested in Poland, mainly because the mainstream media never reported any of it. It’s strange how all TV stations decided, independently of course, to completely ignore the protests all over Europe. They talk about the “horrible winter” that has befallen us for 30 minutes, but not a pip about ACTA in the past week. This bury-your-head-in-the-sand-and-hope-it-goes-away approach is getting absolutely ridiculous. Some articles have appeared in the online press, but they’re mostly “neutral”. I shared your link on Facebook and encouraged my friends to do the same. Hats off to Poland! Hope we’ll be able to match you on Saturday!

Chris From Poland says:

ACTA itself does not introduce particular laws for copyright enforcement. What it does is it confines the framework of copyright enforcement possibilities to particular solutions which are in its spirit, so it PETRIFIES the state of law so that no other solutions which would contradict ACTA could ever be put forward. So YES, ACTA does not introduce particular laws, but the countries themselves will have to, on the basis of ACTA, introduce such laws to make their laws compatible with ACTA. So when ACTA passes, there will be no means of ever backtracking from copyright maximalism and liberalizing the law.

s. keeling says:

Re: Re:

… but the countries themselves will have to, on the basis of ACTA, introduce such laws to make their laws compatible with ACTA.

Worse, once all the backroom dealing on ACTA is done, then ACTA signatories can bash all those nations not a party to it to conform or face sanctions, yada, yada. Lots of innocent nations were not invited and are not party to ACTA discussions. They will be subject to the result.

Chris From Poland says:

Daria – most EU countries have SIGNED ACTA, but none have RATIFIED it. A proposal of law needs to be ratified for it to become law. The signing process itself is a “promise” of ratification, but politicians can change their mind, or HAVE THEIR MIDS CHANGED if enough people make enough of a fuss. And believe me, we are making a fuss :-).

Daria says:


I know, Chris, that’s what I was trying to clarify as well – that the countries have signed, but not ratified ACTA and that we can still make a difference. (Maybe I wasn’t very good at it :p) I’ve seen you guys protest in Poland (thanks for the link, by the way) and it was quite a sight to see – congratulations and thank you for everything you’re doing. I’m hoping we’ll be able to match you this Saturday.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop ยป

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...