Intel Gives Clearwire $600 Million To Avoid Making WiMax Look Bad

from the how-it-all-works dept

If you’ve watched Intel’s moves over the last few years in the WiMax space, it’s become clear that they can’t let the technology fail, despite plenty of questions about the technology. Intel has made a huge bet in the space, and over the last couple of years has single-handedly propped up the WiMax market by investing in just about every player in the space — even those who some might consider Intel competitors. Some of this was clear nearly two years ago when Intel made a huge “investment” in Clearwire — Craig McCaw’s attempt to build a WiMax-based wireless ISP (using pre-WiMax equipment, of course). That deal seemed particularly questionable since the investment came the same day that Clearwire promised to buy Intel equipment. In other words, Intel was paying Clearwire to buy its WiMax technology. Of course, for all the hype about WiMax, Clearwire has been saying that the technology is so weak that it can’t withstand people using VoIP services on it. A couple months ago, Clearwire announced that it would go public to raise a necessary $400 million. The details in the IPO filing raised a lot of questions. It didn’t have very many customers and needed an awful lot of money to keep spending on infrastructure. All in all, a bad combination. Combine that with Vonage’s weak IPO, and you could see problems on the horizon. It seemed unlikely that Clearwire could go out successfully. For Intel, that would be devastating. A bad IPO for Clearwire would raise a lot of questions about both WiMax as a technology and the billions Intel has bet on the technology. So what does Intel do? It throws more money after the problem, dumping $600 million more into Clearwire (and roping Motorola in for another $300), allowing Clearwire to pull its IPO. Problem solved (or, at least, delayed).

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Intel Gives Clearwire $600 Million To Avoid Making WiMax Look Bad”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Scott says:

Re: Alaska and Hawaii

I lived in Hawaii and Clearwire was the only option for myself and many other people who live in remote areas. I was really happy to have it. The quality was not what I would like and it was slower and more expensive than it should be. But I was able to run skype with it. And being able to take the bulky modem/antenna down to a remote beach with my laptop was nice too.

Also, I think it makes perfect sense to roll out the service in areas where there is no broadband competition. The infastructure for wireless is considerably less expensive than rolling out miles of cable to remote areas.

Brian says:

Re: Alaska and Hawaii

Ah, ignorance is bliss.

They released the Product in Alaska, Hawaii, Texas, and Florida intially (fact).

If you had any idea of the genious behind it you wouldn’t be talking. Lets take an example. If you had a new type of house siding that you wanted to sell, would’nt you put it on houses in a place that gets temps below zero? an island in the Pacific? a place that has 120 degree plus days and has tornado and dust storms? a place that is riddled with humidity and hurricanes? It’s called making sure your product works in all kinds of conditions…. its just plain good product testing.

There is also the fact that the infrastruccture that it takes to make the service work requires a tower every 2 miles or so. So it would seem that you would start small with cities that take 20 towers to cover as opposed to a city like New York that would take thousands.

Mike Mixer says:

I hope they get it together

This is an unlikely hero story in the making. Ray Kroc
failed at everything he touched until he tried selling hamburgers. Something like WiMax would be more
choice in an area where it seems all of our choices are being taken away. That is why Intel is doing this.
Wireless is the next step but the companies that own
all the wired outlets will want to control that too, so it is important for at least one player who isn’t a telco or cable company to be running strong to keep everything honest.

WirelessGuy says:

Broadband is tough to sell

I worked at a now non broadband, broadband company called airBand that still exists in technical terms, just not in the style that it was intended 5 years ago when I was there. We had a great product, quick broadband (2-3 days) with decent speeds (up to 6 Mbps) and we though we were going to print money. Well, the problem was that the technology wasn’t stable enough to compete with DSL/T-1’s and people just like knowing their company will be there tomorrow.

McCaw has done good things for telecom in the past, but most of his companies are built to be sold. Look at what happened to his wireless companies, how debt laden they were but with lots of promise. AT&T paid a boat load for his assets only then to sell later to form Cingular.

They are going after broadband starved markets like Air2Lan did (and was very successful doing) by heading to tier 2 and tier 3 markets first. Competition in tier 1 markets is just too tough, with everyone offering almost free DSL/Data services just to keep whatever market share they can.

The question is whether WiMax will live up to the press hype, or will it crumble like the first version of Clearwire, Teligent, Windstar, Angel Project, etc…It is a decent technology so as long as they build out the system slowly enough, keep their costs down, they can be successful. They just need to look at history and learn from it, or they will be doomed to repeat it.

Rollie says:

Intel Must Believe in Clearwire and Wi-Max

I must say that it looks as though a bright future may be ahead for Clearwire. Any company that invests that much money in a world-wide networking project must know something that we do not. Start saving your money for some of that Clearwire stock when their company finally becomes public……I know I wanna get in on the ground floor!

Brian says:

Re: Intel Must Believe in Clearwire and Wi-Max

Smart man Rollie is. If you don’t already know much about Clearwire’s founder Craig McCaw, I suggest a quick google search for his biography. He made something like “Mobile Phones” which back in the day seemed funny, into something we all use daily. Keep an open mind and think of what internet access could be like if you could open your laptop anywhere in the world and be online instantly, just like you were sitting at home in your local coffee shop. =)

clkwong(tm) big have@ says:

Intel buy yahoo for wimax

Wimax invest big money , but not application.

We are talking about the computer internet advertise CIA

in video email sever just like the advertise in web sever with


thank Jesus’s love ,it is Goal that can not see people who can
be seen by computerized wireless network and digital camera…
remarks : Can Not sEE means Idea in MInd!!!

Jason l Earl says:


I must say this is very interesting here I am a contractor workining in the Philadelphia PA market and have been building these sites for some time now and must say that
I,m very impressed from my stand point its alot better than Metrocom I,m sure everyone remembers what happened to them
it flopped and I also built alot of there systems in Houston TX were I also reside and tested the Clear net work and it worked great even though there not openning up that market until April the system works and there already upgrading there systems to handle the high volume user climb
so I see no failure in this only bigger gains

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...