The Least Cool-Sounding Muni Wireless Applications Are The Most Valuable Ones

from the boring-but-useful dept

With all the interest in municipal wireless networks, there’s been a lot of hype suggesting the networks that offer ubiquitous coverage could supplant fixed broadband and even cellular networks, accompanied by a lot of fuss that local governments have no business competing with these companies. However, both takes on the issue are inaccurate since the networks are a long way from being viable replacements for existing fixed or mobile networks, while in most cases, municipalities aren’t acting as an ISP. Either way, they focus the attention on the public-access aspect of muni wireless, often ignoring the other benefits the networks can provide to local governments and their citizens. We’ve believed for some time that the real benefits of muni wireless could come from public service applications like remote meter-reading, security or public safety communications, with public internet access an added benefit on top. Now, a muni wireless consultant agrees, saying that public internet access will be the weakest financial aspect of muni networks, with mobile workforce applications showing the best return on investment in 2007. Despite studies and statistics from companies putting up muni networks saying public access is very popular, any sort of business model for it remains largely unproven (as do some of the networks themselves). While politicians look to score some PR points by talking about how they want to blanket their constituents with low-cost internet access, the real benefits of municipal wireless will come from far less sexy applications.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “The Least Cool-Sounding Muni Wireless Applications Are The Most Valuable Ones”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
110100100 (user link) says:

muni wireless sucks

Muni wireless is a huge waste of taxpayer money. If you want internet, get a damn job. If you don’t want a job, goto the library… The government has never been well-known for their efficiency and I doubt that their ability to implement internet will improve that image. Leave internet service providing up to the Internet Service Providers. Government – go do some government stuff, like lower my taxes.

Mike (profile) says:

Re: muni wireless sucks

Muni wireless is a huge waste of taxpayer money.

Many of the major muni-wireless offerings aren’t funded by taxpayer dollars, but by the private companies that operate them. The only thing really muni about them is that the gov’t offers the right of way access for the wireless access points and requires certain amounts of coverage.

who cares (user link) says:



Actually.. it doesn’t need to be highbandwidth low latency access.
Common people who simply cant afford to pay due to low budget can still benefit greatly from public access to a vast network of information and I personally don’t think it would cost that much to implement.
Education wise it would be invaluable, to the common online porn freak they can’t stand low bandwidth, to the common online gamer they can’t stand high latency.
So there may be a chance that it could work out well if the government dumbs down the network enough to point where the only the less fortunate people would dare use it.

Pete (profile) says:


First off. READ THE ARTICLES before posting. Muni-Networks are not free! They are a government built network that is open for PRIVATE business. You still have to sign up for the isp that is running on them.

Sounds like a good idea.
1. Build network. (Yes, with taxpayer money. Keep your shorts on.)
2. Allow private companies to lease network bandwidth.(Wow making money back already.)
3. Collect local taxes. (Cool. A brand new tax revenue source.)

Seems to me like it would be a good boost for the local tech economy. The cost of starting an isp on the network would be minimal as compared to building your own infrastructure. This brings access to this market down from the eletist giant isp’s and would encourage competition. So if comcast wanted to move in to the neiborhood the would have to compete with the locals. Not something they have had to do before.

So in short. quit whining about “wasting the taxpayers money”. There are bigger wastes out there. Like polititions voting themselves pay raises.

110100100 (user link) says:

muni wireless sucks

@who cares – it does have to be high speed low latency or people bitch and need to improve it. In St. Paul, the current budget is already hovering around the $300 million mark. $300 MILLION! (That is over $2,000 per household, BTW) because of this very point. Also, why build it if it won’t even benefit most people (gamers, porn freaks, pirates and the like…)?

@Pete – one waste of $$$ does not justify another. We should eliminate both wastes, of course.

jmchugh (user link) says:

Re: muni wireless

In figuring cost/benefit of muni wifi, don’t just use household numbers. Small businesses stand to benefit, especially where cabletv broadband serves mainly residential areas, and DSL has yet to serve every address in a municipality. Wifi fixes a marketplace failure where cable and telco can drag their feet, or condition service on multi-year contracts/plant construction expense.

Would you like your first responder (fire or police) to be able to download a map/floor-plan of the building they are called to for help? While current cell phone type data connections are currently used at less than broadband speeds, muni wifi improves significantly on this and other public safety/public service applications.

One last item…muni wifi presents itself because the private sector hasn’t filled the need.

Laz Sanchez (user link) says:


We do not ask the municipality for a dollar on the “WiFi” side. We offer it to the tax payers for FREE and FEE, and where we do make “tax-dollars” is on the Public safety Homeland Security side.

Some of you sound pretty savy, and others sound like no-so-savy little complainers and whiners.


God Bless America and the Freedom of Opinion! 😉

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...