Hey Elon: You Don’t Just ‘Ooopsie’ The Destruction Of Ebola Prevention

from the global-health-isn't-a-botched-twitter-feature-launch-you-can-roll-back dept

Look, sometimes you make mistakes. Maybe you send an email to the wrong person. Maybe you accidentally buy the wrong kind of pasta sauce at the grocery store. Maybe you accidentally dismantle critical global health infrastructure. These things happen! At least, that’s what Elon Musk wants us to believe.

At yesterday’s first official Musk/Trump administration cabinet meeting, Elon decided to share a cute little anecdote about his DOGE team’s approach to governing. Just a fun little story about how they “accidentally canceled” Ebola prevention efforts. What a knee slapper!

Elon Musk: "We will make mistakes. We won't be perfect … so for example, with USAID, one of the things we accidentally canceled very briefly was ebola prevention."

Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) 2025-02-26T16:56:46.666Z

Here’s Musk’s exact quote, which deserves to be read in full because, well, you’ll see:

We will make mistakes. We won’t be perfect. But when we make mistakes, we’ll fix it very quickly. So, for example, with USAID, one of the things we accidentally canceled very briefly was Ebola prevention. [nervous chuckle] I think we all want Ebola prevention. So we restored Ebola prevention immediately and there was no interruption.

The only problem is that almost everything here is nonsense… well, except for the part about canceling the program on Ebola prevention. Musk absolutely did that. And some other terrible stuff as well. But the fixing the mistake part? That doesn’t appear to have actually happened. Oopsie!

[Nervous chuckle intensifies]

The Real Impact of “Accidental” Cuts

To be clear, this one scenario actually offers a really good case study in how dangerously short-sighted the Musk/DOGE efforts are, in which they have no clue what they’re doing, are slashing and burning, and figuring they can just “fix it very quickly after” when things go wrong.

Except, that’s often not how this works, and the things they’re doing are creating not just lasting damage, but real-time harms that can never be fixed.

So, first of all, they absolutely cut off Ebola prevention and it had real world consequences the day they did, because there was an Ebola outbreak reported in Uganda that very day. As Ebola expert (and survivor!) Dr. Craig Spencer explained, normally the US would send an Ebola expert to Uganda to help with the prevention, which they were unable to do, because Musk and DOGE basically made that impossible. Spencer’s explanation of what happened is maddening (this is just a snippet):

On January 29, Uganda reported an Ebola outbreak. Normally the U.S. would’ve very quickly sent one of our Ebola experts to help the response. But this time, we didn’t. Because we couldn’t. Because this administration wouldn’t let them go right when this outbreak was declared.

And normally the U.S. would’ve helped set up border screening and other measures on the ground.

But this time, we didn’t.

Normally, we would’ve spoke with the WHO about helping end the outbreak.

But this time, we didn’t.

Because CDC staff weren’t even allowed to talk to them.

I’ve been told by a colleague that Uganda tried calling the White House to notify them of the outbreak for 2 days…but no one answered the phone. Two months ago we had amazing experts working on global health security there. Now there appears to be no one to pick up a phone.

Lies About ‘Fixing’ Those Mistakes

It turns out that Elon and DOGE actually fired 90% of the team working on it. Which raises an interesting question: How exactly do you “turn on” Ebola prevention when you’ve fired all the people who… you know… prevent Ebola?

“There have been no efforts to ‘turn on’ anything in prevention” of Ebola and other diseases, said Nidhi Bouri, who served as a senior USAID official during the Biden administration and oversaw the agency’s response to health-care outbreaks.

[….]

Bouri said her former USAID team of 60 people working on disease-response had been cut to about six staffers as of earlier this week. She called the recent USAID response to Uganda’s Ebola outbreak a “one-off,” far diminished from “the full suite” of activities that the agency historically would mount, such as ramping up efforts to monitor whether the disease had spread to neighboring countries.

