TimothyAWiseman’s Techdirt Profile


About TimothyAWiseman

TimothyAWiseman’s Comments comment rss

  • Dec 31st, 2014 @ 9:32am

    Requiring registration is unnecessary

    I vehemently disagree with the suggestion that registration should be required. There are huge amounts of content where registration would at least slow the publication process that ought to be protected by copyright, and that is to say nothing of unpublished works.

    With that said, I do agree that either the copyright term should be shortened dramatically or else that registration could be required to get an extended term of copyright after the initial automatic protection wears off.

  • Aug 13th, 2014 @ 10:12am

    It could be good with propert protections.

    I understand your objections to the concept, but there have been indications that something like this could reduce crime (including muggings for cell phones and others). This would only work if such kill switches are widespread and common, and that is best achieved by mandating them.

    Of course, some of the abuses by both hackers and potentially by authorities (not to mention the phone companies) are true risks. But the answer rather than abandoning the idea is to build in both legal and technological safe guards against its abuse.

  • Jul 25th, 2014 @ 10:03am

    9 Year old alone in park, how is that bad?

    How is leaving a 9 year old alone in a park with a cell phone bad parenting?

    Obviously, there could be context here not mentioned, but off hand I would call that fine. Most 9 year olds are more than mature enough to handle it, real crimes against children are rare, and in this case the kid had a way to call for help if she got hurt or had trouble. This sounds fine to me and the meddling parents and authorities should probably have stayed out of it unless there were other circumstances that actually made it dangerous.

  • Jun 17th, 2014 @ 10:28am

    The School's Fear Was Reasonable

    Reading only this article and not the opinion letters, I fear that those two opinions by the lawyers may not have been completely different. The college feared being sued as much as it feared losing that suit, and fair use is seen as an affirmative defense currently. Even a fair use ruling in your favor can be very expensive to acquire.

    It may be a criticism of our current copyright laws and in particulr the strength of fair use that this situation arose, but in the current state of the law the college's fear of being sued is reasonable. We may wish that a college would be prepared to accept that risk on behalf of its students to fight for their free speech, but a smaller college may not have the resources to do that.

    In short, we should be reconsidering our current copyright laws rather than blaming this school.

  • May 14th, 2014 @ 12:48pm

    Better late than never

    I have to strongly disagree with two things from this article. First, responding to customer demands is not caving. Second, correcting insanity is something to be lauded.

    Now, Mr. Geigner is quite right to say that these are things that MS should have done a long time ago, but it makes no sense to fault them for finally listening to their customers.

  • Nov 4th, 2013 @ 10:47am

    Re: DRM

    I agree with all of that, but its worth noting that there may be no fiscal cost to avoiding DRM with video games.

  • Jun 27th, 2013 @ 9:58am

    Pandora is great advertising

    Considering that almost all the music I have purchased in the past few years has been found on Pandora or at least an artist I found because of Pandora, I find it surprising that the labels aren't paying them, much as they often pay radio stations, to play more of certain songs or musicians.

  • Jun 19th, 2013 @ 2:57pm

    They listened to consumers

    In this case, it seems that Microsoft listened to its consumers, reacted relatively quickly, and improved their product.

    This seems like a very good thing and Microsoft should be applauded to shifting to a better model and listening to their customers.

  • Jun 18th, 2013 @ 9:14am

    Graphics aren't the only things

    This particular article struck me as a bit melodramatic, yet I agree with all of its core points.

    Chief amoung them for me is that graphics are not what make a game great. I do enjoy good graphics, and they are a factor, but only one amoungst many. The gameplay and story are more important. I played Planescape: Torment fairly recently and it was phenomenal despite the graphics being dated.

  • Jun 12th, 2013 @ 10:27am

    Re: Re:

    Unfortunately, you have a point. And it is a point that should be remembered by consumers.

    With that said, the PS4 currently looks far superior to the XBox in being more consumer friendly and having better hardware as well.

