EU Orders Makers Of DieselStormers To Change Name Because Diesel Clothing Trademarked Diesel For Everything
from the you-got-game? dept
In trademark disputes and their resolutions, it’s not often that I see a pure headscratcher. That is to say, I rarely see a ruling on a trademark dispute and find myself at a loss for all explanation. This is, however, one of those cases. The dispute is between Black Forest Games, makers of a game entitled DieselStormers and Diesel the company, which makes clothing. The problem arose over a year ago, it seems, when Diesel reached out to Black Forest Games about the title of the game, expressing concern that it was a trademark violation of the Diesel brand.
The dispute began in July 2014 when Black Forest Games, maker of Giana Sisters: Twisted Dreams, received a trademark claim from Diesel over the name of its co-op arena brawler, Dieselstormers, which was funded through Kickstarter and released to Steam Early Access in July 2014. The Italian clothing manufacturer had claimed there would be a “likelihood of confusion” if Dieselstormers received its own trademark. Diesel’s trademark covers things outside of clothes, such as toothpaste, walking sticks, Christmas tree decorations – and games.
“In all probability an understanding will be reached as Black Forest have no intent to create clothing under the Dieselstormers brand,” the developer stated at the time, before adding, “the ‘Diesel’ part of Dieselstormers refers to the liquid fuel type of the same name and is not a parody of the fashion brand.”
Turns out no understanding was ever reached, however, and Diesel ended up taking the dispute before the EU Office for the Harmonization in the Internal Market (OHIM). At issue was Diesel’s registration of their trademark “Diesel,” including in the marketplace for games. The reason why the developer kept referring back to clothing, including in the quote above, is because Diesel doesn’t make games. Like, at all. And Black Forest Games doesn’t make clothing using the “Diesel” mark. In other words, for the OHIM, there was no internal market to harmonize, because there was no conflict. If anything, Diesel had registered a trademark for a market it wasn’t participating in, which is typically grounds for the loss of the trademark. Nothing about this seemed to make sense.
Unfortunately, the OHIM is apparently in possession of logic that I don’t have access to, because it is forcing Black Forest Games to change the name of DieselStormers to something else.
Now, over a year later, the Office for the Harmonization in the Internal Market (OHIM), which rules on trademark matters in Europe, has decided in Diesel’s favour – and forced Black Forest to come up with a new name.
“This decision has caught us with our pants down,” said Black Forest boss Adrian Goersch. “We are quite surprised that our trademark application has been formally denied. We are no multinational corporation, we cannot fight this decision, even though, frankly, it is a disaster with indie marketing as difficult as it is today. But the history of this game and our company as a whole has been marked with tough challenges and we will manage to overcome this one as well. First of all, we will make sure everyone will be able to keep playing the game, then we’ll come back with a new name.”
And why? Because a clothing company registered a trademark in a marketplace it isn’t participating in and then had the gall to push around a small game developer over it. Whatever you might think the purpose of trademark is or should be today, it sure isn’t this.