“The full spectrum — the investments in disease surveillance, the investments in what we mobilize … moving commodities, supporting lab workers — that capacity is now a tenth of what it was,” Bouri said.

Furthermore, contrary to Elon’s claim, it appears that the funds for Ebola prevention have not resumed at all:

Other current and former USAID officials, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss internal operations, agreed with Bouri’s assessment.

“There was a waiver for Ebola, but USAID funds have never been back online,” said a current official. “USAID has been frozen: staff and money.”

“If there was a need to respond to Ebola, it would be a disaster assistance response team, or DART,” said one former official. “There is no longer a capability to send a DART or support one from Washington. Many of those people are contractors who were let go at the very beginning.”

This should be terrifying. Even if you’re so myopic that you think “America First” means not doing any foreign aid work (and boy, is that a discussion for another day), surely you can recognize that preventing foreign outbreaks of deadly diseases helps protect Americans at home as well. Right? Right???

A Pattern of Destruction

And the Ebola example is just one example.

There have been multiple reports of how the DOGE team halted funding for PEPFAR, which is the “President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief,” started by George W. Bush that has been credited with saving over 26 million lives and limiting the spread of AIDS globally. But DOGE stopped the program.

In Africa, thousands of U.S.-funded health workers have been laid off and clinics have closed, restricting access to HIV testing and treatment. African health officials and experts have pleaded for PEPFAR to resume, fearing services that have become a key part of the health care system will be stripped in a way that sets countries back decades.

And even though Marco Rubio has promoted PEPFAR and claimed that he signed a limited waiver to keep some (not all) of it funded… reports are that the DOGE team has still blocked any PEPFAR funding from going through. As the AP reports:

“…aid groups say they know of no payments getting through for that or any program.”

And even though a court ordered USAID to continue its congressionally mandated funding efforts two weeks ago, the Musk/Trump administration has refused to do so. Yesterday, after the judge made it clear that they were walking into a contempt of court situation, the DOJ ran to the Supreme Court, which put a temporary pause on the order, giving the Court a couple more days to evaluate.

Meanwhile, people are dying. Right now. Today. While Elon and his DOGE crew chuckle about their “accidental” mistakes (all easily preventable if they hadn’t fired actual experts or just… asked people to explain what was happening), and then claimed they “immediately” fixed things they didn’t actually fix.

And we could easily go on. I mean, last week they “accidentally” fired all the experts working to prevent avian flu and then were scrambling to try to find them to rehire them. Because nothing says “competent governance” and “efficiency” quite like firing your bird flu experts in the middle of a bird flu outbreak, and then struggling to find the fired experts in order to beg them to come back.

It seems like everywhere you look, these kinds of “accidental” mistakes are being made, and they’re not being rectified.

But Elon and the DOGE crew think it’s all just a laugh.

It’s Not Just The Incompetence, It’s The Indifference

Here’s the thing about all of this: None of it had to happen. None of these “accidents” were inevitable. Even if you wanted to cut actual waste, fraud, and abuse (and who doesn’t?), there are ways to do that without, you know, accidentally dismantling global disease prevention infrastructure.

But there’s no interest from Musk or DOGE in figuring any of that out. Zero. Zilch. Nada. There’s not even a pretense of concern about the irreversible damage being done.

Not only do they have a total lack of intellectual curiosity to learn about the institutions and systems they’re destroying, there’s not even one bit of concern about the very real damage that has been done and can’t be fixed, even if they actually were turning back on the funding (which, again, it appears they’re not).

There are a million stories to be covering these days about all this, but this is a tragedy of epic proportions. And the only acknowledgment of it is a little giggle from Elon, in which he admits to just one part of the error, but falsely states they corrected it. Because apparently that’s where we are now: treating global health infrastructure like it’s a Twitter feature that can be rolled back with a quick deployment.

