Does The RIAA's Silver Bullet Break Wiretap Laws?
from the looks-likely dept
The RIAA has been running around the halls of Congress showing off Audible Magic as the “silver bullet” against file sharers. Audible Magic is a system that claims to be able to identify and stop file sharing of unauthorized files in its tracks. While some have accused the product of being vaporware, it certainly is getting plenty of attention. The EFF has taken a quick look and pointed out that for all the hype, there are some simple workarounds that would make Audible Magic ineffective very quickly. However, Ernest Miller raises an even more important question: does Audible Magic violate wiretap laws? After all, it’s intercepting communications without the users’ knowledge. He goes through the various exceptions and points out that Audible Magic doesn’t seem to apply at all. Thus, it likely is an illegal wiretap. The one way to make it “legal” is if consent is somehow given beforehand. Then, of course, the problems get worse, because you’ve basically had someone agree to have all of their internet traffic open for snooping. Seems like an awful lot of effort for technology that doesn’t even work.