Chris Dodd Implies US Gov't Should Go After Wikileaks For Publishing Leaked Sony Emails

from the that-pesky-first-amendment dept

Variety has a report on the talk that MPAA boss Chris Dodd gave at CinemaCon, in which he appears to at least imply that the federal government should go after Wikileaks for publishing an archive of the leaked emails from Sony Pictures:

He did condemn WikiLeaks? decision last week to publish a searchable list of the Sony materials, calling it ?terribly wrong? and serving ?no public purpose.? Dodd noted that many of the emails are from low-level employees who have a right to privacy.

Dodd said that the U.S. government was in the best position to try to go after the website not the trade organization he runs. In the case of the WikiLeaks situation, he praised Sony officials for being ?highly responsive? in communicating with the proper authorities.

This is the same Chris Dodd who (before he worked for the MPAA) once gave a rousing speech at Google (of all places) in which he urged them to take a stronger stand against censorship and not giving in to government demands to block content.

Tell the Chinese government that Google.cn will no longer censor information with Google’s consent. And should the Chinese government not find that acceptable, then Google.cn would shut down its operations. I understand that you’ve already moved all of your search records out of China, to prevent them from being turned over to the Chinese government. But what better way to affirm Google’s commitment to the free flow of information as a human right, than to send this message to a nation with the largest population in the world?

But now, when a site is revealing some rather newsworthy leaked emails from Sony, Chris Dodd (MPAA version) wants the US government to throw the book at them and try to censor them. In that Google speech, Dodd said:

One way we respond to change, in my view, is to stand up, and to stand up for our principles, which do not change.

Apparently, your principles do change when the MPAA pays you over $3 million per year. I’m sure Dodd sleeps well at night with that money as a cushion, but I do wonder how he reconciles the fact that he sold out his principles.

Filed Under: , , ,
Companies: mpaa, sony, wikileaks

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Chris Dodd Implies US Gov't Should Go After Wikileaks For Publishing Leaked Sony Emails”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
36 Comments
tqk (profile) says:

Re: Re:

He reconciles his morals with lots and lots of money.

You believe he has morals? How … quaint. Somebody the other day called him a paid shill for “special interests.” Oh yeah, that was me!

He did condemn WikiLeaks’ decision last week to publish a searchable list of the Sony materials, calling it “terribly wrong” and serving “no public purpose.”

Who gives Dodd the right to determine that? Chris, you’re stupidly incorrect, and a paid shill. It does serve my interest, and I’ll bet lots of other people’s interests, all of whom you’re now paid to ignore, or worse. Do you have any pride in yourself left?

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re:

If anyone did obtain access to Dodd’s computer and got hold of copies of his emails and documents etc. and made all of them public on a site like Wikileaks then Dodd will no doubt be straight on the phone to the FBI demanding that find and charge the person for a terrorist act and calling for the person to face the death penalty.

That One Guy (profile) says:

Re: There's a slip...

Nah, that wasn’t a slip, that’s just a cheap emotional plea, ‘Please, won’t you think of the poor employees?’

Of course other than simple curiosity, most people, and certainly most people reporting on the data, aren’t likely to really care about the data regarding the low-level employees, as why should they when there’s much more juicy details in the pile?

Anonymous Coward says:

The government needs to investigate the MPAA for bribery of officials. The biggest problem for Sony is doing things that were not exactly legal, such as the rootkits and then it being exposed to the public. This means there is more dirt there they are afraid will come out.

An inside view of how the MPAA plans to kill off all competition and put into place major censorship blockaids. Were everything stickly above board, no one would care that Sony’s emails were leaked. The MPAA wouldn’t care either. So they come away butt hurt that their dastardly plans were exposed to the public. Something they know if the public knew it would not approve of. That’s the main problem, not that the emails were exposed.

With the exposure also comes the chance someone will discover the illegal bribes and plans they have in mind. Couldn’t happen to a nicer bunch.

Anonymous Coward says:

Alot of the sony emails reveal actions that are anti consumer ,pro big corporation,
eg reduce fair use, support tpp agreement,
support politicians that would reduce consumer rights
in terms to acess to certain services or websites ,or extend copyright terms make infringement a more serious offence .
The mppa has opposed every almost new technology eg vcrs,
online video services etc
ITS not there to protect consumer rights or openness on the web .
Alot of the sony emails are newsworthy as they
refer to issues that effect the economy the rights of the consumer
and trade agreements and fair use .

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re:

employees who have a right to privacy.

Not if you have something to hide.

You might really be NSA! Or incurably sarcastic.

Since it is impossible to know who has something to hide and who does NOT have something to hide, it is necessary to eliminate privacy from everyone in order to discover those who DO have something to hide.

Only a crooked NSA employee could see that as logic.

—-

GEMont (profile) says:

Nothing personal you understand. Its just business.

“…but I do wonder how he reconciles the fact that he sold out his principles”

Easy. He did not sell out his principles.

He keeps them in a suitcase in the closet at home, so he can properly utilize whatever set of principles his current employers might deem suitable, without conflict.

In this way, he can, when necessary, retrieve his old principles quickly for such things as interviews, public discussions and TV photo-ops.

In the world of big business, this is called “Principle Flexibility”.

Without it, one cannot possibly work for the Dark Side, without incurring the debilitating side effects of conscience, remorse and guilt.

As these side effects tend to degrade the ability to do what “must be done, regardless”, and thus reap the maximum rewards from the Dark Side, a portable set of principles is an absolute necessity for all successful minions to develop and maintain.

tqk (profile) says:

Re: Nothing personal you understand. Its just business.

Without it, one cannot possibly work for the Dark Side, without incurring the debilitating side effects of conscience, remorse and guilt.

Those are easily overcome with liberal doses of ethyl alcohol, which I’m quite sure he employs with great vigour. What congresscritter doesn’t? Perhaps not Elizabeth Warren or reps from Utah (maybe), but they’ll be exceptions to the rule.

GEMont (profile) says:

Re: Re: Nothing personal you understand. Its just business.

Ah too true.

Alcohol will dull the feel of steel and allow the villain to do the deeds and forget the details.

However, a minion must consider that his employer might call upon him at any time and demand service.

The Fascist Employer will always see alcohol or drugs as a weakness that might lead that minion to tell tales while under the influence, so a set of transferrable morals, flexible principles and malleable honor are necessary gear for the successful minion in today’s cut throat world domination business.

After all, there are a million other minions waiting at the door seeking his job and even the tiniest visible weakness could mean the loss of the two things he holds truly dear.

Money and the belief that he is on the winning side.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...