The real tragedy isn’t just the destruction of vital programs — it’s that lives are being treated as acceptable collateral damage in an ideological experiment, based off of a myth. Musk, DOGE, and the Project 2025 crew are completely bought into the false belief that federal government employees do nothing useful, that they don’t work, and almost all foreign aid is wasted.

When global health infrastructure built over decades is dismantled overnight, it can’t simply be restored with a presidential waiver or a tweet. What’s being lost here isn’t just money or bureaucracy, but institutional knowledge, relationships, and capacity that took years to build. And Musk shows no signs of learning this lesson at all. To him, it remains a joke and a meme to tweet. As people die.

Filed Under: , , , , , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Hey Elon: You Don’t Just ‘Ooopsie’ The Destruction Of Ebola Prevention”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
48 Comments
This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Anonymous Coward says:

Permanent, irreversible damage

When you throw those people out, this is not readily reversible. There’s no latent market of Ebola experts in the free market and private sector. World governments make these experts and are the only entities that have them.

In addition to the time window and lost opportunities (because viral outbreaks, to use a product term, are a one-way door), when these people are booted out of their offices, even if you could hire them back, typically much of their work product is also lost. Servers shut down, offices vacated, etc. Even if it is technically retained somewhere, with no owner, the knowledge and documents are not findable or accessible, very often, and especially when the situation is unplanned with no transition.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
That One Guy (profile) says:

Re: Re: 'Always just one temper-tantrum away from being fired? Sign me up!'

‘You want me to come back to work for the sort of person and administration that would fire the people responsible for stopping and preventing deadly diseases, and who have a demonstrable track record of erratic and spiteful behavior that would mean I and everyone else under their employ would be constantly in a high-stress situation wondering whether they’ll decided to can half or all of us again on a whim or because we said something they didn’t like?

Yeah, I think I’ll pass on that. Good luck finding some gullible sucker to take my place.’

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: Re:

Hopefully most of those people are able to go work for another government (or even private entity) who values their work and will provide the stability needed to do the jobs they used to do.

Maybe Canada and Germany will become the new leaders in epidemic response?

Anonymous Coward says:

Re: Re: Re:2

Hopefully most of those people are able to go work for another government (or even private entity) who values their work and will provide the stability needed to do the jobs they used to do.

Alternately, I figure there’s a good chance one could milk the instability by filing wrongful termination suits. Get your back-pay, get re-hired, wait till you get fired again for no fucking reason

A question for Americans who still see television commercials: have the lawyer advertisements for the Trump/Musk firings started yet? It could be the biggest opportunity since mesothelioma.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
That One Guy (profile) says:

Re:

When you throw those people out, this is not readily reversible. There’s no latent market of Ebola experts in the free market and private sector. World governments make these experts and are the only entities that have them.

Were I one of the higher-ups in other said world governments I would make it a high priority to be making job offers to these sorts of people to snap them up for my own government as soon as I found out they were fired.

Not only would that allow my government to snag a highly trained and experienced medical professional who just go stabbed in the back by their own government but it would also be a potential PR goldmine as my government could boast about picking up the slack after the USG decided that pandemic prevention and mitigation wasn’t worth it.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Bloof (profile) says:

The goal is to break as much as he can as fast as he can because he does not want government to function at all, citing ‘useless’ programs to justify cutting the useful stuff. The problem is even the most bloody minded of republican voters know that abolishing things like Ebola prevention is mindbogglingly stupid and will lead to more questions being asked about the other things being killed. Elon may be tonedeaf enough to not realise this, but people without billions to fall back on do and have just enough power to make him backtrack… for now at least.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Stephen T. Stone (profile) says:

Re:

he does not want government to function at all

And the reasons are twofold:

  1. He wants to get rid of any regulations (and regulators) that might hamper his businesses and/or business interests⁠—like, say, demanding the FAA use Starlink instead of Verizon for air traffic control systems.
  2. Like many rich right-wingers, he wants as much of the government as possible to be privatized so he (and those other rich bastards) can profit from privatization even as it would provably make those once-public services much worse.
This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Bloof (profile) says:

Re: Re:

There is little doubt in my mind that 40-50% of what he slashes and the contracts he breaks will result in his companies being given more expensive contracts to replace them, even though his companies don’t have any experience in those fields. He’ll end up hiring a lot of the people he laid off in places with no protections for employees, for a fraction of what the living wage they would have been paid by government, while the republicans sandbag any Democrat president to make sure the corruption cannot be overturned or undone.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Narcissus (profile) says:

Re: Will it come back to bite them?