    Given Sony's history, I agree you have a point and we should approach with caution to make sure they stay with it. But for the moment I am happier with their stance than I am with Microsoft's and I have money waiting for PS4 launch day as long as they don't change their policies.

  • Jun 4th, 2013 @ 1:01pm

    It will make it less appealing to buy games

    I buy almost all of my games new, but I also generally resale my games afterwards. That ability is a factor in how much I am willing to pay for a game, especially one that I am unsure of. Especially for a game I am not certain I will enjoy, it is a major factor to know that I can resell it to recover at least some of that money to buy the next game.

    And that is before we get to the fact that them declaring by fiat that I cannot resell really annoys me and I would be more inclined to look at other options with fewer restrictions.

  • May 30th, 2013 @ 3:15pm

    I don't want to be paid for some things

    There are a lot of things I post to the internet that I suspect are useful, including some of the comments I leave on technical message boards and answers to technical questions, that I don't want to get paid for.

    I posted them hoping to help someone, like the person that asked the question, and the most payment I would even want is a "Thanks". I don't want to burden anyone helped by those things with the idea of paying me for them.

  • Apr 29th, 2013 @ 10:53am

    Well said

    I have no problem with advertising as long as it doesn't get in the way of the other content. As you say, I actually like some ads. If the ad is informing me of a solution I didn't know about to a problem I have, it will likely get my attention and possibly my money. The same if the ad is entertaining and funny (my wife bought me the old spice body wash specifically becuase of the ads and still does.)

  • Apr 24th, 2013 @ 10:38am

    TV Depreciation

    This was enlightening and rings intuitively true.

    My one surprise was how fast TV shows depreciate. Now that I have netflix available, I often find shows more interesting after they've been around long enough for friends and community to tell me what is actually worth watching. I just started with Game of Thrones after it has been on for a while, and I find myself enjoying Thundercats when I watch it with my young children. (Far too few good shows that young children can watch that still entertain adults if you ask me.)

  • Apr 18th, 2013 @ 9:33am

    Addding unnecessary online connections is silly

    Well said. When I sign up for a game that is inherently online and must be for a core game component(Magic: The Gathering Online, Star Wars: The Old Republic) I understand that it depends both on company and the community and that doesn't bother me.

    But I detest the idea of adding an online requirement to a single player game. I wanted to buy the new Sim City for my son, but then I found out about the online only component. My son is 7, has one of my previous computers that I fixed for him, and does not have internet access on his computer. So, I bought him Sim City 2000 from GOG instead.

  • Apr 3rd, 2013 @ 9:30am

    You should be able to record.

    I just want to say that I agree 2 party recording laws are silly. I should be able to record any conversation I am part of if I wish to.

  • Dec 20th, 2012 @ 12:18pm

    Most Law Enforcement is Excellent

    "While it would be obvious hyperbole to claim that law enforcement in general is somehow inept or evil,"

    This doesn't go nearly far enough. Most Law Enforcement Officers are honorable and excellent people doing a job which is necessary and for which they don't get enough credit.

  • Dec 13th, 2012 @ 1:48pm


    Perhaps I fit in the "techie" crowd, but I would happily pay more for additional speed.

    I do of course expect the prices to be reasonable, but I said reasonable, not cheap or the same as I am paying now.

  • Nov 30th, 2012 @ 4:26pm

    If it isn't on pandora I probably won't find it

    "Here's where these artists make one of the worst assumptions -- that withholding their music from streaming services will result in a corresponding boost in sales. "

    The vast majority of music that I like I find on pandora, and I buy most of it from Amazon based on the link on Pandora. For most music that fits my taste, if it isn't on Pandora I will probably never know it exists.

  • Nov 30th, 2012 @ 10:49am

    Wrong Question

    "So here's the quick question: which action here was more valuable? Baer's or Bushnell's?"

    No, I do not think that is the right question. That is like asking "Who is more important, the person who lays the foundation for the house, or the electrician that does the wiring?"

    For a modern acceptable house, both are important. Here, both men were needed and both contributed substantially, but in different ways.

More comments from TimothyAWiseman >>