Spot The Unattended Voting Machines

from the fun-for-the-whole-family dept

When the e-voting companies respond to all of the security holes that people like Avi Rubin and Ed Felten point out, one of the popular claims is that for any of these attacks to work, someone would need to be able to spend a fairly long time examining the machines — and since they’re kept locked up and protected, that would never be an issue. Of course, in years past we’ve seen reports that the voting machines are often left out in the open for days before an election, and indeed, that’s exactly what Ed Felten found. He wasn’t even looking for it this weekend when he came upon a bunch of e-voting machines left out in the open in preparation for Tuesday’s election. Once again, this doesn’t do much to raise the level of trust anyone has with these machines.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Spot The Unattended Voting Machines”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Kevin says:

Hacking Democracy

I don’t know if anyone has seen it, or even the legality of it, but the documentary “Hacking Democracy” is available on Google Video. I am in the military overseas so I won’t be able to see it in theaters, but it was so good I definitely want to buy it and convince my friends to see it. It is truly eye opening and I highly reccomend watching it. It highlights many of these issues.

Popeye says:

Fighting Overseas ...

Actually, that gives me an idea …. why not stick with the traditional paper ballot for a bit longer? While it has it’s flaws, it’s gotten us through a couple hundred plus years worth of voting …

In the meantime, let’s ship these e-voting machines to Iraq, Afghanistan and all the other places where we are fighting for “democracy”. Field test them there, where they can only foul up the election of a democracy in it’s infancy – couldn’t get too much worse …

Why not? We outsource a lot of things, but this wouldn’t actually affect jobs here in the US. Once the bugs are worked out over there I’ll stop voting by absentee ballot here.

Dosquatch says:

Re: Outsource Democracy

In the true spirit of free markets, shouldn’t American votes be sold on ebay to the highest bidder?

Bah, this is far too short-sighted. There’s no need to rig elections or buy votes. As long as you can buy the politician, it really doesn’t particularly matter who gets elected. Business figured this out ages ago.

lil'bit says:

voting machines/software

All we want or need the voting machines to do is tabulate, verifiably, votes. In other words, we want nothing more than a calculator, and a very basic one at that. So why do the companies insist they can’t share programming code because it’s proprietary? Do they have some other way of adding 1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1++1 than the rest of us do?
Given the absolute basic level of math/calculation going on, one would think the machines would be marketed on their security, verifiability and back-up features.

Oh well, it would not be the first time I seem out of touch with how the real world works . . .

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Later

The same way they’ve addressed the country’s security issues by creating the HS department (which still has yet to decently secure our ports), push and pass legislature which erodes our privacy rights further (Patriot Act, RFID) and then reroute a large percentage of national funds to fight a war that has made us more hated than before while increasing our already bloated deficit to an all-time high?

Does that sum up what our beloved Rep’s will do?

Jason says:

We should completely eliminate paper and other non electronic ballots. All electronic, all the way. Simply have the machine print a receipt out when you are done. To combat fraud, simply make the penalty for tampering with election results a slow and horrible execution, carried out in public view. Just think, we would instantly know the results of elections. The polling place should be opened for an entire week, and at the cutoff time at the end of the week, the votes are counted, and winners announced. As technology progresses, we can eliminate polling places all together, and let people vote from their home. Simply register your IP address when you register to vote, and limit the number of votes from that particular IP to the number of registered voters living in the house with that IP. If you are against this idea, then you are more than likely a member of the party that requires voter fraud to win, the democratic party, or you are an “African” AMERICAN, who has been brainwashed by the “reverend” Jessie Jackson into thinking your “civil rights” are being denied. By the way, the US Constitution does NOT guarantee the right to vote. Go ahead, look it up. You won’t find it anywhere. You won’t find the word “democracy” in there, either, but you will find the word republican. You don’t even have to read it, because I know you are too damned lazy. Simply find an online copy of the US Constitution, and use the search function of your browser.

tommo says:


I live in Palm Beach county, Florida, ground zero to election malfunction.

We now have e-voting machines, but the system we got, is from a company that gave hundreds of thousands of dollars to the Republican party to get the contract. I wonder how fair are the machines, or if my vote really counts or was changed by the machine.
In the last election there were reports that the machine would not take the vote, for the person the voter wanted, he had to go back 3 times before the machine marked his choice properly, and submitted his vote

Anonymous Coward says:



Please embrace the concept of “moving on.” was founded to push the concept after the contested 2000 election. You would like the site and what they preach.


Do your homework. Perform a google search on the following words “ohio voter fraud.” There is more than a “hint” of voter fraud from the 2004 election. I grew up in Northeastern Ohio as a Conservative Rebublican yet I refuse to ignore such things even if they “benefit” my party.