The Nobel prize for economy was recently awarded to 3 guys that did research on failed states. While it is hard to define how to build a succesful nation, some prerequisites are:
– Reliable institutions (judiciary, but also press)
– Rule of law (minimal corruption)
– Stable Government
– Proper access to Health care and education
Without these the nation will certainly fail.

Trump and his cronies are working on destroying all of that, insofar as it existed (healthcare). So, how long until the US will become a failed state?

So, all the techbros and other greedy billionaires might find that their main market has devolved into chaos. Not exactly helpful for the business model. They might also find out that Europe is becoming more and more hostile to them, whihc might impact them even if the US market doesn’t collapse. The EU press and assorted governments are already describing the US as an unreliable partner and, potentially, and enemy.

Signals of a growing anti-Americanism are showing already. Despite a growing marketshare of EVs, Tesla sales dropped >50%. I also saw a news item describing how to move from WhatsApp to Signal. Additionally, even though most countries are planning to increase defense spending, all of them are also thinking about how to keep that spending in Europe. Nobody wants to buy from a country that might be our enemy in a couple of years. So, the US defense industry stands to lose a lot of customers.

I, as a middle-aged European, am sad to see this. Yes, we always considered our American brothers as a bit wayward, with their guns, expensive healthcare and bad food. However, they were always considered as being on the same side.

Stability in the world is not improving.

Tanner Andrews (profile) says:

Re: not exactly backtracking

Elon may be tonedeaf enough to not realise this, but people without billions to fall back on do and have just enough power to make him backtrack… for now at least.

Close. There is enough opposition power to make Elmo announce that he is backtracking and restoring ebola response. That is similar but not identical to actually backtracking and restoring ebola response.

Anonymous Coward says:

Re:

And we can all be thankful that Trump hasn’t been re-elected in 2020 during Covid-19, because 90% of us would not have seen the end of 2021.

Trump was in power during the most dangerous part of the pandemic, and did actually endorse the vaccine. By the time Biden’s term began, the most vulnerable people were already being vaccinated. That was despite Trump’s general down-playing of the COVID-19 risk, which probably cost many thousands of lives but somehow did not hurt the later re-election campaign.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Justinfinity (profile) says:

Isn’t doing unnessecary things, and especially undoing them, pretty much the easiest “inefficiency” to get rid of?

One step [obstenibly] forward, onto a rake, two steps back, now with a bloody nose that needs [potentially expensive] repair.

It’s basically “measure twice, cut once”, and he somehow can’t even do that correctly. He’d rather “cut a hundred times, and then waste time and money to glue it back together and/or find replacements”.

This ignorant quest for rooting out “inefficiency” is one of the most wildly inefficient things to ever exist. Did anyone vote for this?

Anonymous Coward says:

The problem is when you sack highly qualified trained staff it’s hard to replace them doge are reckless incompetent and literally don’t know what they are doing reducing staff and aid to organizations that prevent the spread of deadly disease is not saving money meanwhile more people die and Americans are at risk of disease
Usaid also helped to stop disease provided medical aid and help to stabilize economys that were at least friendly to American interests .they also cut firefighting staff which is ridiculous after the worst fires in American history last year .
Doge is short term in the long term it makes not even save money as disease spreads and fires cause more damage due to lack of resources

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
That One Guy (profile) says:

Elon/Trump: Hey, those tax-cuts to billionaires need to be paid for somehow!

