Phony Bologna: More Evidence Of Indiscriminate Pepper Spraying, As Police Defend Actions

from the just-admit-he-screwed-up dept

NYPD Deputy Inspector Anthony Bologna remains in the news, even as the NYPD ramped up their “arrest the protesters” campaign this weekend. After all of the video evidence that he randomly pepper sprayed some women at the OccupyWallStreet protests, the NYPD Commissioner Ray Kelly has said that the Internal Affair Bureau would open an investigation into the actions. But at the same time, he defended Bologna’s actions. Of course, at about the same time he was doing this, a second video came out, once again showing Bologna appearing to indiscriminately pepper spray people, including a credentialed photojournalist (wearing his credentials around his neck).

So how is Kelly defending this? First, he blames the protesters for “tumultuous conduct.” I’ve already said that I don’t really think much of the overall protest, but the video evidence doesn’t suggest that those who were pepper sprayed were involved in any such “tumultuous conduct.” Later Kelly said that the group was “disorderly” and “intent on blocking traffic,” and that could justify the use of pepper spray. That seems like a huge stretch. Again, the individuals who were sprayed appear to have been chosen at random.

The NYPD Deputy Inspector Roy Richter, who is basically Bologna’s “union representative” is defending Bologna’s actions thusly:

?Deputy Inspector Bologna’s actions that day were motivated by his concern for the safety of officers under his command and the safety of the public. The limited use of pepper spray effectively restored order without any escalation of force or serious injury to either demonstrator or police officer.?

Someone else at the police department had another cover story:

A law enforcement official familiar with Inspector Bologna?s account of what occurred, however, said he was not aiming at the four women who appeared in videos to have sustained the brunt of the spray. Rather, he was trying to spray some men who he believed were pushing up against officers and causing a confrontation that put officers at risk of injury, the official said.

“The intention was to place them under arrest, but they fled,” the official said.

Given how many videos of the scene and surrounding areas have been shown, it’s amazing anyone can claim that with a straight face. There was no indication of these “others.” There was no indication of any attempt to arrest others near the women. If Bologna was aiming at these mythical men, he’s a terrible shot, because he hit those women he wasn’t aiming for point blank.

In the meantime, the folks at remind us that Bologna wasn’t the only police officer using random “escalation” techniques. They point out this video of an NYPD officer purposely tripping a protester who already appeared to be in the control of multiple officers. Of course, the act of tripping the guy makes it look like he’s trying to resist arrest.

Of course, once again, all of this is caught on video. It really makes you wonder if all of this kind of video evidence is finally going to lead police to recognize that they actually have to behave and follow the law themselves.

Filed Under: , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Phony Bologna: More Evidence Of Indiscriminate Pepper Spraying, As Police Defend Actions”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
MrWilson says:

Re: Re: Time for a few federal arrests.

From the FBI Website, emphasis mine:

“The FBI investigates violations of federal civil rights statutes and supports the investigations of state and local authorities in certain cases. Federal civil rights violations fall into several categories: hate crimes motivated by bias against such characteristics as race, religion, national origin, and sexual orientation; color of law crimes involving law enforcement and related criminal justice professionals? misuse of their right to discretion, such as use of excessive force or police misconduct;”


DCX2 says:

Re: Again

Covering up for the “bad apples” makes you an accomplice…when you don’t have a badge.

In the rare event that some transgression is so egregious that there is no choice but to punish the officer, there had better not be any sweetheart plea deals. For instance, Johannes Sebastian Mehserle who shot Oscar Grant – unarmed, face down – in the back. He got just 2 years for ending an innocent life.

bshock (profile) says:

wishful thinking

Mike, I’d really like to believe that the growing frequency of video evidence will help to improve police behavior.

But the social psychology seems to be against it. Police behave the way they behave because there are countless major and minor pressures acting on them as they perform the role of physical authorities. Video is just one small addition to this, and I suspect it will either become illegal to video a police officer (as wildly unconstitutional as that might be), or the police will simply adopt an absolute contempt for video evidence against them (as seems to be the case here).

Anonymous Coward says:

?Deputy Inspector Bologna’s actions that day were motivated by his concern for the safety of officers under his command and the safety of the public. The limited use of pepper spray effectively restored order without any escalation of force or serious injury to either demonstrator or police officer.?

I’d say the use of mace qualifies as an escalation.

Anonymous Coward says:

“The intention was to place them under arrest, but they fled,”

So.. we justify pepper spraying because “someone” did “something”. And after spraying randomly, we let them leave.. you know, because 1000 cops can’t possibly arrest a few people they targeted in the crowd.

