Hide Techdirt is off for the long weekend! We'll be back with our regular posts tomorrow.

Nathan Myhrvold's Bait And Switch Plan On Patent Hoarding

from the can-you-say-greenmail? dept

We’ve written about Nathan Myhrvold’s dangerous plans to put hundreds of millions of dollars into hoarding patents many times before. Business Week is now running yet another article that tries to get to the heart of Myhrvold’s plans — though his company, Intellectual Ventures is being quite secretive. The article does discuss his “invention sessions” where he brings together a bunch of smart folks to brainstorm — where the whole conversation is recorded and monitored by patent lawyers looking for anything they can file patents on. However, what’s much more interesting is the story of how Myhrvold pulled a total bait-and-switch on the many big tech companies who represent his investors. The original business plan for Intellectual Ventures was to create a “Patent Defense Fund.” The idea was to buy up all the available patents from the bursting dot com bubble and offer to license it to companies to protect them from patent infringement lawsuits from others using the typical nuclear stockpiling defense. However, these days, the company no longer discusses the patent defense fund. Instead, it refers to many of its own investors as “the patent infringers lobby.” As the article suggests, it seems like the company basically convinced these companies to fund it based on this “defense fund” plan, by making it clear if they didn’t invest, they would be the first targets for future lawsuits. In the meantime, would you trust any company that insists the patent system is just fine — but doesn’t seem to understand the history of innovation? Update: In a move that can’t make folks happy at either magazine, it appears Fortune has an almost identical article about Myhrvold coming out. The two articles are so similar, in fact, that it makes you wonder why the publicity tour is starting up now.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Nathan Myhrvold's Bait And Switch Plan On Patent Hoarding”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
s1l3nt.c (user link) says:

My latest patent

I just want to make an official announcement that I have patented the concept of bitching about IP whores (and their pimps) on any blog.

You may submit an immediate payment of $6725.36 to me , or I will unleash a pack of rabid shysters into your bedroom while you are sleeping and they will rewallpaper it with a vast array of extortion letters.

Pleasant dreams. 🙂

angry dude says:

techdirt's idiocy

What is fucking wrong with you, people ?

America’s economic prosperity was built on thousands of patented inventions made by many many inventors, some were corporate workers, some worked in their garages or workshops.

Why is all this bitching and moaning about patent system ? Patent systme is not broken, the underlying principle is sound, it’s just the current implementation is poor and underfunded.

Without IP rights you would live in a much different world, and for many of us (at least for those who can create something new, not just steal…) this IP-less world would be an absolute nightmare

Don’t buy into Mike’s foolish anti-patent propaganda (which for some strange reason happens to have many common points with the BS coming out of the infringer’s PR depts)

Panic says:

angry dude

“Why is all this bitching and moaning about patent system ? Patent systme is not broken, the underlying principle is sound, it’s just the current implementation is poor and underfunded. ”

You said it yourself right there what all the bitching is about.

The principle’s of Patents ARE sound, it is the implementation we’re bitching about.

Do you READ the articles here?

International Space Agency (ISA) (user link) says:

Nathan Myhrvold - Inventors

I saw a story on CNN tonight on Nathan Myhrvold, and his invention shop. I am very interested if this is legit, or is a big money scam to steal the brain capital of America?

I have contacted Nathan Myhrvold by phone, to arrange a meeting with him. I will see if he is legit, or not?

I would like to say, that as a genius and inventor for 30+ years, that the inventors in America are under attack from within, and from without, the USA.

Countries like China, U.K., and Australia are setting up so called invention shops in the U.S.A., as U.S. front companies, to pin point and steal or destroy American geniuses and inventors.

Also, the United States Military and NSA have systematically sought out state of the art inventions and inventors and subjected them to covert theft, or steal their work under the guise of National Security.

The United States Patient Office is a joke, and is totally corrupt, and is why the vast majority of REAL geniuses and inventors do not even file their work with the patient office anymore. As a matter of fact, the International Space Agency, and our work with state of the art space transportation and propulsion systems, have been warned by numerous patient attorneys NOT to file our work with the United States patient office, lest the U.S. Government STEAL or SIEZE or work, under the GUISE of NATIONAL SECURITY!

Ask Burt Rutan about the MEN IN BLACK, who came to his company, Scaled Composites, after his successful launch into space with Space Ship One, and threatened to arrest him or SIEZE his company, if he sold that technology to Virgin Galactic (Our U.K. Allies).

Many PRIVATE Space Companies, Inventors, and Researchers have been destroyed and undermined by the United States Government, in order to maintain U.S. MILITARY CONTROL of Earths Orbit and Space!

In the good old days of American Invention and Historic Growth and Discovery, Inventors were protected and made heroes. Today they are fodder for government and corporate greed and lust for power!

That is why 30+ years after the Moon landing, we cannot even today barely get into or stay in Earths Orbit!

In a day in age when the social corrupt elite make millions for eating bugs and having open sex on National T.V., and our Nations crème of the crop and the core of our Nations Future, are starving to death and being gobbled up and destroyed!

The whole purpose Benjamin Franklin set up the patient office of the United States, was to protect the genius of this country, and that those with genius were rewarded and acknowledged for their important contributions to American Society.

The “SO CALLED” Invention Show that was on T.V. not so long ago, was a JOKE! They paraded homosexuals around the stage and pushed and anti-inventor / anti-American leftist agenda and propaganda mill. NO REAL AMERICAN INVENTOR would have EVER been part of that SIDE SHOW and MESS! But, indeed, where is the main stream media support of our Nations REAL Geniuses and Inventors???!!!!

No where to be seen or heard, because it does not serve the agenda of those taking control of America!

To destroy America, you must first DUMB IT DOWN, and DESTROY ITS BRAIN CAPITAL! This has been strategically underway for 30+ years now! It is only a matter of time before America becomes a bunch of bumbling idiots, that cannot even keep its National Space Agency up and running, or even keep it high technology base functioning!

What side of the fence is Nathan Myhrvold on?
I really do not know, but I am going to try and find out!

Ad-Astra! To The Stars!
In Peace For All Mankind!

Signed, American Inventor

Mr. Rick R. Dobson, Jr.
Chairman & CEO
International Space Agency, I.S.A.
International Space Administration
Registered Trademark & Copyright
1986 to 2007, All Rights Reserved
Washington, D.C. Phone: (202) 917-0209
Omaha, Nebraska Phone: (402) 299-2799

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...