And even though a court ordered USAID to continue its congressionally mandated funding efforts two weeks ago, the Musk/Trump administration has refused to do so. Yesterday, after the judge made it clear that they were walking into a contempt of court situation, the DOJ ran to the Supreme Court, which put a temporary pause on the order, giving the Court a couple more days to evaluate.

Just let that one sink in for a moment.

A court ordered the administration to get an agency to do it’s congressionally mandated job and they refused. When the court mentioned the very obvious contempt of court they were engaging in the DOJ ran like tattling children to the Supreme Court and they put a hold on the ‘Do your damn job’ order for the lower court to ‘evaluate’ the situation(read: stop thinking that the WH is bound by the courts).

And all the while the same party that never stopped screeching about how the Biden administration was constantly engaging in government overreach is either conspicuously silent or clapping and cheering their Dear Leader on…

Anonymous Coward says:

So they make cuts sack staff then if they get negative feedback or make obvious errors they maybe rehire people they fire last week doge staff Are inexperienced and very young how can they understand that sacking experienced staff whose job is to stop the spread of deadly disease in country’s with only basic medical healthcare might be a bad idea
They look at programs spreadsheets oh look if we fire 50 percent of staff we can save my money
This is a nightmare complex medical healthcare systems and agencys that provide emergency services are being taken apart by
people who are hardly qualified to drive a car
This would be funny if it were not so serious

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
Darkness Of Course (profile) says:

What Musk and the Convict has wraught

To those outside the USA – Do not count on the USA again. No treaty is safe. No agreement is safe. Nothing is safe from the whims of fascists

To those in the USA – If you’re rich, good for you. Everyone else, is gonna get screwed sooner or later. The poorer you are, the further down the totem pole the worse it is going to be

They are killing Medicare/Medicade
They want to steal the funds that Social Security has acquired. Because it is in Trillions
They want to privatize it. Just like our healthcare is: You know, like United Healthcare

Ehud Gavron (profile) says:

DOGGIE and stuff

I loved my DOGGIE but he died 21 years ago and I still haven’t been able to replace him. Those of you who have DOGGIEs will understand. Those of you with kids, pretend I said “YOUR KIDs”. But a rabid beast needs to be put down. Trump and Musk have shown their disease.
18USC871 suggest we simply vote them out of office.

The real tragedy …

I was taught that a tragedy had certain elements. Aristotle’s version (outdated) https://library.fiveable.me/classical-poetics/unit-6/aristotles-elements-tragedy-significance/study-guide/kyY6HFLWp95oqyAo suggested we needed song and a plot.

Tragedy requires a tragic hero. This is the person you like; bad things happen; they learn; they survive. Our entire US society is not that thing.

Then there’s a thought and a plot. If the doggies knew what they were doing there would be something like that. Instead they are Clancy Brown (awesome dude) as The Kurgan. Slash and cut and burn.

No song.

Spectacle. Yes, quite.

It’s not a tragedy as much as a disaster. Is it a “horrible disaster that shouldn’t ever happen let alone be continuing as we look on in horror”? Yes.

How do we correct this imbalance in the time/space continuum?

E

dickeyrat says:

AS IF?? As if Muskrat could EVEN give a fat fuck?? “Consequences” are for other people; Elon’s the richest fuck in the world. He can AFFORD to care not! Besides, it all just might provide a juicy opportunity for Elon to privatize the entire situation. Coming up: “Cure-X”. And “Little X-AI”, or whatever his name is, will wipe his oysters wherever he damn well pleases! (And to think some say God has no sense of humor!)

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get all our posts in your inbox with the Techdirt Daily Newsletter!

We don’t spam. Read our privacy policy for more info.

Ctrl-Alt-Speech

A weekly news podcast from
Mike Masnick & Ben Whitelaw

Subscribe now to Ctrl-Alt-Speech »
Techdirt Deals
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...