India Wants To Ban US-Based Email Systems For Government Communications Over NSA Concerns

from the pissing-off-our-allies dept

Back in June and July, during much more innocent times, Glyn Moody and Tim Cushing doubled up on stories about the intrusive surveillance system India had set up and commented on how the NSA must have been drooling over having that kind of capability. Now, those stories probably seem sweetly ignorant, since we know much more about what the NSA is both capable of doing and how little restraint they suffer, but the point is that India is not made up of saints when it comes to respecting the privacy of their citizens.

But, having said that, India is an incredibly important friend and ally of the United States. They’re an important trading partner and a nation with aligned goals when it comes to fighting terrorism. So it may be a sign of trouble that India distrusts the American government enough to force government officials to pull their email from American-based email providers.

The move is intended to increase the security of confidential government data and information after it was revealed earlier that NSA may be involved in widespread spying and surveillance activities across the globe.

In a statement to reporters here J. Satyanarayana, secretary in the department of electronics and information technology, said that data of Indian citizens using US based email services like Gmail is residing on servers which are located outside India and for now the government is concerned about the large amount of official and critical data that may be resident on those servers.

That’s the problem with unfettered hubris from a global power like the United States: you’re going to start losing friends. It’s one thing to spy on unfriendly nations. That might still have its problems, but you’re going to have an easy sell to your citizens on the question and it doesn’t matter all that much if you’re found out because, hey, the spied-upon already hate you. But when you begin turning your spy-sights on your allies, particularly allies as important as the Indian government, you just have to wonder whether more harm than good will come of all this. Yes, there’s a cynical response that this also helps those in power in India better use their own surveillance capabilities to spy on everyone within the government, but that doesn’t diminish the potential harm between US and India.

In an increasingly connected globe, the postures of our allies are every bit as important as those of our enemies. The American government pissed off a friend in India, Hopefully that won’t come back to bite us.

Filed Under: , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “India Wants To Ban US-Based Email Systems For Government Communications Over NSA Concerns”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
16 Comments
gorehound (profile) says:

We Citizens are pissed off at our Government and for many reasons.They are not our friends.I for one am glad to see India do this and other Nations.I hate this Government……..I love our Nation.Our Government are the Criminals not us………….you fuck with us and others.
You Make the Bed You Sleep In US Gov !

In other News is everyone ready to lose some of your money over yet another Default ?

out_of_the_blue says:

No, the prior items seem hopelessly naive.

“those stories probably seem sweetly ignorant,” — As in the latter: “Makes The NSA Look Like A Paragon Of Restraint” — Sheesh. — I assume that here you’re slyly taking a shot at both by linking to those howlers. Well played, Timmy.

I pointed that up with title of my censored post: Ah, here’s the “not as bad as” excuse. Because no matter what happens in India, doesn’t affect me as much as NSA and Google. The billion Indians are just going to have to solve their own problems.

Anonymous Coward says:

Yes, but...

…it’s absurd to even think about hosting any government entities’ email (that includes public universities, by the way) anywhere but inside those entities.

A mythos has grown up over the past 10-15 years running an email system is hard. This is nonsense. It’s only hard if, through poor design choices, one makes it hard. (Source: running email systems since before most of you knew there was a ‘net to run them on.) Hosting a decent email system for (let’s say) a 20,000-student college or the state department of transportation or the senate is a straightforward exercise if prudent choices are made.

And that’s the trick, really: and it’s one that most miss. They deploy Exchange and Outlook, they install Barracuda devices, they install anti-virus products — every single one of those a catastrophic blunder that sabotages their chances of success. Then they complain that “Email Is Hard” and outsource to Microsoft or Google. The proper solution is fire the idiots that made such appallingly stupid decisions and hire people who have at least a baseline level of competence in the field.

Anonymous Coward says:

I believe you will hear more of this in the days to come. One by one, more governments are going to decide they have secrets they want to keep as their secrets.

Privacy is a bigger deal in Europe than here (other than some selected countries and I think in the end that more of them will elect to seek other places to do their internet business and their communications other than ones tied directly to the US.

What did the NSA and our government think would happen when this came out? Did they some how believe it would never be exposed? Now that it is out, no one is doing anything that restores the confidence in them. Quite the opposite in that every pitch to support it has left the public and the world open mouthed at the audacity of some government supposed to be representing the land of the free being anything but free.

I have little belief nor faith in this country anymore. Not the people and the land itself but in the political leaders.

Anonymous Coward says:

also needing consideration is how the USPTO and others have been doing their damnedest to prevent countries like India, where the people cant afford a pot to piss in, from making and selling look-alike medicines, thereby reducing the income of US drug companies that wanted to maintain the exorbitantly high prices that no one could afford. the point there is, yes, many more people would die prematurely because they couldn’t buy the medicines, but the US drug companies gained nothing anyway when the drugs weren’t bought! that’s stupid thinking! ‘a’ keep the monopoly but lose money by not selling anything and get blamed for causing unnecessary deaths, or ‘b’ still lose money while saving lives. in typical US stuck up it’s own ass fashion, it goes for choice ‘a’!!

Digger says:

This from India??? The Queen of invasion?

India’s Security council forced their government to pass a law that demands that all communications that happen within their country be copied unencrypted to the government spies, so they can copy, read, do whatever they want with it all.

Any company operating within India must turn over encryption keys to decrypt the traffic.

Companies with field offices have resorted to using services like rdesktop and citrix servers residing outside of India so that their network traffic won’t be snooped on by India’s government in addition to the NSA.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...