Techdirt's think tank, the Copia Institute, is working with the Trust & Safety Professional Association and its sister organization, the Trust & Safety Foundation, to produce an ongoing series of case studies about content moderation decisions. These case studies are presented in a neutral fashion, not aiming to criticize or applaud any particular decision, but to highlight the many different challenges that content moderators face and the tradeoffs they result in. Find more case studies here on Techdirt and on the TSF website.

Content Moderation Case Study: Nextdoor Faces Criticism From Volunteer Moderators Over Its Support Of Black Lives Matter (June 2020)

from the everything-is-politics dept

Summary: Nextdoor is the local ?neighborhood-focused? social network, which allows for hyper-local communication within a neighborhood. The system works by having volunteer moderators from each neighborhood, known as ?leads.? For many years, Nextdoor has faced accusations of perpetuating racial stereotyping from people using the platform to report sightings of black men and women in their neighborhood as somehow ?suspicious.?

With the various Black Lives Matter protests spreading around the country following the killing of George Floyd in Minnesota, many companies have put out messages of support for the Black Lives Matter movement, including Nextdoor, which put up a short blog post entitled Black Lives Matter, with a few links to various groups supporting the movement.

This happened around the same time that the site started facing criticism because users posting support of the Black Lives Matter movement were finding their own posts being removed as leads were claiming that posts about the protests violated guidelines not to discuss ?national and state? political issues (even when the posts were about local protests).

Meanwhile, many of the ?leads? were using their own forum to complain about the company?s public support for Black Lives Matter at the same time that they believed discussing such issues on the platform violated rules. The ensuing discussion (which in many ways mimicked the wider national discussion) highlighted how frequently local leads are bringing their own political viewpoints into their moderation decisions.

When the company also added posts to local Nextdoor communities that highlighted black-owned businesses, as part of its support for Black Lives Matter, it again angered some leads who felt that such posts violated the rules they had been told to enforce.

Decisions to be made by Nextdoor:

  • When there are national conversations around movements like Black Lives Matter, when is it appropriate to take a public stand? How will that stand be perceived by users and by local moderators?
  • If the company is taking a stand on an issue like Black Lives Matter, should it then make it clear that related content should be kept on the platform — even if some moderators believe it violates other guidelines?
  • How much leeway and power should local, volunteer moderators have regarding what content is on the platform?
  • How much communication and transparency should there be with those local moderators?
  • How involved should the company get with regards to implicit or unconscious bias that may come from non-employee, volunteer moderators?
  • Is it feasible to have a rule that suggests that local communities should not be a platform for discussing state or national political issues?  How does that rule play out when those ?national or state? issues also involve local activism?

Questions and policy implications to consider:

  • When issues of national importance, such as civil rights, come to the forefront of the public discussion, there is often the likelihood of them becoming politically divisive. When is it important to take a stand despite this, and how should any messaging be handled — especially in cases where some staff or volunteers may feel otherwise?
  • Issues of race are particularly controversial to some, and yet vitally important. How should companies handle these questions and debates?
  • Using volunteer moderators to help moderate targeted niche communities has obvious benefits, but how might historical bias and prejudice manifest itself in doing so?

Resolution: Nextdoor has continued to support the Black Lives Matter movement, and Gordon Strause, the company?s director of community, went onto the forum where some leads were complaining to explain the company?s position and why they were supporting Black Lives Matter, and to push back against those who argued that the movement itself was discriminatory, while also highlighting how there were a variety of perspectives, and there was value in learning about other viewpoints:

In an attempt to quell the furor, Gordon Strause, the company?s director of community, wrote on the leads forum on Monday from his ?own perspective? and not ?on behalf of Nextdoor.? Noting that ?it?s of course absolutely true all live [sic] matters, whether they are black, white, brown, blue, or any other color,? he explained his views on Black Lives Matter.

?The goal of the BLM movement, at least as I understand it, is simply to make the point that black lives matter as much as any other lives but too often in America that isn?t actually what happens in practice and this dynamic needs to change,? he wrote.

?While no one that I know or respect believes that looting helps anything, there are folks that I respect (including people in my own family) who believe that riots may be a necessary step to help the country finally understand the scale of injustice that has been happening,” he wrote, “while other folks I respect believe that the riots will be counterproductive and will only undermine the goals they are meant to achieve.? Strause then went on to recommend a book from psychologist Jonathan Haidt and urged leads ?to listen and not to judge.?

?While Nextdoor is generally not the place for discussions of national issues, I think it?s going to [sic] hard to restrain those discussions in the coming days without being perceived as taking sides. So rather than trying to do so, I would recommend that Leads instead focus on a different goal: keeping the discussions as civil and issue focused (rather than personality focused) as possible,? he wrote.

