by Mike Masnick
Mon, Oct 26th 2009 2:38pm
You wouldn't normally associate NPR with sending bogus DMCA takedowns, but via the EFF we learn that NPR has sent a DMCA takedown to YouTube over a commercial that uses a clip from NPR. The commercial is from a group that opposes same-sex marriage, so there's likely a political angle here. NPR claims that it issued the takedown to "protect NPR's valuable reputation as a trusted and unbiased source of news," but that's not how copyright works. This is quite similar to when CBS tried to stop the McCain campaign from using a snippet of a broadcast in an ad. In both cases it seems that the use is a clear situation of fair use, with the content not being used for commercial reasons (yes, we'd like to believe that politics still isn't commercial) and only a snippet was being used.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- Techdirt's New T-Shirt Is Now Available... But Its Content Isn't
- EFF Lawsuit Challenges DMCA's Digital Locks Provision As First Amendment Violation
- Minneapolis PD Issues Questionable DMCA Notice To Bury Its Controversial Recruitment Video
- How 'Reasonable Andy' Stopped NPR's Lawyers From Threatening Fan, And Actually Connected With Him
- NPR Takes Down Vision Media's Claims; Will Vision Media Sue NPR -- Or Does It Only Sue Small Operations?