Why A Toilet Is a Better Desk Than Your Desk

from the just-to-be-safe-don't-eat-off-your-phone dept

There have been numerous studies about the surprising places that germs are found. Once again experts are warning that objects like doorknobs pale in comparison to mobile phones and keyboards when it comes to germ load, while a typical desk, they claim, is more germ infested than a toilet seat. The conclusion is that people who consider themselves careful about germs, by flipping up a public toilet seat with their foot for example, have their fears misplaced. But what all of these studies leave out is whether people who fail to abide by proper germ prevention techniques actually get sick more often. Do teenagers who chat on cell phones and then pass it off to a friend actually have a higher rate of the flu? Do people who go to cybercafes actually come down with colds more frequently? Perhaps, there’s more to it than the simple equation of more germs equals more sickness. Still, just in case, you might want to pick up a sterilizing phone charger.


Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Why A Toilet Is a Better Desk Than Your Desk”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
37 Comments
Jeremiah (user link) says:

Bolster the immune system

Sickness is not simply an end result – often the body will develop antibodies and other immunity-related compounds in reaction to exposure to “other people’s asses.” In the long run, I bet a case could be made that all that contact with other people’s keyboards and mice (i speak of IT support) actually makes you more resilient to infection.

IMHO.

Whateva says:

Re: Re: Bolster the immune system

“Exactly. By trying to live in a bubble and “sterile” environment, we only weaken our immune systems and truly impair our ability to fend off the real threats.

That is why I refuse to get the flu shot.”

Dear Mikester — congratulations. You are so much smarter than the rest of us. You seem to think the flu shot helps people live in a “bubble and sterile environment.” You couldn’t be more wrong. The flu shot IS the germ. You are taking a small dose of (inactivated) germs to help build your immunity when that big dose arrives. But please, get your resistance the hard way and save the flu shot for the rest of us. Thanks!

Mikester says:

Re: Re: Re: Bolster the immune system

Thanks – gee, I didn’t realize I was actually getting INJECTED with the flu!

Listen brainiacs, the flu shot is a farce anyway. It is only a sample of the top flus going around the previous year. You better hope those same strains are still going around when you get the shot, other wise it’s all for nothing.

By letting your own immune system fight it off naturally, you’re doing your body a service by building it up the proper way.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: Re: Bolster the immune system

“But please, get your resistance the hard way and save the flu shot for the rest of us.”

That’s exactly what I do, but not because I don’t “believe” in the flu shot, but because there is typically a shortage of shots and my 36-year-old body is much better able to fight off minor infections than would be a 76-year-old’s who might NEED my dose. Then again, in a world where everyone has the shot, my added protection from the shot is pretty small. Hmm…is this an example of *negative* network externalities? Cool.

Tyshaun says:

Re: Bolster the immune system

Sickness is not simply an end result – often the body will develop antibodies and other immunity-related compounds in reaction to exposure to “other people’s asses.” In the long run, I bet a case could be made that all that contact with other people’s keyboards and mice (i speak of IT support) actually makes you more resilient to infection.

IMHO.

Kind of sort of. The primary problem with your statement is that viruses mutate very quickly and bacteria mutate rapidly as well.

Working as a paramedic for 8 years I can tell you that it’s more of a function of the individual. Some people have very fast acting immune systems and hardly ever get sick, some are cursed. I had a partner who was sick all the time and ended up quitting because she just couldn’t be around people with communicable diseases. Me, I caught one case of the flu in my 8 years as a medic and that’s only because my patient insisted on shaking my hands after I had taken my gloves off.

ChocoTuar says:

Re: Re:

How old were these kids? Or, more pertinently, how long have they had a “big” network? I’d bet money that in the beginning of the “network” they got sick more than would have at the time the test was taken. The beginning was probably more sickening than a “loner”‘s could ever be.

Posterlogo says:

Re: Re: Re:

“How old were these kids? Or, more pertinently, how long have they had a “big” network? I’d bet money that in the beginning of the “network” they got sick more than would have at the time the test was taken. The beginning was probably more sickening than a “loner”‘s could ever be.”

Not true at all. So very very wrong. You don’t have to get sick to build up immunity. The idea is to get EXPOSURE to mild amounts of many antigens when you are young. This is most dramatically illustrated in the case of parents who are too strict and sterile with their kids — they inevitable develop asthma and allergies. Some of it is hereditary, but a great deal of it has to do with being allowed to play in the dirt a little. Pets too — kids who are raised with atleast 1 pet have a 25-50% lower chance of getting asthma than those raised without pets.

dorpus says:

Re: Re: Re: Re:

Not true at all. So very very wrong. You don’t have to get sick to build up immunity. The idea is to get EXPOSURE to mild amounts of many antigens when you are young. This is most dramatically illustrated in the case of parents who are too strict and sterile with their kids — they inevitable develop asthma and allergies.

