Content Moderation Case Study: Ask.fm Responds After A Teen's Suicide Is Linked To Bullying On The Site (August 2013)
from the difficult-content-moderation-questions dept
Summary: After a UK teen took her own life in response to bullying on social networking site, ask.fm, her father asked both the site and the UK government to take corrective measures to prevent further tragedies. This wasn’t an isolated incident. Reports linked multiple suicides to bullying on the teen-centered site.
Ask.fm’s problems with bullying and other abuse appeared to be far greater than those observed on other social media sites. Part of this appeared to be due to the site’s user base, which was much younger than more-established social media platforms. This — combined with the option to create anonymous accounts — seemed to have made ask.fm a destination for abusive users. What moderation existed before these problems became headline news was apparently ineffective, resulting in a steady stream of horrific stories until the site began to make serious efforts to curb a problem now too big to ignore.
Ask.fm’s immediate response to both the teen’s father and UK Prime Minister David Cameron’s criticism (Cameron called for a boycott of the site) was to point to existing moderation efforts put in place to deter bullying and other terms of service violations.
After major companies pulled their advertising, ask.fm pledged to assist police in investigating the circumstances behind the teen’s suicide, as well as consult with a law firm to see if moderation efforts could be improved. It also hired more moderators and a safety officer, and made its “Report” button more prominent.
More than a year after ask.fm became the target of criticism around the world, the site implemented its first Safety Advisory Board. The group of experts on teens and their internet use was tasked with reducing the amount of bullying on the platform and making it safer for its young users.
More significantly, ask.fm’s founders — who were viewed as unresponsive to criticism — were removed by the site’s new owners, InterActiveCorp (IAC). IAC pledged to work more closely with US law enforcement and safety experts to improve moderation efforts.
Decisions to be made by ask.fm:
- Should anonymous accounts be eliminated (or stop-gapped by gathering IP address/personal info) to limit abusive behavior?
- Does catering to a younger user base create unique problems not found at sites that skew older?
- Would more transparency about moderation efforts/features nudge more users towards reporting abuse?
- Should the site directly intervene when moderators notice unhealthy/unwanted user interactions?
Questions and policy implications to consider:
- Given the international reaction to the teen’s suicide, does a minimal immediate response make the perceived problem worse?
- Does having a teen user base increase the risk of direct regulation or unfavorable legislation, given the increased privacy protections for minors in many countries?
- Are moderation efforts resulting from user reports vetted periodically to ensure the company isn’t making bullying/trolling problems worse by allowing abusive users to get others suspended or banned?
Resolution: When immediate steps did little to deter criticism, ask.fm formed a Safety Committee and, ultimately, dismissed founders that appeared to be unresponsive to users’ concerns. The site made changes to its moderation strategies, hired more moderators, and made users more aware of the features they could use to report users and avoid unwanted interactions.
Filed Under: bullying, case study, content moderation, suicide
Comments on “Content Moderation Case Study: Ask.fm Responds After A Teen's Suicide Is Linked To Bullying On The Site (August 2013)”
Has the bullying situation improved?
Following the suicide some assessment of bullying and reporting thereof would be very illuminating. I see what they have done and some policy and position considerations but what’s missing are metrics regarding wether the bullying situation improved in the time since the suicide during which all these efforts were made. Is what they are doing making any difference?
UK Prime Minister David Cameron’s criticism involved asking parents to make sure their kids weren’t being dicks online.
Oh wait, no, that isn’t what happened at all.
No, obviously if their kids aren’t dicks on that specific platform then the problem is solved.. Not like they could just move their bad behaviour elsewhere and do the same thing at school, sports events, parks, etc etc
How about as parents, we monitor our kids social media accounts and internet browsing. I know shocking, we can just blame the companies that run said social media/websites instead. Shocking.
Online Dating tips to help you Find Love
Everyone knows that you have to have a profile photo if you want people to take you seriously on online dating services. One <a href=https://www.love-sites.com/latin-women-date-online-dating-advice-for-men/>Latin women</a> photo is not always enough and you also need to change your photos often. If a person has had an online profile for a while or are starting a new one, You should plan to update your profile photo and add new photos at least every three months.
Just because you have one bad experience while trying online dating, doesn’t suggest you won’t find love on a different site or with another member. Some people join countless dating site at a time so they can meet more people. If you are new to online dating service, You might simply want to stick with one site until you get used to everything.
don’t waste your time or anyone else’s with dishonesty. If you are searching for a real relationship you have to be honest from the start. Even if you’re you are telling a harmless lie, It could return to haunt you later. The last thing you want to do is have to admit to a lie after you have established a great relationship with someone online.
These three tips can make online dating easier and better established and could even help you find love. peace of mind.
Click to express on Facebook (Opens in new windows)Click to share with you on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)Click to share with you on Reddit (Opens in new window case)Click to share with you on Twitter (Opens in new eye-port)Click to express on Tumblr (Opens in new wind shield)Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new time frame)Click to express on Pocket (Opens in new truck’s window)Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new eye-port)Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new door)Click to talk about on Skype (Opens in new time frame).