Back when the Sony rootkit fiasco hit, some people noticed the irony that this product Sony kept insisting was designed to "protect" intellectual property was actually making unauthorized use of some open source code, and not abiding by the license the software was released under. Now, Digg points out that DVD Jon, the author of some of the code being used (extra amusing, since the his claim to fame is breaking copy protection and getting sued by the entertainment industry), has discovered it doesn't really make sense to sue Sony BMG, because the work isn't registered at the Copyright Office. The code is covered by copyright, but the law says you can only go after statutory damages (basically above the nominal damages) if it's registered. Secondly, it's difficult to prove what those nominal damages are -- especially since the code was GPL'd. Basically, there aren't really any nominal damages. The only way to get money is to go for statutory damages -- and you can't do that without a registered copyright. If Sony BMG were still using the software, then he could sue to get them to stop -- but since they've officially stopped (even if they're still widely available) there just isn't that much to be gained in a lawsuit. So, basically, there's almost no remedy for him under the law -- making it pretty pointless to sue at this point, no matter how amusing the resulting lawsuit would have been.
If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...
- Feds To FISC: Of Course We Don't Have To Share Our Full Legal Filings With Companies Suing Us Over NSA Transparency
- Kansas City Cops Tell Man They'll Kill His Dogs And Destroy His Home If Forced To Obtain A Search Warrant
- Most Big Internet Companies Speak Out For Major Surveillance Reform
- Witness In No Fly List Trial, Who Was Blocked From Flying To The Trial, Shows That DOJ Flat Out Lied In Court
- Feds Insist It Must Be Kept Secret Whether Or Not Plaintiff In No Fly List Trial Is Actually On The No Fly List