Thu, Jul 12th 2007 12:02pm
Sony BMG settled both the class-action lawsuit against it and with the FTC, after it distributed rootkits that opened up security holes on consumers' PCs in the copy protection it used on its CDs. Now the company's filed a suit of its own against Amergence, formerly known as SunnComm, and its MediaMax unit, which supplied one of the pieces of copy-protection software in question. The lawsuit alleges Amergence/SunnComm supplied Sony BMG with faulty software -- which, all things considered, seems true. But the bigger issue here is that Sony BMG is implying that none of this mess is its fault, when it's the one that felt the need to implement the DRM in the first place. As we've pointed out plenty of times, DRM doesn't stop piracy, it just annoys legitimate customers. The SunnComm and XCP copy-protection that Sony BMG implemented on its CDs didn't stop piracy, and it wouldn't have, even if it hadn't been "faulty", as the suit alleges. It created a huge PR mess for the company, and it's cost them a fair bit of money to clean things up. Getting $12 million from Amergence won't change the fact that deciding to put the DRM on its CDs was a bonehead move that never would have delivered any real benefits.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- Continued Disagreement And Confusion Over Yahoo Email Scanning
- Musician Demands Google, Major Labels Pay Him $325 Million For Removing Videos He Paid $30 To Upload To Vevo
- Thought Komodia/Superfish Bug Was Really, Really Bad? It's Much, Much Worse!
- Ubisoft DRM Fiasco: Allows Any Website To Take Control Of Your Computer
- Wal-Mart Ditches DRM... And Lots Of Major Label Music With It