Hide Techdirt is off for the long weekend! We'll be back with our regular posts tomorrow.

Attorney General Mukasy Claims Piracy Funds Terrorism

from the oh-please dept

We had assumed that former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales’ sudden facsination with “piracy” was as a way to avoid dealing with the controversy surrounding his office — but it appears his successor is heading down that path as well. In a speech given today in Silicon Valley, Attorney General Michael Mukasey gave a fear mongering speech about how piracy and counterfeiting fosters terrorism. This is a line (literally) straight from the RIAA training manual, which it appears Mukasey has bought into. It should come as no surprise to hear that Mukasey flew up to Silicon Valley after spending a day in Hollywood at Warner Brothers.

Still, what’s most interesting is that he doesn’t seem to indicate much of a difference between merely copying content and “counterfeiting,” which would be passing off a fake good as a legitimate one. Counterfeiting is more akin to “trademark” in that it’s really about customer protection (making sure you’re not buying Bob’s Cola thinking that it’s Coca Cola). It’s understandable to be upset about counterfeiting — but the problem is that two separate impartial government agencies have both found that counterfeiting isn’t that big a problem, and it’s regularly exaggerated by lobbyists.

Unfortunately, it doesn’t appear that any of these nuances have made it to the AG’s office. Instead, he’s just lumped all piracy and counterfeiting issues into one single category and labeled it all a big problem and linked it to “terrorism” so that no one questions it. And rather than assigning more Justice Department officials to work on real problems and real crimes, he’s been beefing up the “IP” group, increasing prosecutions 33% in the last couple of years. Is this really the best use of our taxpayer money?

Filed Under: , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Attorney General Mukasy Claims Piracy Funds Terrorism”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Casper says:


It’s amusing and sad at the same time how this political game is going. They lump counterfeit media sales with pirated content, in order to better help push legislation to help the RIAA/MPAA, yet no one asks how they came to this conclusion? Seriously, if someone is pirating something for free, how are the source of the pirated material making money off it? Also, I some how do not think the counterfeit DVD vendor down the street is funding terrorism, because if you have seen the way he is dressed, he isn’t even funding himself very well.

Nick (profile) says:

It is like saying colonialism is a too of democracy.

Counterfeiting is an interesting topic. When someone is able to counterfeit something very well, it means the price should be lower.

When someone can make something at a lower price than you, they are competing and winning.

What better way for Bush/Cheny INC. to stifle foreign competitors so that US competitors will win in the market, and make more income taxable: in the name security. I hope most people can see right through this, and that Obama addresses it.

August West says:

Re: piracy?

There does not need to be any basis in reality for our current president and his handpicked cronies to try and pass off some ridiculous statement as fact. Lets see… Iran trains Al-Qaeda, WMD’s in Iraq, Al-Qeada in Iraq before we were there, if you oppose illegal wiretapping you support terrorism…. See, this piracy/terrorism argument is actually almost logical compared to the BS they’ve been spinning off for the past seven years or so…

I have started to believe that Bush is actually a mole for the Democratic party. He was put in place to permanently ruin the credibility of the Republican party. Thats the only reason I can think of that he would so consistently make sure his entire regime were such liars and idiots. Plus do and say all the moronic things he has.

The Muffin Man says:

>Fill in the blank< Funds Terrorism!!!

Man… I for one am sick and tired of hear about how anything that this Administration doesn’t like or agree with it amazingly Funds Terrorism!! You know what The Bush Administration Funds Terrorism!!! Lobbyists Fund Terrorism!!! The RIAA and MPAA Funds Terrorism!!! Come on Everyone this is fun! What else funds Terrorism?? Just say it and people will buy it because Hey! Fear is a powerful tool, but you know what i for one think this shit is getting real weak… They need to start focusing on the REAL issues that face this nation, to many to list…

Rekrul says:

How long will it be before the puppets in Washington just come out and admit that they’re on the payroll of large corporations? I mean, that’s what it amounts to now. These idiots will pass any law or take any action that makes the corporations happy and keeps the money rolling into their political funds. Isn’t that the same thing?

Lawrence D'Oliveiro says:

In other news...

