Judge Says He'll Make Google Cough Up Some Info For Feds

from the everybody-else-did-it dept

Well that didn’t take long at all. While he still hasn’t released his official decision, it sounds like the judge hearing the dispute between the Department of Justice and Google over whether or not Google needs to turn over a random sample of searches and URLs has made up his mind. He’s going to split the difference and require Google to turn over some data, though it’s not entirely clear how much. Apparently, Google’s original effort in basically suggesting the government was clueless wasn’t particularly convincing. In court, the company took a somewhat different strategy — apparently focusing on the fact that Amazon’s Alexa now offers open access, so the government researcher can get all the data he needs from there. Even the judge admitted that he was worried the result of this case would force Google to hand over data to researchers involved in all sorts of lawsuits — and thus, it’s expected that he’ll have the government compensate Google for the work needed to supply the data. Already, though, the ACLU (which is on the other side from the government in this case) has said that it, too, will need to get data from Google in order to respond to the government’s case. While it seems unlikely that any of the data revealed gives up any seriously private info, this does seem to open some worrisome precedent-setting doors that could lead to problems in future cases. Update: A different take on today’s events claims that Google and the DoJ had already reached a settlement on handing over the data before today’s hearings — and the hearings were just a facade to make everyone look better.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Judge Says He'll Make Google Cough Up Some Info For Feds”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Joe Smith says:


I find it amazing that a Judge would order the seizure (because that is what is going on here) of private information of private information because the government says the information might help them get an experts report which might help them support legislation which might be valid.

A decision favoring the government will mean that the government can issue an injunction any time to anyone demanding private information if they think that perons has information might be useful to the administration in advancing the administration’s ideological agenda.

Whatever happened to the Fourth Amendment?

Sarojin says:

Re: Crazy

Does everyone forget that Google was the ONLY company that didn’t turn over their info VOLUNTARILY? MSN, Yahoo, both rolled out the red carpet, as did most of the major phone companies. We live in a fascist state, wake up!!!

When Google said “No, that’s not legal” the “no longer of the people, for the people” government enacted legal measures. What, no legal justification before the request (it’s about porn), just have a right-wing appointed judge rule in our favor so we can ignore the law.

You should all be very concerned, and become very active, to throw out the criminals occupying the white house.

discojohnson says:

is it worth it?

granted there’s the high probability that google can produce a better result set for the gov’t, but when the gov’t asked the other search engines to release info they did so willingly. what purpose does it serve for google to release information when the gov’t already obtained a good chunk of info from the other engines? what can google provide that is so damn important to waste this much of my tax money? if they’ve got to release a random sampling, it doesn’t matter from where the information comes from. even if it’s in the interest of national security, i’m sure terrorist networks use msn and y! plenty of the time too.

WhoNu says:

They came a knockin'

Yesterday the govment came to my door and said they needed a portion of my phone book. I thought what the heck would they want that for. Seems as though some people have been searching in them for some kind of information. So I opened one up and sure enough, right there in black and white is my name, address and phone number. Jeepers creepers, not only that but with a little more lookin you can figure out my wifes name and my teenage daughter. So I hastely tore a few pages out and thrust them at ’em, telling them to go away and leave me alone. It was later that I realized that in the part I’d given them was the pages for a local ‘Gentlemans Club’ all circled and everything. I figure that they will be back wanting more pages, so I’ve been busy going through the rest of it circleing all the churches in the local area. I hope that will make them happy, wait a minute, someones knockin at my door now…

Gestapo says:


Seems we have heard it all before… but nobody responds till the innocent are in jails or camps and the tanks and troops are marching the streets. History repeats itself unless the lesson is learned and not forgotten. For the people by the people is a joke under the current regime. Thank heavens the current reign will be over soon, but I fear that the sheep are asleep and the next one won’t be any different. I wonder what will it take? Tanks and troops, or do we have to go that far? Today, nobody has to ask to see your papers directly… they just go to companies like google and demand for them to show your papers for you. Thanks Bush Admin… and the Facist House and Senate… Your citizens love you! Keep up the good work.

pwb says:

This is completely insance. Google has *NOTHING* at all to do with the matter in question. It is crazy that the government can knock on their door and force them to spend a bunch of time and energy turning over a bunch of data that they have good reason to prefer not to turn over. Even if the data were not sensitive (I believe it certainly could be), how can the government force it from a party with no involvement in the case? Why cannot the government get the data on the open market (e.g., from a company like Compete.com which is in the business if supplying exacltly this type of data). Crazy.

Welcom Networks says:


I agree with those who are unhappy with the pending decision forcing Google to release data to the government. However I don’t’ believe it to be against the law, we do have to keep in mind that the Patriot Act is still in to play, thus giving the Government power to confiscate information. If the FBI or whoever wants this information from Google, could supply an actual or better reasoning behind why they want our data then I could easily support them…for a proper cause.

I do find this whole dispute to be rather frustrating in that there has been no reasoning as to why that data is needed, in which case the Patriot Act would not assist the government in this case.

Thank you,

Jay Weatherell
Operations Lead
Welcom Networks

Jan Christiansen says:

Economic Development

If the Feds win then consider this scenario.

The Supreme Court has already taken the position that Cities can expropriate private property to facilitate economic development.

Suppose a mid sized city goes to the credit card issuers and says “We demand to know what people living in our city are buying from outside of our service area. We want the data so we can encourage specialty retailers to locate in our city and thereby foster economic development here.”

What happens then?

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...