by Mike Masnick
Wed, Oct 26th 2011 6:08am
While we've seen plenty of judges recognize that copyright troll outfits suing a bunch of people at once for copyright infringement are really nothing more than a fishing expedition to identify people to be sent demand letters for payment, it appears a few judges still don't recognize how this is a serious abuse of the legal process. toyotabedzrock alerts us to the news that U.S. District Court Judge Alexander Williams in Maryland has ordered Comcast and Verizon to turn over names in two cases involving (of course) porn companies. What's even more ridiculous here is that Judge Williams should clearly recognize that these cases were almost certainly legal shakedowns, rather than actual cases, because one of the companies involved, Patrick Collins Inc, immediately dropped the case against one of the John Does sued because that defendant got himself a lawyer. If that doesn't indicate that the company doesn't actually want to fight these cases in court, but just wants to get the names to send demand letters, it's difficult to know what would convince the judge.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- Dish Agrees To Make Ad-Skipping DVR Less Useful In Settlement With Comcast, NBC Universal
- Comcast Incorrectly Bills Customer $1,775, Tells Him To Figure It Out With His Bank
- Dallas Buyers Club Demands Accused Pirate Take Polygraph, Asks For Judgment When He Agrees Anyway
- $25 Million Jury Verdict In Rightscorp Case Raises Serious Questions About Copyright Law
- Australian Court Rejects Dallas Buyers Club Copyright Trolling Demands