MikeVx’s Techdirt Profile

mikevx

About MikeVx




MikeVx’s Comments comment rss

  • Sep 21st, 2018 @ 4:25pm

    Copyright seems much more likea problem than a solution.

    Setting aside the issue of copies, the primary use of copyright has become the suppression of creativity of the many in the name of profit for a few, as the article gives an example of.

    Another recent example: I had been enjoying Lucas the Spider, and the three parts that managed to get out of Daddy Spider, which I found an amusing spin-off that was going I-don’t-know-where. And now, thanks to asshattery on the part of the creator of Lucas the Spider, I never will find out where Daddy Spider might have gone. This is just one in an innumerable quantity of creative works lost to a system that was ostensibly meant to increase the quantity of human culture. The practical upshot of this is that, on top of the loss of the Daddy Spider story, my enthusiasm for Lucas the Spider has disintegrated. I will hold this against whatever company releases the TV show, if it actually gets that far.

    The “derivative works” portion of copyright law is counter to human culture. Our legends and folk tales evolved by people inventing stories, then others embellishing them or putting completely different spins on them. This is how human culture operates. This is how human culture has operated since we evolved enough intelligence to have culture. This is how our brains are wired. Copyright actually represents an immense impediment to the creative process.

    The number of distinct completely original ideas is vanishingly small. Almost all creative works through human history are derivatives of prior works. This is why they are relevant and interesting. Truly original ideas are slightly rarer than hens teeth, and even then will only be an element added to prior works, in either a general or specific sense.

    For story telling, the modern manifestation of the legend/folktale process is called fan fiction. People with a creative itch to tell a story get ideas based on existing stories, and write/record them. These usually go in a different direction than the original, but sometimes are just similar stories with new elements. Some of these stories end up being better than the original material. In some cases I find interesting fan fiction, and when I backtrack to the “original” work, it turns out to be so dreadful that I cannot figure out how someone could stand to watch/read/listen long enough to have a better (sometimes a much better) treatment of the material. In other cases, fan fiction or other creative transformations have led me back to interesting material I would otherwise never have known about. One example of the latter was an AMV that led me to an interest in a Swedish singer and an anime about a duck, a dance student, and a magic princess, and that’s just one character.

    Both the article and the example I listed above are clear examples of stifled creativity. I could go on, but I have neither the lifespan, nor Techdirt anything like the required storage space, to list even a fraction of the losses.

  • Sep 6th, 2018 @ 7:12pm

    There is a trend here...

    I don't know why anybody would be surprised at this...

    {Insert country music here}
    "'cause United breaks their app"

  • Sep 4th, 2018 @ 5:42pm

    (untitled comment)

    I've never had a vendor fight so hard to not be paid. Do you actually make money off these people?

  • Oct 30th, 2015 @ 12:14pm

    Typo patrol

    Given that one listed homonym is actually not really one (hear/hear), it sounds like someone applauding a point. Perhaps (hear/here) would work better.

    Even accidental approval should be avoided hear. :-)

  • Sep 9th, 2015 @ 8:06pm

    Re: XKCD ref.

    A small boulder won't be able to attempt to control the vehicle if external overrides are used. The operator of the vehicle should be able to ignore any external order, regardless of the "originating authority", otherwise an autonomous vehicle becomes the most effective murder weapon/kidnap aid in the history of history.

    AVs are one place where the use of closed-source proprietary systems should be an automatic life sentence.

  • Apr 8th, 2015 @ 4:47pm

    Finally working, and now I can't even connect to tell them that much.

    Well, after much aggravation on my part, the site finally processed my order. I had just fired off an unsatisfied rating to their follow-up e-mail, now I can't seem to connect to update the rating. Maybe that will start working in a couple of days.

    What a crazy week.

  • Apr 7th, 2015 @ 11:23am

    Re: Re: Re: Re: These offers are extremely sketchy

    First is use Google Chrome. I did try several browsers, Chrome is on my avoid list. This sort of suggestion causes me to wonder about the source of the advice.

    I have also been advised to try different devices and locations. I've tried a PC running Linux and a couple of Android phones. I've used a VPN to appear in the next time zone. I've used the guest network at the office.

    According to the bank that it is easiest to get information from, Stack Social is sending a zero charge through, which the bank approves, but I get a "cannot be processed" error from the web site.

    Is this helpful?

  • Apr 6th, 2015 @ 7:16pm

    Re: Re: These offers are extremely sketchy

    You've managed to purchase some yourself? How did you manage that? I keep getting payment failures, and the suggestions I get for fixing the problem tell me that either the staff operating this thing don't know how payment systems work, or that the payment processor does not know how payment systems work. (3 different cards used, errors in all cases.)

    The failure of these people to be able to complete a sale is what is going to reflect badly on Techdirt.

    I'm going to be annoyed if I can't get the 2015 Code course.

  • Mar 29th, 2015 @ 11:24am

    Well, it looks like I can't get the course.

    Surprisingly, I got a response to my request for support.

    I don't like to say things like this, but the sender had no clue whatever how payment systems work. I was being told to try different browsers, different locations, and other irrelevant things. I found that the company was sending zero-charge transactions to the banks. Many banks will error out on that, and there is nothing I can do about it.

    I was told that if all else fails, Use PayPal.

    That is about as nasty as you can get.

    The value on the courses is enough that I was even willing to compromise a credit card by running a transaction, then change the number later, but PayPal was requiring me to create an account with them to complete the transaction.