Filed Under: , , , , , ,
Companies: nextdoor

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Content Moderation Case Study: Nextdoor Faces Criticism From Volunteer Moderators Over Its Support Of Black Lives Matter (June 2020)”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment

This comment has been flagged by the community. Click here to show it.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Killing?

Um, what part of Floyd died of a drug overdose don’t you understand?

The only autopsy that has come to that conclusion is the imaginary one used by right wingers so that they do not have to admit the police are capable of murder, and so attack the protestors.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Killing?

"He wasn’t killed."

I look forward to your publication of relevant evidence in support of your claim. I am not holding my breath however.

"Content moderation is fascism. It should be outlawed. In a free country it would have been. Like 10 years ago."

Outlaw fascism or moderation? Making either one a criminal act would preclude your desire for a "free country". Your logic fails.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Mike Masnick (profile) says:

Re: Killing?

Um, what part of Floyd died of a drug overdose don’t you understand? He wasn’t killed.

You have posted this false line over and over again, and every time you do it has been debunked. He did not die of a drug overdose. There were two separate autopsies and neither one said he died of a drug overdose. Some grifters have pretended one of them did say that, but they are shopping a line to suckers.

Don’t be a sucker.

Content moderation is fascism.

No, it’s free speech. I have the right to choose who I allow to speak on my property. You seem to think that private companies should be forced to allow any idiot asshole to mouth off?

Scary Devil Monastery (profile) says:

Re: Killing?

"Um, what part of Floyd died of a drug overdose don’t you understand?"

The part where that still is a lie? Both coroners agreed that asphyxiation was what killed Floyd. The initial police coroner determined that there were traces of fentanyl in Floyd’s blood, but that isn’t the cause of death, and even the police coroner admitted as much.

I realize that you have a vested interest in lying through your teeth about the cause of George Floyd’s death but by now you should realize that denying the expert evidence doesn’t fly on this forum.

Hell, looking at some of your previous posts I’m inclined to applaud you for actually using Floyd’s name rather than using ethnic slurs.

Scary Devil Monastery (profile) says:

Re: Killing?

" Content moderation is fascism. It should be outlawed. In a free country it would have been. Like 10 years ago."

What sort of free country outlaws private property rights?

That you and your cross-burning brethren are getting kicked from facebook and twitter every time you start discussing the "inferiority of the black man" is something for which we are all grateful.

And that gratitude is the feeling of actually living in countries where we are free to choose social platforms which tosses racists and bigots out on their asses.

Did you have anything to add other than "I’m a victim of bigotry because no one wants to let me dwell in their living room and scream bigoted lies at bypassers through my bullhorn!!"?

Ligoren (profile) says:

Racism is still an issue in the United States. Recently there have been serious protests over it. Although it is possible that the last election was just as much a part of it. There are several points of view on this subject. For example, I have researched several essays on racism and the "Black Lives Matter" movement right here . I learned a lot about this movement and what their true motives are and still are. It may even come as a surprise to some. Good luck, I hope I helped!

Rishmpk (user link) says:

what to expect when marrying a filipina

My boyfriend was horrified

abruptly, Six months into our love,My boyfriend was insatiably curious about everything that had happened before we’d met. the questions started out simple enough: How old were you when you had been first kissed?Then theyquickly escalated into points like:have you had sex in a public place?When he got an answer that made me seem not so much as virginal, We struggled. rather than being intrigued, He turned out insulted. With each new analysis,It was getting started as clear that hethought I was a slut, And i think overall I was normal.

I was 29 years old at that time, And hewas no longer my first. He knew regarding. We had been friends with regard to a, And in that time we both dated and slept web-sites,But what mattered to me was that we were in a committed relationship in concert now. When he smiled and told me he loved me, I deemed him. When he told me he thought we mightspend us together, I idea him.

At first I thought maybe he was nervous that I was disappointed in our sex life. I explained to him that he was the only person that I dreamed of being with. (no, I did not fantasize about being with men. n’t any, I didn’t wish to have some sort of mnage a quatre.) He stopped ranting just long enough to become me whisper all these things, And the dealing with would cease. Thenanother probing idea would pop up.

"How many many people you slept with, He expected again.

I wanted to do lie, But I’m a terrible liar. Good luck appointment setting that second date.

I was infuriated. What a double standard! As the woman in this association, I was likely to be pure as the <a href=>how to tell if a vietnamese woman likes you</a> driven snow, But regardless how many women he’d been with, I was purported to accept it?

i can agree, while, I did recognize it. i did not care how many woman he had slept with. He was with me at night now, And which was enough. My info, stated, Were never sufficiently for him.

Here’s a look at some incredible takeaways from 2015 research about the sex lives of the millennial generation. (Claritza Jimenez/The miami Post)

This question How many technicians youslept with? was really a trick. My number had not been that high. But that wasn’t going compare unique car features. Anything compared to onewas going to be too much for him. hopefully, I responded to him. He left of the room.

