Verizon Wireless' Solution To Tracking Fears: A Warning Sticker You'll Ignore

from the but-we're-doing-something! dept

With the new questions being raised about how much tracking data is being recorded (and potentially sent to others) from your mobile phone, Verizon Wireless has come up with a solution that allows it to wipe its hands of the problem: warning labels. Yes, the ever-popular liability minimizing trick of affixing a warning label has made its way into this debate:

I’m sure that will settle everyone’s concerns.

Filed Under: , ,
Companies: verizon wireless

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Verizon Wireless' Solution To Tracking Fears: A Warning Sticker You'll Ignore”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Fzzr (profile) says:

Verbal confirmation


How about require that a salesman verbally confirm that you understand those things before selling it to you? Of course then you get into “I don’t remember agreeing to that!” territory verbally, which is is even harder to confirm… hmm…

Nope, I guess the only way to make these things safe and fair to consumers is a transparent Opt-In.

ComputerAddict (profile) says:

Re: Re: Verbal confirmation

Simple, It makes some really useful apps work.

Google tracks where android phones are to see where phones are clustered on roadways. This way they can deduce where traffic jams are and tell their other customers to avoid that area. With an Opt in there wouldn’t be as much data, and hence the service would suffer. Or to be able to re-use your last GPS coordinate in order to speed up the next one.

Why Apple feels it needs a years+ worth of data… Well as scientists know more data is better. But really it was probably just some quick code that never got checked, they said only keep 2MB as they felt that was a small value of data( I mean thats less than one MP3! ). As it turns out txt is really small, and apparently a year’s worth of location data fit inside that 2MB.

Good ideas, Poorly Executed.

deathsbedbug (profile) says:

Verbal Confirmation....really?

I mean really guys…if people aren’t willing to read up a little on that $400 phone they are buying, it shouldn’t be the company’s responsibility to verbally make sure they understand.

I agree it needs to be more prominent than the tag being displayed, and definitely in the manual or in the setup of the phone. Agree to it, or the phone doesn’t work. But how many people read what they are agreeing to? They could be agreeing to give away their firstborn child and still click ‘I have read and accept these terms’.

You can’t idiot proof everything, the world just builds a better idiot.

Digger says:

Re: Verbal Confirmation....really?

No, what they need to do is keep that data isolated, usable only by apps that the user agrees to allow access to it, then not allow it to be transmitted anywhere, including the cellular provider. So your little how do I get there app can use it, the feds and or your what eateries are close by cannot.
Configure the API so that certain cells or sources of data cannot be transmitted, copied, buffered anywhere..

Not that difficult.

Jon B. (profile) says:

Would you feel better if it read like this?


Verizon is a cellular service company. That means we have to have a general idea where you are. How else do you think you make phone calls?

Also, that GPS thingy that makes the maps so useful? Well, of course, it knows where you are, too. And if you’re dumb enough to download apps that ask permission to access your GPS and then transmit that data to someone else, don’t start bitching to us about it later. Just so you know.

Also, coffee is hot. That really has nothing to do with this phone, but if you found this note to be helpful, you probably shouldn’t drink your coffee too fast.



G Thompson (profile) says:

This Warn You

I think the opening Warning text in ?The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: The Black Dossier?, written by Alan Moore says what I think here

WARNING: Docs after in oldspeak. Untruth, make-ups only. Make-ups make THOUGHTCRIME. Careful. Supervisor rank or not to read. This read warn you. THOUGHTCRIME in docs after. SEXCRIME in docs after. Careful. If self excited, report. If other excited, report. Everything report. Withhold accurate report is INFOCRIME. THis warn you. Are you authorised, if no stop read now! Make report! We know. Careful. Any resemblance, living or dead, is ungood. Make report. If fail make report, is INFOCRIME. Make report. If report made on failing to make report, this paradox. Paradox is LOGICRIME. Do not do anything. Do not fail to do anything. This warn you. Why you nervous? Was it you? We know. IMPORTANT: Do not read next sentence. This sentence for official inspect only. Now look. Now don?t. Now look. Now don?t. Careful. Everything not banned compulsory. Everything not compulsory banned. Views expressed within not necessarily those of publishers, editors, writers, characters.

You did it. We know. This warn you.

[for a printable version click here]

Chris Brand says:

Can it really determine my location ?

Why do they call out “its (and your) […] location” ?

Can it really tell where I am ? Is this some new feature so that if I leave it at home and somebody calls, it can tell them where to find me ? Or if I leave it on the bus it can tell some passing stranger where to go to return it to me ?

I can just hear this “Hello, this is Bob’s phone. He left me on the dresser this morning when he went to work, so you could try his work phone. But not right now, because he just went to the washroom. I expect he’ll be back at his desk in 10 minutes or so”.

Truly amazing what they can do with technology these days…

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...