    A universe of no.

    The state of online payment systems appears to be deteriorating, rather than improving.

  • Mar 27th, 2015 @ 8:24pm

    Neat if it would take my money.

    I've discovered a problem with the payment system in the deals section. It will not accept any card number I give it. I've sent a message to support, but since they only operate M-F 9-5, the deal on the charging system will expire before they can look into it. The code courses will be neat, if I can get them.

    In an internet-enabled world, bankers hours support is not a good thing.

  • Dec 11th, 2014 @ 3:58pm

    Defending the indefensible

    If a business depends on advertising, at either end of the process, the model is not so much broken as disintegrated.

    If ads ever had any legitimacy, that is no longer the case. Anything people might want to learn about in the way of products and services can be found via any decent search engine. If you feel the need to shove your product into my face, that tells me you don't think it capable of standing on merits. If you don't think much of it, why should I?

  • Nov 24th, 2014 @ 8:43pm

    At long last!

    I've been crabbing for a decade or so that encrypted traffic should be the only option, it's nice to see the net finally starting to get to where it should have been long ago.

  • Aug 21st, 2013 @ 8:20pm

    One fast way for this to go south...

    If they file a complaint against Sailor Moon projects for the use of "Sailor Scouts".

    I don't think there's enough legal power in the world to protect the BSA from a continent or three of pissed-off anime fans.

    Some people might think I'm kidding, but the fastest growth in genre conventions right now is in Anime, and a few conventions making a policy of "if the BSA has been there, we won't be" could limit the BSAs activities exclusively to forests and campsites, as the hotels don't want to be on the black lists of single events that need 3 or more hotels plus a convention center for what constitutes a "sparsely-attended" event.

  • Aug 8th, 2013 @ 3:15pm

    Re: Re: Alternatives to lavabit.com?

    Clicked link, got blank page. Can't capture much from that, at least.

  • Apr 9th, 2013 @ 6:17pm

    This is nothing new...

    Many years ago, I got a call from Comcast, the rep was raving about the new service levels and features being made available. I interrupted the rep and asked:

    "So when is Americast rolling out service?"

    [several awkward seconds of silence]

    "Three months."

    Americast was what is now WOW, unless they have changed hands and I haven't noticed. I had some incidents of being billed by them when I didn't even have service, and they wouldn't talk to me.

    The point is that there is nothing new in service improving only when competitors exist. I went with Americast at the time because it was a better deal.

    Some years later I cut the cord because logos had contaminated TV everywhere and TV service had ceased to have value.

  • Apr 5th, 2013 @ 9:28am

    Raises hand.

    Hand, foot, eyebrows, blood pressure. :-)

    Actually, that last is going down because I don't have to deal with web screens that are more garbage than anything else. I've seen what the web looks like on non-blocked computers, how can people stand it, and how can the data overages not destroy them from the ads being 90+% of the page data?

    Ad blocking is just simple security practice. Aside from ads being a form of fraud in and of themselves, ad networks are infested with malware to an insane degree. If I service a computer, an ad blocker is mandatory, you are getting at least one, or I will not waste my time trying to fix your system.

    Since Google has placed their revenue over the security of their users, root your Android device, find F-Droid, get Ad-Away, update every now and then.

  • Mar 7th, 2013 @ 9:02pm

    Interface choices

    I have been using Xfce on Slackware for the past decade or three. The infestation is felt even there as the clutter level goes up with each new release.

    For all the faults of Windows 7 (a complete description of which would consume more storage than there is mass in the universe), it is at least usable (for very forgiving uses of the term) for several things at once, if given absurd quantities of resources.

    I will push any device or system to the edge, but the previews of Windows 8 were so utterly useless that I actually gave up on it completely. I can get more productivity out of 3.1. Heck, I can get more productivity out of DOS 5.whatever and a copy of DESQview. I actually did that back in the day.

    While they've given up this time, I expect that the issue of pay-us-forever will continue to to creep along until there is no pay-once software from Microsoft.

    One of many reasons why I use Linux for most of my doings, and only use Windows (carefully locked away in virtual machines for my own system) for device synchronization or when people pay me to work with it.

  • Jan 11th, 2013 @ 4:13pm

    The definition of "Unfair Competition"

    Competition is always unfair when you are the loser.

  • Dec 6th, 2012 @ 6:05pm

    Re: Re: Extreme Making Up Words.

    Thanks. I've actually told the author that there was some overlap on the Sniglets audience into his sort of craziness. He thinks this is a totally different target. We'll see.

    The title is:

    Goofilinguage - A Collection of Very Silly Words by Bruce Jaffe.

    At the moment, only on Amazon, other outlets being worked on.

  • Dec 5th, 2012 @ 7:54pm

    Extreme Making Up Words.

    A friend of mine has gone on an extreme kick of making up silly words with sillier definitions and has even published them in an e-book dictionary. He's trying the tactic of promoting on Facebook with iffy results.

    I'm not sure if it would be appropriate to name it here (I'll check back later for comments) but I will say that if you are curious, visiting a popular sales site named for a large river and searching on "very silly words" makes it easy to find. Getting it on other e-book sites is being worked on, but if nothing has gone wrong, there is no DRM to interfere with migrating it to your choice of reader. I was able to convince the author that irritating your customer base was not a great idea.

    So far the CwF is going well, the RtB, not so much, but this is an experiment. Whether it works or not, we'll find out.

More comments from MikeVx >>