Story continues below posting

In any the relationship, i would like to feel accepted as I am. There was no amount of proof I could offer to showthat I was sufficiently for him. not surprisingly, I couldn’t take back anything I had done in the last. and possibly even if I could, why isn’t I? I wasn’t self-conscious. All of my viewpoints made me me. But suddenly I was in a affair where I was required to defend my right to have sex before I’d even met him. It was on an emotional level exhausting.

We asked each other 36 questions to fall in love. Then we left each other.

It became clear that this relationship was not going to offer me the level of realization and trust that I craved.

When I started dating a new guy,I waited for the questions to begin. I was going to see how this new man would react,But those queries never came. We developed adeep mutual insight and respectfor each other, And in this market place I blossomed. When he informed me he loved me I knew that he did. When he said to marry him, I believed, "certainly,

The man I ended up with was never once about my history. being with him, And which has been enough.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Older Stuff
15:43 Content Moderation Case Study: Facebook Struggles To Correctly Moderate The Word 'Hoe' (2021) (21)
15:32 Content Moderation Case Study: Linkedin Blocks Access To Journalist Profiles In China (2021) (1)
16:12 Content Moderation Case Studies: Snapchat Disables GIPHY Integration After Racist 'Sticker' Is Discovered (2018) (11)
15:30 Content Moderation Case Study: Tumblr's Approach To Adult Content (2013) (5)
15:41 Content Moderation Case Study: Twitter's Self-Deleting Tweets Feature Creates New Moderation Problems (2)
15:47 Content Moderation Case Studies: Coca Cola Realizes Custom Bottle Labels Involve Moderation Issues (2021) (14)
15:28 Content Moderation Case Study: Bing Search Results Erases Images Of 'Tank Man' On Anniversary Of Tiananmen Square Crackdown (2021) (33)
15:32 Content Moderation Case Study: Twitter Removes 'Verified' Badge In Response To Policy Violations (2017) (8)
15:36 Content Moderation Case Study: Spam "Hacks" in Among Us (2020) (4)
15:37 Content Moderation Case Study: YouTube Deals With Disturbing Content Disguised As Videos For Kids (2017) (11)
15:48 Content Moderation Case Study: Twitter Temporarily Locks Account Of Indian Technology Minister For Copyright Violations (2021) (8)
15:45 Content Moderation Case Study: Spotify Comes Under Fire For Hosting Joe Rogan's Podcast (2020) (64)
15:48 Content Moderation Case Study: Twitter Experiences Problems Moderating Audio Tweets (2020) (6)
15:48 Content Moderation Case Study: Dealing With 'Cheap Fake' Modified Political Videos (2020) (9)
15:35 Content Moderation Case Study: Facebook Removes Image Of Two Men Kissing (2011) (13)
15:23 Content Moderation Case Study: Instagram Takes Down Instagram Account Of Book About Instagram (2020) (90)
15:49 Content Moderation Case Study: YouTube Relocates Video Accused Of Inflated Views (2014) (2)
15:34 Content Moderation Case Study: Pretty Much Every Platform Overreacts To Content Removal Stimuli (2015) (23)
16:03 Content Moderation Case Study: Roblox Tries To Deal With Adult Content On A Platform Used By Many Kids (2020) (0)
15:43 Content Moderation Case Study: Twitter Suspends Users Who Tweet The Word 'Memphis' (2021) (10)
15:35 Content Moderation Case Study: Time Warner Cable Doesn't Want Anyone To See Critical Parody (2013) (14)
15:38 Content Moderation Case Studies: Twitter Clarifies Hacked Material Policy After Hunter Biden Controversy (2020) (9)
15:42 Content Moderation Case Study: Kik Tries To Get Abuse Under Control (2017) (1)
15:31 Content Moderation Case Study: Newsletter Platform Substack Lets Users Make Most Of The Moderation Calls (2020) (8)
15:40 Content Moderation Case Study: Knitting Community Ravelry Bans All Talk Supporting President Trump (2019) (29)
15:50 Content Moderation Case Study: YouTube's New Policy On Nazi Content Results In Removal Of Historical And Education Videos (2019) (5)
15:36 Content Moderation Case Study: Google Removes Popular App That Removed Chinese Apps From Users' Phones (2020) (28)
15:42 Content Moderation Case Studies: How To Moderate World Leaders Justifying Violence (2020) (5)
15:47 Content Moderation Case Study: Apple Blocks WordPress Updates In Dispute Over Non-Existent In-app Purchase (2020) (18)
15:47 Content Moderation Case Study: Google Refuses To Honor Questionable Requests For Removal Of 'Defamatory' Content (2019) (25)
More arrow