by Mike Masnick

Popping The Anti-Muni Broadband Balloon

from the bam dept

There's been so much happening in the muni broadband (mainly muni WiFi) space lately that it's been difficult to figure out what's worth writing about. If you're really interested, you can always follow most of the news over at Muniwireless. However, today, Glenn Fleishman pulls out the big guns and simply obliterates many of the arguments made by those against muni broadband. On the question of "tax-payers" supporting broadband instead of having private companies do it, he retorts: "Once again, subsidies rear their ugly heads: I'd like Comcast to disclose every penny they're received in subsidies or allocated taxes. It's only fair. We already know how much money Verizon got for a fiber-optic network they never built in Pennsylvania." On the claim that government's don't know how to offer services: "Help me, I've fallen down laughing. A telephone company is lecturing public entities on providing service." On the claims that cities can't accurately estimate the cost of such networks: "Comcast argues that the city's estimate of $10 million to set up and $1.5 million a year is too low. But how would Comcast know? They don't run broadband wireless networks for public safety or for wide access. It's more likely that other cities would understand the costs than Comcast." The incumbent broadband providers are obviously spending a lot of money to fight municipal broadband these days. If they only used that money to actually provide broadband, most of these issues wouldn't matter anyway. The only reason why governments are looking at providing broadband is because the big providers aren't. It's that simple. While governments can certainly be inefficient providers of services, when done right it can help everyone. Not every place should have a municipally funded broadband project -- and the ones that do should be watched carefully. But, muni projects that blend public and private offerings (gov't grants the real estate and right of way issues, but lets private operations build the network and offer services) seem to make a lot of sense.

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

  • identicon
    eskayp, 17 Feb 2005 @ 7:13pm

    No Subject Given

    "Not every place should have a municipally funded broadband project
    -- and the ones that do should be watched carefully."
    Let's see...most government records are public,
    with exceptions for personnel, legal, and bidding matters.
    How 'open' are any of the telcos, cablecos, or other providers?
    Ask for the last annual budget and most public entities will provide it,
    while most private businesses will tell you to stuff it.
    For justification they will wrap themselves in that false flag of 'competition'
    while arranging a cartel or monopoly under the table.
    Consumers can receive shoddy service from public sector or private sector.
    Unhappy consumers can vote the public scoundrels out at the next election.
    Victimized consumers are stuck with the private scoundrels forever,
    or until they go broke, or until someone buys them out, whichever comes first.
    Under the public umbrella broadband recipients can have direct input
    at the local 'broadband commission', at 'city hall', and at council meetings.
    Citizens are direct stakeholders, and have a voice in the policies and management of public broadband.
    We can voice our concerns to the private providers, but they aren't listening.

    Off topic: Has Mike looked at 'Blood on the Street' yet?
    I noticed some relevance to earlier discussions related to Blodget.

    reply to this | link to this | view in chronology ]

Add Your Comment

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here
Get Techdirt’s Daily Email
Use markdown for basic formatting. HTML is no longer supported.
  Save me a cookie
Follow Techdirt
Special Affiliate Offer

Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Essential Reading
Techdirt Deals
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Chat
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads
Recent Stories
Report this ad  |  Hide Techdirt ads


Email This

This feature is only available to registered users. Register or sign in to use it.