Wait, There Are Good Internet Laws?
from the just-kidding... dept
Law professor Eric Goldman has written up an article where he wanted to list out the best and worst internet-related laws out there. Coming up with “good” ones turned out to be a challenge, with just the law banning new internet access taxes and section 230 of the CDA making the list. Of course, you could argue that the safe harbor afforded by section 230 (protecting sites from the actions of their users) is based on so much common sense that there shouldn’t need to be a law to back it up. Of course, when it comes to the “bad” list, there were way too many to choose from. The DMCA makes a couple of appearances (for different parts) and there are some other blasts from the past as well. It’s pretty frustrating to read through the list, in part because so many of the “bad” laws aren’t just bad, but were obviously bad from when they were proposed. Lots of people have pointed out why those laws would do more harm than good, but so far, politicians don’t seem interested in correcting the mistakes they made with them. They passed the laws so they could claim they stopped some “bad” thing from happening online, even if the law did no such thing. It would be nice if politicians were actually held accountable for the unintended consequences of their bad laws — especially when those laws do little to actually achieve what they were proposed to do.