Shockingly, YouTube NOT Blamed For Teen Web Attack

from the really? dept

Last week, there was plenty of news about a group of eight Florida teenagers who purposely lured another teen into someone’s home and then beat her while filming the attack — which they specifically planned to put on YouTube in an attempt to “get famous.” While there have been some attempts to point a finger of blame at YouTube and MySpace, it looks like the press isn’t jumping on that bandwagon as quickly as you might expect. Rose M. Welch writes in to point to an Associated Press article that quotes a bunch of people pointing out that YouTube is not to blame and has nothing to do with this attack. Some point out that those sites gave us a record of the attack to make it easier to capture and prosecute those responsible — while others point out that “the public” is equally as responsible for wanting to watch that kind of attack in the first place. Either way, it’s nice to see the AP quickly come out with a clear defense of why YouTube isn’t the problem here.

Filed Under: , , ,
Companies: google, youtube

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Shockingly, YouTube NOT Blamed For Teen Web Attack”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
yo ho ho.... says:

Point the finger

Isn’t it about time that we finally blame those really responsible for all of these atrocious (and disturbingly increasing) acts by amoral teenagers — its the parents fault for not taking an interest in their kids and instilling a sense of values, etc.

Blame the parents who let their kids be parented by TV and other forms of electronic mediums rather than personal interaction.

I was stunned when this happened — but worse yet is the lack of accountability assigned to the parents and others around who let their kids become such monsters!

‘Nuff said…. time to step down from my perch… and grab another beer.

EEJ (profile) says:

My 2

I haven’t seen much reported about where the parents were during all of this, and where they thought their kids were.

Her mother says she was talking bad about them online, or something to that effect. I don’t see where that’s an excuse for conspiring to brutally assault someone, and then post a video of it online for posterity. Does she really think that’s okay?

xxboxers says:

and now for the update...

This happened in my town (that’s nothing to brag about), and our sheriff deserves some of the credit for getting the attackers charged as adults and keeping the blame off of the internet. Our sheriff has his own MySpace page that is filled with information about how to use the ‘net safely, and how to avoid online sexual predators.

The girl who was assaulted is still in the hospital, but last Friday Dr. Phil’s staff posted $30,000 bail for one of her attackers so that the assailant could be on his show.

Bigboots says:

Dr. Phil and the "Running Man"

First I thought the kid’s actions were disgusting, but for a syndicated network show to profit off the misfortune of others is terrifying. Dr. Phil and the “Running Man”. “This is television, that’s all it is, it’s nothing to do with people its to do with the ratings.”

If the Dr. Phil show is trying to do some good by bringing some awareness to violent teenage predators and educate them he should donate the advertising revenue to develop programs that have a long lasting effect for years to come.

Errant Garnish (profile) says:

Who needs YouTube when you have Broadcast News?

This case didn’t, and shouldn’t, provoke criticism of “YouTube” or “The Internet” since no part of it actually played out on the web. It further illustrates the video makers’ immaturity that they allegedly believed the YouTube community would tolerate a clip of a violent assault.

The irony of the whole thing is that many more people have seen the video replayed endlessly on national newscasts than would have ever seen it on YouTube.


TheTraveler says:

Lets all video tape up beating up on 1 girl

The fact that there was like 10 of them on 1 girl, and the fact that she didn’t fight back made the whole video even better! I love the quote towards the end of the video… “Make the last 17 sec’s good”

Video Camara = $200.00
House, planning, myspacecomments = $0.00
Factthat you can’t take a skinny girl by yourself and have to show the world your an idiot! Priceless

Nasch says:

Small step

What occurred to me is that in this case YouTube was (going to be) involved after the fact. We still need to see some cases where an online service was involved via members’ actions before the deplorable crime happened, and the service still doesn’t get blamed. For example, if the teens had posted a video about their plans to assault this girl, and then done it, would people have been crying that YouTube should have seen the video and alerted police? Probably.

Tack Furlo (user link) says:

Re: Small step

Yes, but…

What if I was to go on youtube and say I am in possession of a nuclear device and a gigantic drill capable of piercing beyond the earth’s crust down to its core and causing a worldwide volcanic eruption? For kicks, we’ll even go with the whole corny back story about being named Dr. Evil and the like. To me, I’m just jokingly reciting lines from the first Austin Powers movie. To youtube, it’s funny. There are 2 ways this can turn out badly.

1) If I’m not joking (and I obviously would be – I would never use a nuke so recklessly) and youtube doesn’t report it, then the entire world gets covered in magma and many millions die. Was youtube to blame or was it just that I’m an evil SOB?

2) Youtube could be obviously aware that it was a joke but required to report it to the authorities as a threat. It eventually makes it to DHS by which time it has gone through so many transcriptions that what I said looks nothing like what Dr. Evil said in the Austin Powers movie and it looks almost like a credible threat. DHS sends agents that come and get me in the middle of the night, hogtie me and send me to gitmo, where I spend the next 6 years being tortured for what would be at best a copyright violation if I quotes too much of the movie to fall under fair use.

Ok, sure, technically there is a third option…

3) Jack Bauer teleports to my location, shoots me, and then teleports to the next internet goofball’s house and continues shooting them all until the world is safe

But I don’t watch 24 and prefer the Chuck Norris jokes over Jack Bauer, so whatever.

Alas, the real moral of this story is that if every threat on youtube was reported to the authorities (FBI, CIA, Secret Service, whoever) the vast majority of youtube would be in some form of jail, foreign or domestic, and all the good videos on youtube would be either the star wars kid or some kind of animal. (I mean, hell, even the leave Brittney alone chick is a threat to homeland security IMHO – she’s harboring a terrorist responsible for raping hundreds of thousands of ears!) The best course of action is, unfortunately, just to let those who makes threats on youtube continue to make them and respond after the fact, or else, we all get convicted with crimes that 99% of us would’ve never committed.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...