However, they can arrest 700 people a week later?

HothMonster says:

Re: Re:

oh its just another bullshit excuse. It almost as if the people making these excuses are not allowed to watch the videos. Maybe the NYPD has youtube blocked or something because no one who has seen the video would think this is true. Tony Bologna just spays and turns around and strolls away, both times, he has no interest in arresting anyone. I think he is off to get his pepperspray refilled.

That Anonymous Coward (profile) says:

I was more entertained at how angry the spokesweasel was when Anonymous identified this fine example of their profession. And the internal review only came about after the citizen review board informed them of the opening of an investigation.

Given his training in handling protests (he was in charge of the unit to handle protests at one point), and a series of suits against him for civil rights violations one has to wonder how deep the contempt for the law is in the NYPD.

And now there is questions if the arrests on the bridge were caused by protestors or by officers creating a situation where they could arrest people. Sort of how the police in the UK lead some protest organizers, who had done nothing wrong, out the back door “to avoid being with those damaging property” who were going to be arrested. They then arrested the organizers and left the anarchists in the shop causing damage.

So I wonder if we will continue to see the news black out on Occupy Wall Street, I am pretty sure no one will mention the fact the Koch Brothers company was selling things to Iran either. (Bloomberg did…)

George Orwell says:

Goons to protect the public from the poleese please

It has been less than 200 years when the first municipal police force was organized in London. Since then it has morphed into a military occupying naziesque club (look at the Darth Vader helmets/jackboots, black gear, etc.)which attracts sadists and control freaks who feel immune to all accountability, especially in the NWO USA. Yes, there are many good cops. Methinks a minority. At least the Mafia usually confined their mayhem to their own (and to those who deserved their just desserts – aka justice). Yes, a rant… I know. But true nonetheless.

holdenough (profile) says:

Just Desserts...

These high-ranking police officers are just fully owned and paid-for attack dogs for the super-rich and the corporate interests. Thus, it will be particularly satisfying when (not if!) they lose their collective bargaining rights just like those police and firefighters in Wisconsin and soon in Ohio. Once they have done their masters’ bidding, they will become dispensable and fall to the scythe wielded by republicans all over the country. In Tony Boloney’s case, this will have been well-earned, and just desserts. I can barely wait to hear them whining!

Beta (profile) says:

"So there I was..."

If this is the kind of story the police spin in the face of irrefutable evidence to the contrary, just imagine the liberties they may take when there’s no evidence (that hasn’t passed through their hands), and it’s their word against that of a shifty-looking prisoner.

Something to remember the next time you serve on a jury.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: "So there I was..."

^— This, but that presumes the case even makes it to trial. I’ve been on the receiving end of lying cops. As I whiled away the hours in county (a direct result of said lying cop), I got to know some of my fellow guests and their stories. It seems my situation wasn’t all that uncommon.

Thomas (profile) says:


is clearly showing they are the current edition of the Gestapo.

The Commissioner said he would “open an investigation”, which is clearly doublespeak for “we will prove the cops acted correctly:.”

This clearly shows why the cops want to make it illegal to videotape their actions: they want to avoid another ‘Rodney King’ incident by outlawing videotape of cops beating the crap out of people.

We are in far far mor danger from our own cops than from the Taliban or any crazy Jihadists.

Our cops are no longer there to protect citizens; they simply are out of control thugs doing the bidding of whoever pays them the most. At the moment it’s the super rich Wall Street executives.

Anonymous Coward says:

I use to wonder why Pirate Mike puts stories like this on his “tech” blog. Now I get it. Pirate Mike cannot stand authority. He will do ANYTHING he can to make those in power look bad. He won’t write stories about positive things that happen. No… He only focuses on the negative.

You truly are a wonder, chubby. I’m starting to understand what makes you tick. It’s disgusting and scary, but at least it’s starting to make sense to me.

JMT says:

Re: Re:

This whole ongoing story, and many other similar ones, are about the use of technology. Specifically how nearly everyone now carries a device that can record, store and distribute reasonable quality video, and how that technology is now being used to highlight abuse of police power.

I don’t think you’re so dumb that you can’t see this, so it’s safe to assume you’re simply taking another pathetic potshot at Mike due to either some deep personal issue you have with him or because it’s part of your job description.

Grae (profile) says:

Re: Re:

So I was following along pretty well until I hit this little disconnect: “You truly are a wonder, chubby.