…Osama Bin Laden is appealing to the WIPO, the US DHS and the US Attorney-General’s office to put a stop to the trading in fake Osamas that, it is claimed, are threatening to dilute the well-known terrorist’s brand. “We value our Intellectual Property very highly,” a spokesterrorist was quoted as saying. “And it’s well-known that these sorts of counterfeiting activities go to fund, umm … what was it again …”

gas says:

we give billions of dollars to the arab countrys our gas
guzzers 6 and 8 cyl cars are to blame everyone who uses gas in thir cars are to blame they are funding terrorists
we know who the terrorists are we need to stop all oil from
coming unto the us and ban these people from stepping foot in our country terrorists have around long long before
the tv was invented for thousands of years

Anonymous Coward says:

This man is one of three things, we need the mains

As I see it this man is either,

#1 A fool, simply believing what he is told.
#2 On the take, receiving money from the “media lobby” either for himself or his affiliations.

We need to get mainstream media interested in which of
these is true.

Perhaps the first step would be asking for documented proof of any such connection.

Bill says:

Big Brother wants to justify even more taking away

In my opinion, the primary reason the government wants to attach the term “terrorist activity” to everything is because that label gives them nearly unlimited powers of pursuit with virtually no checks and balances.

They have already taken away far too many of our civil rights in the name of fighting terrorism. Thanks to the highly un-patriotic “Patriot Act,” all they have to do is say they suspect you of terrorist-supporting activities, and they can put you under even the most invasive types of surveillance without the need for a warrant. Plus, they are constantly abusing this power by filtering ALL communication traffic travelling through key nodes of the largest telecommunication companies. One of the major television news shows exposed this activity fairly recently, in fact.

The irony is that by our government turning this country into an Orwellian nightmare, the terrorists have already accomplished a lot of what they set out to do. People will cower in their homes scared of not only a possible terrorist attack (thanks to constant government warnings – real or imagined), but many folks will also be frightened that their own government will label one of their harmless private activities as being “terrorist-supporting” and throw them in prison, tarnishing their image and ruining their lives.

Just talk to a Homeland Security officer who works at our airports off the record if you want to know if we are really any safer after all this. Or just ask airline employees. We’re giving up all of our freedoms for nothing but the illusion of safety.

Our only hope for the future is that we can try to get the current crop of freedom-haters out of Washington before they erode any more of our civil rights. Otherwise, we could be looking at a future that looks somewhat similar to the movie “V is for Vendetta.” Folks will start being censored and even prosecuted simply for speaking out against the methods our own government is using against us. They will be labeled as “terrorists” for disagreeing with the direction of the government. At that point, we as a democracy are doomed. Perhaps they should stop trying to establish democracies all over the world and start trying to re-establish our own.

That’s my two cents. Now, I’m broke.

Anonymous Coward says:

How come you never bring up Moises Naim, the self-declared expert on Illicit trade and terrorism when talking about this kind of issue. Moises is the editor of Foreign Policy magazine and is perhaps the most respected authority who expouses the connections between terrorism, counterfeit, and pirated goods….

Surely he is easily refutable 🙂

Anonymous Political Coward says:

It's The Oil, Stupid

#17 nailed it.

The goofballs in power will constantly try to sell their “war on drugs” or their war on piracy, or whatever they choose as “funding terrorism”. Give me a break!!!

Al Qaeda and other fringe groups don’t need to operate crime rings to raise money. They don’t need to do a “fund raiser, they don’t set up a lemonade stands, bake sale, sell weed on the corner, or get a paper route.


Rich sheiks and prices, making millions from oil extraction in their lands, like to maintain the feudal system they have in place. As such, they need to keep the populace ignorant, and they need to keep them indoctrinated and angry at someone else. Some of the oil rich sheiks fund the terrorist organizations.

Ask yourself: is their more oil money floating around Iraq, or more MP3, filesharing, and marijuana money?

How can our government dare even try to sell us such an obvious bunch of lies? And it works??!!!

People, it’s the oil. I don’t have a solution for us. I use a lot of gas myself. But that’s where the money trail ends. That’s how we sell out our security. By using oil. But gas is my ‘crack’, I’m hooked on it…and so is our administration in a big way…and so are most of you.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...