Law Professor Edward Lee's Favorite Techdirt Posts Of The Week

from the plus-a-book dept

It’s a real treat to pick my Favorites of the Week on Techdirt. I’m a huge fan of this site! I teach intellectual property and Internet related courses at IIT Chicago-Kent College of Law. In researching my book The Fight for the Future: How People Defeated Hollywood and Saved the Internet–For Now, I read Techdirt’s daily coverage of SOPA and ACTA in 2011-2012. Techdirt’s coverage was amazing and filled the void left by the mainstream media, which basically ignored SOPA and ACTA for as long as it possibly could. If you are interested, my book on the SOPA/ACTA protests comes out mid-September under a Creative Commons license; more news on my Facebook page. I hope to give a book reading at SXSW, so please consider voting for my talk.

1. The Netflix model. My favorite post this week was, hands down, the post on actor Kevin Spacey’s speech about the Netflix distribution model for his show House of Cards, plus other shows including Orange Is the New Black and Arrested Development. With these shows, Netflix now provides its own original content (in addition to other content). The uniqueness of Netflix’s approach is to provide online all the episodes of the first season of House of Cards at once, so the viewer can watch it whenever she wants–without commercials (except for product placements). I don’t watch any series on TV except for Mad Men. But the buzz around House of Cards–which just got 9 Emmy nominations–coaxed me to give the show a try. I watched one episode a night for a two week period and was thoroughly impressed. I did enjoy the freedom to watch the show on my own time, but I enjoyed even more the great acting by Spacey, Sean Wright, and Kate Mara. To me, the most disruptive part about Netflix’s model is not the freedom for the viewer, but the break from Hollywood’s stranglehold on what programs to broadcast. We might get better shows to watch if new, nontraditional outfits like Netflix, YouTube, Amazon, and others start producing a lot of original content. Then, it’d be time to give up cable, for sure. That’ll be a new Big Bang Theory, and the start of something really revolutionary.

2. Social Media Contract. I enjoyed reading the post about Lodi School District’s new Social Media Contract for students who participate in extracurricular activities and athletics, in an attempt to stop cyberbullying. Apparently, the school district contract would have banned these students from saying a number of things on social media–a good deal of which looked like protected speech under the First Amendment. Good job by the Bear Creek High students who protested the new policy and successfully convinced the school district to retract it. That’s a victory for free speech. Students have rights, too.

3. SOPA and the Syrian Electronic Army hack of NYT. This post was a last minute addition to my list because I couldn’t resist discussing SOPA again. During the SOPA debate, many prominent Internet engineers criticized the DNS blocking provision of SOPA because the practice of DNS blocking would interfere with DNSSEC, the more secure protocol being developed with the U.S. government backing. Under DNSSEC, each domain name is supposed to match up and be authenticated with its IP address. As the important White Paper of May 2011 by five leading Internet engineers explained: “By mandating redirection, PROTECT IP would require and legitimize the very behavior DNSSEC is designed to detect and suppress. Replacing responses with pointers to other resources, as PROTECT IP would require, is fundamentally incompatible with end-to-end DNSSEC. Quite simply, a DNSSEC-enabled browser or other application cannot accept an unsigned response; doing so would defeat the purpose of secure DNS.” What I find interesting is that in Tim Lee’s Washington Post article, David Ulevitch, the CEO of OpenDNS, says that DNSSEC won’t be able to stop the DNS hacking by the Syrian Electronic Army. If that is the case, then the DNSSEC would seem to have an obstacle or gap in achieving its cybersecurity goal. I’m not a technology expert, so I welcome more knowledgeable people’s comments on this front.

4. Retiring Senators as Lobbyists. I must confess I wasn’t surprised by the post showing that 50% of retiring Senators are lobbyists. At least there is a one-year moratorium from lobbying Congress for retiring House members, and a two-year moratorium for retiring Senators. But, as the USA Today reported, there’s no bar on lobbying the White House right away, or just providing advice to corporations or interested parties. Is this really bad for democracy? I think it might be if the former Senators are exerting special privileges or connections from their days in the Senate that give them an undue advantage over other lobbyists. But if the retired Senators hold no special sway once they leave office, then they are no worse than other lobbyists–which probably is bad enough.

5. The Survey Bay: Who the “Pirates” Are. I am excited to explore the new database on the Pirate Bay users, as discussed by this post. Data and empirical research are all the rage in my field. My school, Chicago-Kent College of Law, launched a new Center for Empirical Studies of Intellectual Property, with a conference in October if you are interested. My next book, The New Free Speech, will be about Internet freedoms, so I am particularly interested in mining the comments on that topic in The Survey Bay.

Those were my Top Five Favorite Posts of the Week. There were so many other great posts I could have chosen, especially the hilarious saga of the Modern Family photo used without permission (or a clue) in the book jacket to the Bible Principals of Child Discipline. Thanks for spending a few minutes with me.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Law Professor Edward Lee's Favorite Techdirt Posts Of The Week”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Anonymous Coward says:

After 40 years I came to the sad conclusion that politics and law really are not the best way to change anything, nor is revolutions which just people even more incompetent people in power.

Change comes when people change, then opportunistic politicians jump onboard trying to claim they are responsible for the results(see NY mayor) and outdated laws start being mocked public so the justice managers start visualizing the changes that happened and go out their law playground to see the wider sandbox they are in.

Still I am optimistic with the future, open source, open healthcare, tech that is enabling everyone to produce just about anything, our own drive to learn how things works and apply that knowledge is starting to create a world where we just don’t react but are able to actually master our own environment in ways that look like science fiction.

And still there is plenty to do, people still fall for issues that sound foolproof but if you take a close look, what is said and done is not about the issue at all but have other agendas, people don’t stop to think about what they support they apparently just turn the auto-pilot and let it rip without thinking about the consequences, this is probably the number one cause of the surveillance state that was allowed to appear, this is probably why so many laws are so perverse, but I am hopeful, people will learn basic logic, even us here on Techdirt.

Every debate, every discussion is a step in that direction, even with the trolls which are so helpful.

Long live freedom of speech and learning.

Pragmatic says:

Re: Re: Re:

As long as there are people we will need government to maintain order, like it or not. They will require services, which will have to be paid for by subscription or taxes (take your pick) and must be kept accountable to ensure that the service is actually being delivered.

Show me an anarchist nation that actually works. Go on, show me. You can’t because it doesn’t exist.

horse with no name says:


1. The netflix model is basically a way to monetize after initial distribution. It’s not generally a primary way to pay for content, because people are not paying premium for stuff, it’s all included. Imagine for a moment if everyone pirated, that model would be dead as a dodo too.

2. We are a society are still dealing with the way that the internet and social media cut a swath across our lives, meaning that many things don’t start and end at the door of a given establishment anymore. It’s certainly not settled by any means.

3. DNSSEC is a red herring in most debates, a security system that isn’t in place except in a few exceptional cases, and appears to make it more difficult to address other national security issues. It’s the geeks telling the spooks how to run their intelligence systems, they have different goals and solutions that block each others. DNSSEC will likely lose out in the long run and get replaced with something a little better and a little less obstructionist.

4. Retiring senators (and their staff, and other people who have worked in the area) are likely the most knowledgeable and more able to understand the current flows and directions of a given department. If they have undue influence, then it is a failing of the system and not a failing of the companies that hire the most experienced and most in contact person to work for them.

5. Self selecting surveys are probably the worst source for information. Limiting responses to people who are interested in the topic and active means that you can draw conclusions which are just not merited.

6. Techdirt still censors my posts (puts them on hold and released them days later). Don’t you think that is an equally big issue for a site that promotes free speech?

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...