Copy Protected Music Ghettos Are Holding Back The Industry

from the doesn't-help-anyone dept

It’s nice to see a mainstream publication, like the Washington Post, start to recognize that the multiple incompatible forms of copy protection and DRM are creating “music ghettos” where songs bought from one service can’t play on certain devices and songs bought on other services can’t play on other devices — creating a huge hassle for anyone who actually wants to buy the music they like and listen to it whatever music device they like. As Tim Lee points out, one of the big culprits here (unfortunately, not mentioned in the Washington Post article) is the DMCA law and its anti-circumvention rule. Without that, someone could come along and create utilities to make songs from any of these services compatible with any device. However, thanks to the anti-circumvention rule, that’s illegal. The end result is that the entire industry is completely held back by the law that the industry itself pushed so hard for and refuses to reform. It’s yet another example where the recording industry is shooting itself in the foot by holding back its own market through short-sighted policies.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Copy Protected Music Ghettos Are Holding Back The Industry”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re:

I guess I don’t care to an extent, I am just going to download CDs from MIRC and other sources as always and to hell with RIAA and all the rest of the recording industry..

DVD-and-Music CD’s
AnyDVD : Bypasses protections on DVD’s

(Does not load any info into the OS and outright bypasses any copy protection I have come across so far… I only hope the rest of the world uses applications like this because I think that the only way to fix the issue is to steal them blind…

Justin says:

Don't download

The music industry is screwing itself and I love it.

About 2 years ago when I realized Apple locked iTunes songs for only 5 computers, I decided to never downlaod music (legally) again. When you can order a whole CD, case and all, used on for $3, why would you ever want to download a CD for $9 at a lousy sounding bitrate.

ScaredOfTheMan says:

I think it so funny. If only to be a fly on the wall during a Music Exec meeting.

They are stuck in a catch 22. DRM free music will solve their problem, but they won’t allow DRM free music.

How do bottled water company’s compete with Free water, that comes out of everyone’s tap. AND They make hundreds of millions doing it. Why can’t the labels do that?

chris (profile) says:

Re: scaredoftheman

How do bottled water company’s compete with Free water, that comes out of everyone’s tap. AND They make hundreds of millions doing it. Why can’t the labels do that?

that’s freakin’ awesome. the same can be said for libraries and broadcast television… why are bookstores doing brisk business when you can get books free at the library… why do we buy seasons of TV shows on DVD when they are always run as repeats in syndication?

Anonymous Coward says:

what about circumvention techniques that the company includes in their software? i don’t know if apple has changed this but from what i understand you can just use itunes to burn your music to cd and then rip the files from that cd… the cd doesn’t have drm on it, so the itunes program itself would be bypassing the protection scheme. it’s time consuming, yes, but it’s drm free in the end…

freakengine says:

No More ITunes for Me

Guess what Apple. I’m done. I’m tired of buying music on Itunes, only to turn around and burn it so I can rip it back into my computer in the format of my choosing. I always thought success in retail was achieved when you sold people things they wanted, and not when you shoved your overpriced crap down people’s throats.

Our society needs to remeber how to say no. No to DRM. No to odd formats. No to overpriced lo-fi tracks. No to lack of liner notes and art. It seems that people nowadays, in their quest to obtain obtain obtain have forgotten that if you aren’t getting what you want you don’t have to buy!

Mr.Obvious says:

I would be willing to bet that 90% of the music on peoples iPods are not DMR protected music bought from iTunes and would say the same for any MP3 player that supports plain old MP3’s.I know that about 99% of mine are not DRM protected and the ones that are were either given to me free through a promotion or a iTunes gift card.And I will not buy DRM protected music with my own money now or ever.Until they come out with the simple format that is not protected and I can use it how I see fit then I will still rip from my own CD’s or friends CD’s or download illegally.That is why the music industry is just barely holding their nose above the water.Because most people feel the same as me.I will pay a fair price for a fair product I can use when and how I want.Until that’s offered im a criminal under todays laws.Laws which were bought and paid for by RIAA.Our Government our the biggest crooks in the world if you ask me.I still hold out hope that one day when my generation or the next makes it to the top seat of Government they will do away with these laws.Atleast I hope anyway.

Murph says:

I like it hard!

Give me hard copy or give me an E.M.P.! I still do and will always aquire a hard copy of anything I listen to before ever moving it to my iTunes or other media player. How I aquire those hard copies is for me to worry about. But the idea of only having an eletrronic copy that is stuck in one format is just stupid. Thats one of the highlights of owning a computer. So that a person can manipulate their own media. I say to hell with the downloads, buy it from a store or amazon or copy it from friend but own it for you! Then do with it what you wish.

CGLC says:

I've seen the future of online music

Most of the music industry is completely clueless about the potential for the market of unrestricted product. They have to rethink the way it works. I’m a great fan of Magnatunes which has downloads of WAV and lossless format files (also in mp3, but I have no idea why anyone even bothers with that format except for iPod type devices that you listen to with bud earplugs) without DRM. An unheard of 50% of the purchase price (you get to decide how much to pay) goes directly to the musician. I download in WAV format (takes awhile) and then burn a cd, meaning that I have a hard copy to archive and then rip from that into whatever format I want(usually WMAL). They even give you a pdf cover art file. This is an obvious model for the music industry, if they’d just wake up to the potential. No cd production – just provide the music and allow the end user to choose what to do with it.

mbrownie says:

DRM and Device Compatability

It is laws such as these that continue to baffle me. Next there will be food that can only be cooked on a certain name brand microwave due to chemicals injected into the food. Absurd yes, impossible no. Where will it end? I will contnue to buy my music from whomever I choose and play it on whatever I like, ofcourse I still only play 8 tracks and vinyl!!!!!!!! Analog lives!,,,digital kills! ( I have learnered to convert all forms to digital, just don’t like to let it out, god help me if the entertainment industry finds out I bootlegged an 8 track!)

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...