The proper term here would be “inevitably”, though it would still be wrong. What you are referring to is the hygiene hypothesis, which claims that kids growing up in antiseptic environment are at INCREASED RISK of developing asthma and allergies. However, there are just as many studies which show that kids exposed to certain kinds of bacteria or viruses are at increased risk of asthma/allergy themselves. Variants of the theory talk about the lack of diversity in gut flora. There is no consensus among scientists on how the hygiene hypothesis works, if it works at all.



Some of it is hereditary, but a great deal of it has to do with being allowed to play in the dirt a little.

However, there are many studies which show that certain kinds of mycobacteria (microbes that live in the soil) INCREASE the risk of allergies/asthma.



Pets too — kids who are raised with atleast 1 pet have a 25-50% lower chance of getting asthma than those raised without pets.

Here also, the results are contradictory. About half the scientific papers out there say that pets INCREASE allergies, while another half say it doesn’t. Most allergists recommend that allergy patients get rid of their pets.

BigMeanDog says:

Keyboard vs. Toilet Seat

And if you go around life avoiding “germs” , be aware, insects and animals crap on everything as well. For example, I have a large male carpenter bee that guards my back door. As you watch him fly around, he craps all over the place. I have chosen not to eradicate him since he runs off everything else that craps including birds. One crapper is better than a group of em. So remember that the next time you leave your grill brush outside on the table.

bmac (profile) says:

At least I feel better...

…when I see all of the people who never wash their hands at all. You can say that the handle on the bathroom door is cleaner than my keyboard, but after I’ve watched yet another person (usually old and rich) handle their wang or wipe their arse crack and walk directly out of the restroom without washing, it just feels better to open the door with a clean napkin. And, unless it’s an emergency, I don’t ever do number 2 at work.

Lastly on the subject of flu shots: I got one for the first time ever at the start of last winter, and I got the worst flu I’ve had in years, which turned into pneumonia. I’ll never get it again.

Anonymous Coward says:

I have allergies but it seems after a while of being exposed to something my body just gets used to it…

Like whenever I would visit my friends house her rabbit would always make me sneeze and my eyes water and everything else, now that it lives here it stopped bothering me after a couple weeks.

I’ve never gotten a flu shot and the only time I can ever remember having the flu was about 7 years ago (I was 11 then, and I was super sick but haven’t had it since).

And it doesn’t really matter HOW MANY germs are on something, it matters how harmful they are to a person. For instance your significant others mouth probably contains a shitload of bacteria, but do you make them sanitize their mouth everytime before you kiss them?

eskayp says:

Immune, or not.

And if your job is at a wastewater treatment plant?

After the initial round of exposure, you seldom get sick from flu, colds, or any of the other ‘nuisance’ diseases that plague mankind.

Every shift is a new set of free innoculations against whatever

is making it’s rounds in society.

Still have to watch out for (and get medically innoculated against)

the traditional ‘killer’ diseases: typhoid, hepatitis, tetanus, etc.

And be real careful about needle sticks or other breaches of your skin.

One question:

Does this continual ‘priming’ of the immune system have a longterm cost?

Do decades of daily exposure eventually lead to immune system failure?

Food for thought — just don’t eat it near your keyboard.

injection molding (user link) says:

we intend to take full advantage of them!

New Zealand It could take a lifetime to experience everything there is to see and do in naturally stunning New Zealand, but we’re going to pack as much as we can into just four weeks. The Lost Girls will be renting a vehicle for the first time on the trip and using to it mow down the miles between major site and destinations. We can’t wait to climb glaciers, hike volcanoes, kayak over aquamarine seas, dive into steaming natural mud baths and of course–throw ourselves off the famous Nevis bungee jump. As our resident Lord of the Rings expert (read: geek), Jen will be steering us towards all those cinematic locations made famous by Peter Jackson and his lovable Hobbits. As a fellowship nearing the end of our own epic journey, we’ll be trying to make the most of every plastic injection molding remaining day.

Bali Together at long last, we’re leaving the mainland to go surfing and sunning in gorgeous Bali. After two weeks spent getting up at noon, drinking pina coladas and otherwise acting like total bums in Kuta Beach, we’ll head inland to check out the scaffolding artwork and accessories in the bohemian town of Ubud.

Leave a Reply to injection molding Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Ctrl-Alt-Speech

A weekly news podcast from
Mike Masnick & Ben Whitelaw

Subscribe now to Ctrl-Alt-Speech »
Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...