Broadband Over Powerlines Is Dead, Dead, Dead

from the say-goodbye dept

For many, many years we’ve pointed out the reasons why broadband over powerlines was unlikely to succeed. Despite the FCC calling it the “the great broadband hope,” many people referred to it as “the great broadband joke.” The technology just wasn’t able to deliver what was promised and certainly couldn’t scale effectively. Now, as Broadband Reports points out, one of the big “flagship” deployments of BPL, in Dallas, has been sold and is going to shut down internet access. Instead, the buyer is just going to use it for monitoring the electrical grid. Given that this is just the latest in a long line of failures — and that the technology has never worked up to the level promised, can we finally put to rest the idea that BPL is a legitimate “third pipe” for broadband?

Filed Under: , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Broadband Over Powerlines Is Dead, Dead, Dead”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
29 Comments
The Buds says:

Re: Re:Anonymous Coward

1st admitted to much resistance in copper power wire for speed , But the tech. is there , haven’t figured out how to make enough money or interest and limited applications . 2 companys in Texas had 2,000,000 subscribers ready to go! But to me , A Direct access to every outlet in my Home for Data , Privacy , Home Security and more nuisance Factor from the Semi Concious Neo-Phyts and Neighbor hood Vigilantes Slinking in the wall sockets of your life due to the lacking they have in those mundane that they either want to get you busted OR Vicariously live through your contentment with your own ability to entertain yourself without needing to use what another man does in the privacy of his Home for you personal Rude , Unethical , Down Right Unneighborly , But It’s wide open For Civil Rights Violations and will be used so ! Both Criminal and Civil penalties Apply : Prove It !

Jake says:

Having seen broadband-over-power mentioned by name in one of those pump-and-dump stock scams, I really shouldn’t be surprised.
I don’t think we should give up on the idea entirely, though; it’s demonstrably possible, even though the technology’s not mature enough that it’s really practical yet. I just hope it goes back to the lab rather than straight to the history books under ‘Great Scientific Failures’.

Doug Robb (profile) says:

Horses for courses

I think you are correct in what is happening in the market but in Australia read below for some surprises. I think its an idea waiting for a time/place/niche – all technologies that their strengths and weaknesses.

From report:
“Trials of the service in two of Australia’s more remote communities, Tasmania and Victoria, as well as a handful of customers closer to Melbourne and Canberra. The ease of installation on both ends was a huge selling point, and the two year initial trial received rave reviews from customers. Everyone liked how easy it was, how far it reached and the speed (as much as 200mbps in some cases).”

So why didn’t it go ahead?

From Report:

“In order to work at its maximum efficiency, the technology needs a repeater station every kilometer or so. This is no big deal, until you think about how large Australia is, how scattered the towns are, and how many the utilities would have to build in order to service them all. Even if the government subsidized it, the cost of a full roll out would be prohibitive. The very nature of what the technology is designed to do, serve remote and underpopulated areas, makes the return on the cost negligible.

Without a significant return / cost ratio it isn’t worth full deployment. If all of their cash is sunk into a roll out, utilities wouldn’t be able to compete with companies like Telstra to get the market share they’d need in urban areas to be successful in outlying areas. Once again big telcos win the battle before it even starts, and so a brilliant technology dies.”

See for full story google out “broadband-over-power-lines-dies-a-quiet-death” at freeaccess.com.au

freak3dot says:

X10

“Even if broadband is not possible over the grid, would a low speed network over the electrical wires inside a building be possible? I was thinking of the possibility of controlling lights and appliances.”

Steve – Check out X10 technology.

The only reason I am not interested in BPL is X10. I doubt the two will play together nicely.

freak3dot

Observer says:

If BPL is dead, we owe that fact solely to market forces. It would be nice to think BPL died because the FCC was doing its job – that they gave rational consideration to the problem of spectrum pollution from BPL (and the extensive technical data confirming it) and acted to protect the usability of the radio spectrum for licensed users – but they did not. Instead, the FCC did everything it could to stonewall, obfiscate, and ignore the technical community and every licensed spectrum user whose comments did not support the agency’s cheerleading. Shame on the FCC’s leadership for being so blatently political. Shame.

Tony says:

For your information, the term BPL as applied to Current Communications is somewhat of a misnomer. The fact is most of their network – all of the backbone and distribution – is actually fiber optic cable. They are overbuilding the areas they serve with fiber and the only copper involved is the electrical dropwire to the house, so the signal is not going through a transformer.

BK says:

BPL

While Current sold the internet portion of the network in Dallas, the grid monitoring service is actually raking in the cash for them and working very well. I believe they have just discovered that the grid analysis/smartgrid service will make them more money with less effort; Michael Long hit the nail on the head with his comment from what I have been told. The internet service in Dallas did get the promised speeds, in my case it actually got more than promised; we were getting 15 mbit synchronous without any interference to the ham radio I used in the next room.

Jun Lao says:

BPL drives stocks up up up

In the Philippines, PLDT (Largest local telco giant) just bought majority shares from Meralco (Largest Power distributor) and plans test by Dec 2009 (this year)

Stocks have jumped for Meralco, P100 in Jan to its current P272 stock price +63% in 9 mos. (as of July 28 09),

I’m placing all my money in this overpriced stock- if you look 2 years along the line, stock value could increase by 1000%-

My prediction- P2,000 per share by 2011, conservative… lets see…

For all intents and purposes- BPL works, with synnergies with telco and power operators, its the milleniums best symbiotic relationship…

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...