Microsoft Clarifies: Amateurs And Hobbyists Not Wanted

from the no-room-for-you-around-here dept

A few weeks ago, we noted that the details of the proposed “analog hole” legislation made it clear that the bill was less about “protecting” content from being copied, and all about killing off amateur content production. It was so focused on setting up a different set of rules for “professionals” and “amateurs” that it was really just about trying to handicap the disruption that amateur content represented. Now, it appears that Microsoft has bought into that same vision. Two separate stories point to two separate quotes from Microsoft execs that both make this abundantly clear (they’re not even tap dancing around the issue, like you’d expect). The first comes from Tim Lee, who points to a Jim Allchin interview where he was quoted as saying that the only way anyone will be able to watch digital TV is if it’s been certified by CableLabs — meaning that hobbyists and tinkerers are out. Meanwhile, someone in the comments to that article point to a talk by another Microsoft exec, talking about how the company views copy protection as only being for professionals: “We don’t want this technology to be available to every hobbyist. We need to keep the number of licensees down to a manageable number. We charge a license fee to keep the number of people we have to deal with down to a level we can handle.” They may want to do that to keep it “manageable,” but it has the side effect again of trying to block out hobbyists — who are doing some of the most innovative work right now. Of course, while some people are pointing out the anti-competitive nature of these statements, the truth is that the only ones it’s really damaging for are for Microsoft and for the professional content producers. They’re pretty much guaranteeing that everyone else will look elsewhere to work with technology that isn’t trying to hold them back.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Microsoft Clarifies: Amateurs And Hobbyists Not Wanted”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
? says:


There will always be developers out there who will have the capability to produce their own applications for creating / playing somebody’s video content.

It is out there now, and will always be out there. Just because people can’t use M$ Media Player, doesn’t mean that they can’t install some other kind of video player. Amature content has always been under attack by the institutions (govts and corporations alike). Yet, amature content has always and will forever exist.

The only way these institutions can win their fight is to destroy the creative spirit of man (THX 1138).

Good luck to them on that front.

Brad says:

Does it really?

Does it really kill off hobbyists? Or does it simply mean that Microsoft isn’t responsible for protecting their media from being distributed – I mean…has anyone said that ONLY media with DRM Licenses will be playable? Is the plan to completely obliterate the MP3 and AVI file formats? I didn’t think it was, but I haven’t been following too closely. (No sarcasm here, I genuinely don’t know)

Hedwig says:


The way this is going is exactly the way Mike is predicting:
The big business players (MS, studios etc) will have their DRM’d, copy-protected, practically-unplayable-because-of-locked-content (ad’s you can’t skip) etc format that will limit itself to certified, genuine and probably over-expensive content.

And there will be another format that will allow the user to (partially) playback, copy and maybe even paste the content. Call it a free (in the sense of what you can do with the content, not the fact that content doesn’t cost anything).

And now for the real funny part: because the locked, unpopular system is so user-unfriendly, the ‘all the rest’ system will become the system of choice for the creative and innovative: artists will release directly under the ‘free’ system, shortcircuiting the entire ‘industry’.
Or rather… the industry shortcircuiting itself because they made themselves incompatible.

By the way, I suppose that pretty soon there will be ripped, converted, de-DRM’d copies of the locked content available in the free format. On the other hand, I don’t quite see the reverse ever happening…

You may guess once which system will prevail…

Joey (user link) says:

Water flows down the path of least resistance...

and so does money.
If the only thing that “amaetur” artists can do is eek out a “living” (say, $40,000/yr) by doing local gigs (local concerts/local screenings)buying time on local Lease Access ($300/hr here at San Antonio, TX)and selling their CDs iPod/PSP friendly videos and DVDs locally or on the internet(don’t know why we would have to throw out a perfectly good video media because someone is telling us its not good enough),then so be it.
Now if content creators (a.k.a “creative folk”) want to get greedy and make more money, then there are two choices;
do a Buckethead, and release 13 CDs (or movies) a year.
“Sell out” and sign on with a record label/production company and be a tool.
whatever you can live with.

Anonymous Coward says:

No Subject Given

I find this quite encouraging. If you wish to build a fortune and don’t mind nonviolently breaking the law to do so, first look for what has been prohibited and then exploit it. DRM-cracking might very well be the basis of a major underground growth industry, not unlike trade in illicit drugs. Just follow the existing business models: take advantage of grassroots sales networks and pay off the proper officials.

Gizmo says:

The future of kids

What will our children think about it all?

Will they even know what “free” is?

Or will there be a “free” only different?

Anti Competitive behaviour is illegal in most countries isn’t it?

MP3 is just the new Audio Tape, just like AVI is the new VHS tape.

AVI is like TV, FREE

MP3 is like radio, FREE

*** will be just like DRM only FREE

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...