Spanish Court Dismisses Complaint From Nintendo Against Counterfiet DS Cartridges, Since They Add Functionality

from the getting-it-right dept

It seems that Spain is a country that is pretty consistently figuring out that we shouldn’t just throw out all other rights the second “piracy” is shouted by the entertainment industry. We’ve noted recently that the country hasn’t just rejected three strikes and declared broadband a basic right, but has also ruled, repeatedly, that personal file sharing is legal. And now, it even has judges who realize that “anti-circumvention” laws should have limits as well.

As you probably know, one of the key things that the entertainment industry has pushed for throughout the world is “anti-circumvention” clauses in copyright law. In the US we have this in the DMCA and it’s a total mess. The law basically says that any attempt to circumvent (or to make or sell a tool to circumvent) DRM on a digital work is a violation of the copyright law — even if making a copy of the content in question wouldn’t violate copyright law.

Spanish copyright law includes an anti-circumvention clause, but as Leo Martins alerts us, a judge in Salamanca, Spain has taken a much more nuanced view of it in a case pitting Nintendo against Grupo Movilquick, who produced alternative cartridges for Nintendo DS devices. The judge’s ruling (translated from the original) appears to find that the alternative cartridges do, in fact, circumvent Nintendo’s DRM and can be used for “pirating” games, but also extend the utility of the devices for perfectly legal purposes. For that reason, the judge dismissed the lawsuit (translation from the original) noting that it doesn’t make sense that the law would be intended to say that only Nintendo can expand the functionality of its devices, and the fact that Nintendo doesn’t offer similar functionality shouldn’t preclude others from doing so. There are areas where Nintendo can still bring a lawsuit, such as for patent and trademark issues, but the judge notes those should be dealt with in a civil court.

Filed Under: , , , , , ,
Companies: grupo movilquick, nintendo

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Spanish Court Dismisses Complaint From Nintendo Against Counterfiet DS Cartridges, Since They Add Functionality”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
14 Comments
Chargone (profile) says:

Re: Re:

On the other hand: yay! Such judges do exist! The world is not quite entirely doomed!

But yeah. That is pretty sad.

It’s always seemed to me that a lot of cases would be better settled [mostly civil, but some criminal too] by way of the law saying ‘in the event that thing x happens/is desputed, it may be brought before a judge’ … and says nothing else. the judge listens to the sides and then says “here’s the solution. go do it”

I’m not explaining that properly… meh *shrugs*

Simon Lynch (user link) says:

mmm, consistently?

Please don’t hold Spain up as a good example. Blank media and recording devices sold in Spain carry a tax on them ‘just in case’ you do something nasty with them that infringes on someone’s copyright. If I want to buy a DVD-RW to back up data, I get the privilege of paying €0.60 which go to a author’s rights collection agency. Want to buy a PC with a CD/DVD recorder in it, €3.40 extra… Think they are pulling in €300m/year or thereabouts. Someone already figured out how to screw all users, blocking a few cartridges or chucking people off the net is pretty ‘small beer’ in comparaison…

baditup (profile) says:

really?!?!

soooo, basically ANYTHING that can record SOMETHING would fall under that law…

I mean, then Creative Labs would pretty much be in the shitter… oh wait, because I can hear then pretty much immediately play something on the guitar, does that make ME one of those devices…. is my existence illegal?!?! hahahaha, what a joke! ¡Viva España!

Paolo Brini (profile) says:

Very important decision

Europeans, check out new Directive 2009/24/EC (which is a clean rewrite of the several times amended 91/250/EEC).

Recital 15, article 5 and article 6 are strongly consistent with the spanish decision. And there’s more: they should stop Apple’s plan to make iPhone jailbreak illegal (in the European Union).

Link to the Directive 2009/24/EC, official publication.

Paolo Brini (profile) says:

Very important decision

Europeans, check out new Directive 2009/24/EC (which is a clean rewrite of the several times amended 91/250/EEC).

Recital 15, article 5 and article 6 are strongly consistent with the spanish decision. And there’s more: they should stop Apple’s plan to make iPhone jailbreak illegal (in the European Union).

Link to Directive 2009/24/EC.

Christopher (profile) says:

Spain has the only smart judges

Very sad that only Spain has realized how much the arguments of Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo REEK on the piracy front…. I wonder if a court case can be filed there for what Microsoft did to the XBox360 users who had modded their machines to play backup games?

I mean, yes, those things CAN be used for ‘infringement’…. but they can also be used and most likely ARE MORE OFTEN USED for playing backed up games, which should be legal and actually IS legal by the US laws, when you remove the DMCA… which for some reason has never truly been challenged in a court of law.

Anonymous Hero says:

erm…IMHO the title of this is inaccurate, they are not “Counterfiet DS Cartridges” the description used in the article “alternative cartridges” is more accurate.

With exception of it’s shape which is necessary for it to fit (has Nintendo trademarked the DS cartridge shape?) flash cart manufactures are careful not to make their carts/boxes look like the big N’s originals, so they shouldn’t be seen as passing off (moron in a hurry test?)

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...