For reference, here’s a photo and video footage of Mr. Masnick.

Now I can only speak for myself here, but Mike looks a very far cry from “chubby”. I wonder what your point of reference is. One might even consider your point of view “disgusting and scary“. Food for thought, eh?

Jesse (profile) says:

Mike, I’m curious as to why you don’t agree with the protest. It seems to me the motivation behind the protest is to speak out about the close relationship between government and Wall St., rather than to protest against a financial system. Ironically (or I guess predictably, rather), the fact that the police are so keen to shut them down (as opposed to Tea Party Rallies) only further demonstrates that close relationship.

My interpretation could be wrong. But if I’m right, isn’t that the sort of thing you write about all the time? Rather than write a blog, they are going to the streets to raise awareness.

That Anonymous Coward (profile) says:

Re: Re:

The beginnings of this protest were not very clear on what the plan was. As time progressed they saw they were not being taken seriously and they have very quickly focused their message.

They are learning and adapting to the needs of having a “cause” that can be communicated that drowns out the stereotype of slacker punks who just want the world to give them a hand out.

They are gaining visibility and the message is resonating and spreading. Other groups are seeing the effort for what it is and adding their support. They are not trying to co-opt the movement, just adding more voices that will not be ignored.

I don’t think everyone is ready to commit to an underpublicized protest movement, but Mike has at least covered the stories rising up around the protest. This is better than other coverage ignoring it or painting the protesters as an invading horde beating down the poor NYPD.

The revolution will be livestreamed, and that Mike will have an article about… but I think he really is trying to avoid the giant can of worms on the issues driving this protest. Those debates are best handled elsewhere.

username says:

Anthony Bologna D0x
NYPD Deputy Inspector
Patrol Boro Manhattan South – 212-477-6181

-WAS Commanding Officer of the First Precinct for the past 5 years

-Possible phone number: (518) 989-9051

———————-Reason for D0x’ing


Anthony Linda Bologna
Anthony V Bologna
Anthony Jennings Bologna
Linda S Bologna (family)
Dana M Bologna (family)
Jenna Angelina Bologna (family)
J Bologna (family)
Angelina Bologna (family)
Joanne A Bologna (family)
Anthony C Bologna (family)


St. Paul’s High School (1970-1974)

———————-Last Known Addresses

5 Sawyer Ave, Unit A, Staten Island, NY, US
119 Slater Blvd, Staten Island, NY, US
5 Sawyer Ave, Staten Island, NY, US
1309 Lake Ave, Metairie, LA, US
Jennings Hill Rd, West Kill, NY, US
Catskill, NY, US
Lexington, NY, US
New York, NY, US
5314 8th Ave, Brooklyn, NY, US
236 E Gibson St, Covington, LA, US
134 N Carrollton Ave, New Orleans, LA, US
22072 8th St, Abita Springs, LA, US
6 Saint Jean De Luz, Mandeville, LA, US
1000 53rd St, Brooklyn, NY, US
1224 Lake Ave, Apt 205, Metairie, LA, US
10122 Lakewood St, New Orleans, LA, US
24 Claudia Dr, Covington, LA, US
6906 13th Ave, Unit 2f, Brooklyn, NY, US

—————————Legal Trouble

Plaintiff: Posr A. Posr
Defendants: Tulio Camejo, Anthony Bologna, Michael R. Bloomberg, Raymond W. Kelly, Joseph J. Esposito, The City of New York and Connie Fishman

Case Number: 1:2007cv07583
Filed: August 27, 2007

Court: New York Southern District Court
Office: Foley Square Office
County: NewYork
Presiding Judge: Judge P. Kevin Castel

Nature of Suit: Civil Rights – Other Civil Rights
Cause: 42:1983 Civil Rights Act
Jurisdiction: Federal Question
Jury Demanded By: Plaintiff

——————————-Until Next Time Folks…

SamJ says:

I’m sorry no one has mentioned what the Occupy Wall demonstrations are protesting. They are protesting the Jewish investment bankers and brokers who screwed up the entire financial system worldwide. These bankers did this through Jewish cunning, predatory selling of junk derivatives, rated “AAA” when they were actually junk, and just basically selling your grandmother up the river. Did you see the signs carried by demonstrators in New York and Los Angeles? This is not a fringe movement. One of my favorite signs said “Humanity v. The Rothschilds”. Anyone want to nominate their favorite Goldman Sachs crook as Jew of the Year? It won’t be too long before Jew techies are also being investigated. Woo-Hoo!

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...