Partial Feeds, Glass Houses, And Things That Are Broken

from the what-does-one-have-to-do-with-the-other dept

Ok, while I generally like to avoid the random silly navel gazing debates within the blogworld, a few things all combined tonight in an amusing way — and it seemed worth a post (if you disagree, and some of you will, sorry!). First of all, there’s a long (painfully pointless) debate going on among a small group of people about whether or not bloggers should include the “full text” of their posts in the feed, or if it should just be a partial post that pushes people to load the actual page to read the whole thing. There are some people who claim they won’t read a “partial feed,” which seems a bit excessive. From our standpoint, obviously, we publish full content feeds, because we know people like them, and we’d rather our readers be happy than annoyed. Either way, tonight, it appears that SixApart’s TypePad system was down for an extended period of time, just as I was going through my random set of assorted blogs I read… almost all of which publish partial feeds. I’d read a sentence and a half here or there, and then click to open, only to get a “page not found” in response. So, I was thinking that, indeed, partial feeds are a nuisance and a loss for those bloggers — because I’m unlikely to go back and check out those stories later. The rationale for partial feeds doesn’t make much sense, honestly. One reason often given is to force more people to see ads — but, let’s face it, the people reading your stuff via RSS are probably the least likely to click on your ads. The other reason is to avoid spam blogs repurposing your content — but in our experience that’s a pretty silly reason. Spam blogs that scrape and repurpose your content (and there are a ton that do that with ours) seem to disappear pretty quickly and don’t actually detract from our site at all.

However, the thing that really set this post off was that I came across ZDNet’s Steve Gillmor whining about Yahoo’s Jeremy Zawodny’s partial feeds. Normally this is exactly the type of post I wouldn’t even read, but something seemed odd — and it took me a few seconds to realize that two things didn’t make sense. (1) I came across Steve’s post in the ZDNet blogs RSS feed which (whoooooops!) is a partial text feed — so, yes, his attempt to make fun of partial feeds is, indeed, cut off itself by his own partial feed. (2) I read Jeremy Zawodny’s feed as well, and it’s full text. So, here we have someone who has a partial feed complaining about the partial feed of someone who actually appears to only offer full feeds (the two on his site both appear to be full feeds). As for the “things that are broken” in the title, it’s not just TypePad, but I tried to post a comment on Steve’s ZDNet blog and was given a big fat error message instead. Looks like we still have a few kinks to work out with this whole blogging thing.

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Partial Feeds, Glass Houses, And Things That Are Broken”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
Kevin Mesiab (user link) says:

partial vs full

The real reason for partial feeds versus full feeds was a matter of bandwidth. Feeds began as a method of syndication in a one-to-many relationship.
The purpose of truncating feeds is a matter of preserving bandwidth. This is because feeds are intended to be consumed in a much different manner than a typical webpage. Many aggregators and clients request and re-request a feed (which is itself an aggregate of many articles) with some degree frequency.
Giving a client a summary of the article and the choice of reading the full text (and exercising the bandwidth of the provider) allows for a slightly more economical distribution of load.

Andrew Strasser (user link) says:

Blog sites

Of all the news and blog sites I go to this is actually one of my favorite ones. Partials blogs could be annoying if that were the case that the main server would go down. I would hope it’d be a much more stable enviornment than that, but then again you never know what who’s thrown together in their garage. This story is just plain ludicrous really, funny though.

data64 says:

Mobile devices

One of the things I use RSS feeds is so that they can be converted into something that is actually viewable from a mobile device like the Blackberry. Not every blog provides a mobile friendly interface like Techdirt. Plus AvantGo is adding support for RSS feeds (finally).
It is simple enought to write an RSS to html convertor, plus there are a lot of free ones available. I especially love the feed from Gizmodo that includes images as well as full article text.
I really hate the one from CBC ( which only seems to have the headline and a link to the actual article, which is unusable from a mobile device.

Mikester says:


This doesn’t apply to feeds for mobile devices, but one thing I really like about the RSS Popper plug-in for Outlook is that it has the option to download the HTML page the RSS item links to, rather than just the text in the feed (or lack there of).
Like data64 mentioned, CBC and a few other feeds only include the title and nothing more which I find extrememly annoying. This plug-in gets around that.

Britt Brannan (user link) says:

Shower Doors

With the advancement and the change in living styles of people, there has been a dramatic change in people?s preferences. With the increased choices, the demands have also increased. Building a home is one of an asset which you probably will build once in a lifetime, as the choices has changed people want to go for things that are in fashion whether they are regarding clothes, cars, furniture, home, shower doors etc.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...