To all:
Politicians should never be trusted. Never. They are from an elite ilk bent on obtaining power and money. They take sides and preach wedge issues to push you into voting for them. Approach your politicians as you would a used car salesman, with cautious suspicion and distrust. There is ALWAYS a catch. Party loyalty and the refusal to admit your party has/can do wrong is simply letting politicians take advantage of you and control you while lining their own pockets.

Chuck who knows it all (user link) says:

Yeah blame the Republicans

because the ignorant product of teacher’s unions and 60 years of liberal controlled public schools have yielded an electorate so stupid, that they cannot check a box on a ballot with a pencil.

Solution: Congress spends $4,000,000,000 on electronic multi-language voting machines, so the illegal aliens from Asia and Mexico can vote in their native gibberish and later claim they have been disenfranchised.

We deserve it. We are fat, stupid cowards who are standing around while our democracy is hijacked by people too unmotivated to learn our official language. Our forefathers had to fight the British off of our soil for the right to vote, today we let anyone do it, and feel guilty should someone DARE suggest it be done in our official language by people who can read a ballot and follow simple instructions.

Not only should you have to have a G.E.D. to vote, you should have to have a piece of paper showing that at some point in life you paid single or jointly filed State, Fed and SS taxes. An uneducated, jobless fool has no authority to make electoral decisions. Tough excrement.


Finally, If you are senile, illiterate, or just dumb like a box of rocks and cannot operate the machine, do the nation a favor and stay home. Watch some Telemundo, Dr. Phil, or Survivor and eat yourself to death. See you at the polls bitches!

Check the Roll says:

Spot the Unattended Machine

Is Spot the name of the machine, like the dog in the first grade readers???? If so, that would explain how this machine lifted itself up from the storage area, opend the door and walked out to an “unattended” area, right?

Hey, stupid! A human was involved and until you remove the human factor, NO voting machine or paper ballot will be totally secure! Let’s face it, you can point at the machine all you want, but until you show me one walking around on it’s own, sorry, you can’t convince me.

jon says:

so wait, let me get this straight someone’s idea is to get a receipt out of the machine, and that constitutes a paper trail? bah…

i could program something to have you enter the number 1 and then spit out a receipt that shows the number but records a number 2 in the background.

i don’t trust the machines, i don’t trust the government, and when you add the two together there’s my vote…no confidence in the current administration (and it stands for the dems too)

why isn’t anyone trowing a fit about both parties? they both suck, they’re both ruining the country…this is not what our forefathers wanted, or even drafted…

we are lazy and fat and pander to any cry baby out there….we need to go back and look at some things, you want to be an american citizen, you learn the language, you take pride in the country, you stick up for it. if you’re not a citizen, you don’t get the benefits from it, you get to vote about it, you don’t to cry about it.

if your country is so bad that you gotta come here, then go home and do something about it there, instead of enabling your country to continue in it’s floundering. stop sending it money!

we need more bands like the DK’s hahahaha

but seriously, if you can’t punch a piece of paper then you shouldn’t be voting, i’m down with the no high school/g.e.d diploma then no voting, if your not a citizen – no voting, if you can’t formulate a proper sentence without sounding like you’re chatting on IM then you can’t vote, if you listen to top 40 you can’t vote, or if you believe that we should keep california (really just hollywood) instead of giving it back to mexico, you can’t vote!

well i think i’m about done….

but seriously, raise a stink, make should there is a paper trail of your vote NOT A RECEIPT! don’t give them a chance to fudge it, cuz they will given half the chance…

Rob says:

Why are there so many Libertarians in Congress?

I’m not specifically suggesting anything but there’s a way to get those currently in power (that means you Republicans) who don’t seem to care about (or more than likely, don’t understand) the problems with current electronic voting to start paying attention. I’m picturing Libertarians (or pick your favorite minor party) winning by enormous landslides across the country. By enormous landslides, I mean by about 50-100,000 more votes than the number of people who should have voted in that district. Maybe the computer illiterate (by my own impression, well over 50% of our elected officials) will start to realize that there’s a problem. Unfortunately, until it adverses affects them, most elected officials just prefer to pretend like there is no problem.

If you need a list of potential non-Republican/Democratic candidates in your area, just ask Google…

If you need detailed instructions on how to properly hack the voting machines in your area, just ask Google…

If you need to know how to get your current elected officials to pay attention to the things you think are important, your out of luck.

|3331373|3|_||3 says:

Oh dear

You idiot, if the Reps tamper withthe machines and win, then who appoints the investigatiors? If they loose, then they are a bunch of dumb shits and rdeserve the punishment.

Perhaps the best solution is to give myself all the presidential vote (I am not an American Citizen, so I cannot be president [Though my sister is US-born, so canbe]), then to give all my friends the senate and House seats, who are also not american, and some of whom have never visited America. THis might show how useless the system is, especially when we start fixing all the laws.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...